Social Justice Warrior
The Switch: 3 Classic Characters That Should Be Gender Swapped

Ross Lincoln | 10 Jul 2014 19:00
Social Justice Warrior - RSS 2.0
punisher

The Punisher

My favorite portrayal of Wonder Woman is in DC's New Frontier miniseries, in which she disappears after being sent by the US President to 'Indochina' (Implied to be Vietnam) during the 1950s. Superman eventually finds her, where he discovers to his shock that after she helped a village of women defend themselves against what amounts to a guerilla rape-gang, she also allowed them to exact bloody revenge on their attackers. It's a perfect inversion of what we usually think of as the "natural" way women behave.

In popular culture, vengeance and punitive justice are concepts that are generally treated as inherently male. Yes, of course there are a great many female superheroes, but with rare exceptions, like New Frontier's version of Wonder Woman, female superheroes tend to be softer, more reasonable, never really scary. Those heroes who, like Batman, Nexus, Judge Dredd and so forth, exist (at least in part) as personifications of justice, punishment, and avenging-of-victims, are always men*. Nowhere is this more true than with The Punisher, a character who is not only the anthropomorphic embodiment of capital justice, but also of male power-and-revenge fantasies.

He is, after all, inspired to wage his one-man war on crime after his wife and children are brutally murdered by mobsters. It's a classic NOW IT IS PERSONAL story beat, one we've seen in countless movies, books, tv shows and, yes, many other comics. But while I would never discount the trauma and horror experienced by those who have lost their families to horrific crimes, what about giving some time to female power revenge fantasies? There are, in fact, a range of horrors, including sexual assault, robbery, and violent attack, from which women make up the vast majority of victims. Many women survive these crimes and, theoretically, live on to be more than simply inspiration for their male friends and family to kick ass. Which is to say, the actual victims of horrific crimes would have equal motivation, if not more so, to be obsessed with payback.

But reinventing The Punisher as woman would not only provide new layers to explore, particularly if such a series took into account the disproportionate rate at which women are the victims of crime. It would also - if films like I Spit On Your Grave are any indication, at least - make the justice she exacts even more terrifying and cathartic than the series, at its best, has managed.

* I realize that there are female Judges in the Dredd universe, but I am speaking of the character himself.

catwoman

Catwoman

Ok, Ok, I can hear what you're saying. The character is called Catwoman. Fine, yes, I get that, and dealing with that name will be a problem for anyone attempting to gender-swap her. But hear me out.

For some reason, we as a culture see cats as inherently female. Hell, we even have sexual slang inspired by that bias. This might be because cats are lithe, agile, slinky, and frankly, always look like they're in their coolest and most stylish clothing, and we see ideas like "sexiness," "stylishness," and "playfulness" as concepts that can only properly be portrayed via women. Certainly, it's absolutely true that when men are depicted as sexy, stylish and playful, it's generally played for laughs.

Further, those qualities when applied to male characters are most often used to make them seem unmanly, and gives the audience visual clues that they're not to be trusted. (The homophobic overtones of this cannot be ignored. See The Joker in The Dark Knight Returns, or hell, see like all of Western civilization until about 10 minutes ago.) Obviously, Catwoman is a villain, which makes her by default untrustworthy. But her sex appeal, stylishness and playful demeanor are, as often as not, used not to compound her villainy but to increase her moral ambiguity. She is therefore complex enough that her constant teetering on the edge between bad guy and good guy seems credible.

Imagine, however, if she were a man. Flirtatious, with form fitting clothing that emphasizes secondary sex characteristics, lithe, morally ambiguous, and working as a dashing burglar. Admit it, just contemplating this is making you somewhat uncomfortable, isn't it?

And why is this? Because you almost never see a portrayal of such a character who isn't either a joke, or an evil gay man. But it doesn't have to be that way. Now, I admit this suggestion is somewhat social-sciencey. I am as interested in the experiment of trying to portray a traditionally female character as male, simply to force people to think outside of our default sexual paradigms, as I am in the idea that a male Catwoman would make an interesting character in his own right. But rest assured, he would.

Think the gentleman thief, reimagined with an animal motif, morally ambiguous and constantly flirting with the hero. Obviously, not Batman in this instance. But such a figure could at least have an uneasy frenemies relationship with the Caped Crusdader, while flirting shameless with other characters on both sides of the law/crime divide. Plus, it would not only give readers (and lazy writers like myself) plenty to discuss, it would also vastly expand the opportunities for blatant sex appeal for more than just dude comic readers. Hell, base the characterization on John Barrowman's Jack Harkness and you're there.

And if the result is that it helped a lot of us pull the stick out of our asses just a bit, that'd be a bonus.

RELATED CONTENT
Comments on