View From the Road

A View From the Road: Cut/Scene

John Funk | 17 Aug 2009 21:00
View From the Road - RSS 2.0
image

"Cutscenes are obsolete."

This would be my coworker Jordan Deam speaking on the ride home from a concert. When asked why, he elaborated: To him, cutscenes just take you out of the game. You can't interact with them, and it's essentially just watching a movie - a (relatively) poorly-written-and-acted movie. Storytelling in games, he thinks, has moved beyond these static cutscenes - just look at Portal, which manages to communicate an interesting plot without ever taking you out of its first-person perspective or bashing you over the head with a cutscene.

Maybe he has something of a point. Many games these days are all about letting the player tell their own story. Two titles that come to mind representing this "vanguard" of storytelling are Mass Effect 2 and Heavy Rain, both of which allow you to choose actions in real-time during cutscenes, the results of which alter the plot and making it more of an unique experience defined by the player. Don't like the informant giving you lip? Shove him out a window. That's if they necessarily force players to advance the story at all - you could just chill in the worlds of GTA4, Fallout 3, Oblivion, or any other of these open-ended worlds all day and do what you like, cutscenes and storyline be damned.

But as single-player games move away from the age of the cutscene, MMOGs are going the opposite direction. If the cutscene is obsolete, why was it so fascinating to see a story driven by cinematics when I took a look at Aion a couple of weeks ago? Aion wasn't the first MMOG I'd seen in recent memory to feature a cutscene, either - at the end of a long quest chain in Wrath of the Lich King's Northrend, you're rewarded with an epic scene depicting the battle at the Wrathgate. The Wrathgate event is considered by many to be WotLK's own Crowning Moment of Awesome.

Mass Effect 2 and Heavy Rain promise that the player will be able to tell his own story. But in the online space, gamers have been doing that since the days of Ultima Online and EverQuest, and those games had infinitely more stories than even the talented writers at BioWare or Quantic Dream could have ever imagined. In some sense, MMOGs have always been about letting the player tell the story he or she wanted to: Maybe you're a heroic Paladin seeking to rescue the downtrodden, maybe you're a nefarious Rogue looking to make a quick buck... or maybe your Paladin is a Knight Templar who thinks he's more righteous than he actually is. Maybe your Rogue robs from the rich and gives to the poor.

Meanwhile, single-player games have offered a directed story ever since some developer thought "hey, maybe it'd be cool to give our hero a reason to be slicing through the bad guys." It doesn't matter how much the player wants Cloud to become a world-renowned sword-motorcycle-racing champion, because he needs to go get his ass in gear and track down Sephiroth, he's not getting back into Midgar until Disc 2, and - oh yeah - he probably shouldn't spend too much time leveling up Aeris anyway. You're going to play the plot as it's written, dammit!

RELATED CONTENT
Comments on