Topic Index
The Third Batman Film in the Nolanverse *SPOILERS*

Username:Password:
Log In
 (Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6)
juandonde
Pulitzer Laureate
Posts: 711
Joined: 14 May 2008

Indigo_Dingo:
While true, none of those had a sequel that far outdid the original, and was easily considered the best movie of the year, and best Superhero movie ever, hands down. We are dealing with a unique phenomena here.

Superman 2, X-men 2, Spiderman 2 all were better than the first one. Not saying that the third one will be bad, there is always a chance it could be good. Also consider that the rule of trilogy's applies to just almost any trilogy out there (except Return of the King). So unless Nolan pulls a Peter Jackson and makes the third movie holy shit good, it will probably go the way that Aliens 3 did, and we don't want any franchise to go the way aliens 3 did...

EDIT: Also since people either didn't pay attention or haven't seen the movie I am just going to say it SPOILERs be damned two face dies in dark knight SPOILERS OVER.

Indigo_Dingo
Gone Gonzo
Posts: 4744
Joined: 30 Jan 2008

Abako:

Indigo_Dingo:

Abako:
I hate robin. Always have since the phrase Jiminy-Jillickers Batman! (spelling?)

Wasn't that Fallout Boy?

I have no clue as I detest Fallout Boy. Maybe it is and I heard that from a friend but that phrase just sticks in my head. I hated all of robins little 'Holy shit'-esque phrases

No, as in the Character of Fallout Boy from the Simpsons.

Stammer
Infamous Scribbler
Posts: 667
Joined: 16 Apr 2008

7dollarbill:
I figured it was gonna be Two-face.

Well, I thought he died. Even if he didn't die, he'd be in jail big time for what he did to Gordon's family.

DeadlyYellow
Beat Writer
Posts: 148
Joined: 18 Jun 2008

Heard on the round-abouts that Bale wouldn't do a Robin film.

Anyway, I say this a lot for potential Batman villains and most of those who read the books would agree.

Hush.

Although I love the idea of Clayface.

HobbesMkii
Beat Writer
Posts: 172
Joined: 7 Jun 2008

Bane would be perfect. I know people are afraid of using characters from the Michael Keaton - Val Kilmer - George Clooney series, but screw that, Nolan isn't.

It should be Bane and Black Mask vs Batman. And it shouldn't be Robin, it should Batgirl. Introduce Barbara Gordon. It could work very easily, I think, just have her come back from college or university or whatever, and be inspired by Batman and her Father. Bane should definitely break the Bat, which forces him to rely on Batgirl, overcoming any earlier opposition to her aid (and teaching him that Batman can't always work alone, something already known to the comics).

Also, it sets up nicely a fourth film, in which you could introduce Harley Quinn and the Joker again (now given a suitable waiting period following Ledger's death for a new actor to play him) which is one of the most twisted relationships in comics, so that they could cripple Barbara Gordon.

You can't do Clayface for the Third Batman movie. Otherwise you'll draw comparisons to Spiderman 3 and Sandman.

geminired
Anonymous Source
Posts: 1
Joined: 22 Jul 2008

HobbesMkii:
Bane would be perfect. I know people are afraid of using characters from the Michael Keaton - Val Kilmer - George Clooney series, but screw that, Nolan isn't.

It should be Bane and Black Mask vs Batman. And it shouldn't be Robin, it should Batgirl. Introduce Barbara Gordon. It could work very easily, I think, just have her come back from college or university or whatever, and be inspired by Batman and her Father. Bane should definitely break the Bat, which forces him to rely on Batgirl, overcoming any earlier opposition to her aid (and teaching him that Batman can't always work alone, something already known to the comics).

Also, it sets up nicely a fourth film, in which you could introduce Harley Quinn and the Joker again (now given a suitable waiting period following Ledger's death for a new actor to play him) which is one of the most twisted relationships in comics, so that they could cripple Barbara Gordon.

You can't do Clayface for the Third Batman movie. Otherwise you'll draw comparisons to Spiderman 3 and Sandman.

Bane would be a good choice. It would be nice to see Bane portrayed more accurately than he was in the god awful Batman & Robin film. I don't think Nolan would use Clayface for 2 reasons: 1. I'm not confident he could carry the film. 2. Nolan doesn't appear the type to rely on CG too often, and with Clayface it would require a lot.

Nolan seems to go for the psychological villains. In the regard I do think Scarface and the Dummy or the Mad Hatter is feasible as well. I'd love to see Freeze done properly too, but I doubt Nolan will take that road.

As for who could play Bane.....well anyone big and bulky could pull it off. The question is who could do it well. I do think Nolan painted himself into a corner with this film. Even if the third film is great, I still have this nagging suspicion that I will walk out thinking "Good film, but it's no Dark Knight" Still if he can pull off the third significantly better than his predecessors did with Spiderman 3 or Xmen 3, I will be happy.

LesIsMore
Paperboy
Posts: 17
Joined: 22 Jul 2008

Abako:

Indigo_Dingo:

Abako:
I hate robin. Always have since the phrase Jiminy-Jillickers Batman! (spelling?)

Wasn't that Fallout Boy?

I have no clue as I detest Fallout Boy. Maybe it is and I heard that from a friend but that phrase just sticks in my head. I hated all of robins little 'Holy shit'-esque phrases

No, not the band Fallout Boy, but in "The Simpsons" the hero Radioactive Man has a sidekick named Fallout Boy who has that slogan. There's an episode where they film the Radioactive Man film in Springfield and Milhouse gets cast as Fallout Boy - and now I feel old since I remember when the show was actually good.

7dollarbill
Beat Writer
Posts: 150
Joined: 3 Apr 2008

Stammer:

7dollarbill:
I figured it was gonna be Two-face.

Well, I thought he died. Even if he didn't die, he'd be in jail big time for what he did to Gordon's family.

True, but villains and heroes alike in the comic universe have this thing about staying dead. :)

LesIsMore
Paperboy
Posts: 17
Joined: 22 Jul 2008

Indigo_Dingo:

LesIsMore:
Of course, from my point of view it's all a moot point since no superhero franchise has ever been good after it was bled for a third movie (Batman Forever, Spider-Man 3, X-men: The Last Stand, Superman III) and a fourth leads to levels of shittiness that reek like flayed ghouls (Superman: The Quest for Peace and Batman & Robin). Nolan has earned more faith than most for saving the Batman franchise, but there's nothing that makes me think he can follow this successfully.

While true, none of those had a sequel that far outdid the original, and was easily considered the best movie of the year, and best Superhero movie ever, hands down. We are dealing with a unique phenomena here.

True indeed, and I do give Nolan more room to succeed here. I consider "The Dark Knight" the best film of the year, best comic book movie ever and a contender for my favorite movie ever, but there's too many *really* egregious examples to fall back on. I approach any sequel with cautious dread.

Mr.Pandah
Muckraker
Posts: 249
Joined: 20 Jul 2008

You dont actually see Two Face buried...so its still up to debate. I personally think he's dead and that the funeral mass thing they held was to just clear his name and to make sure people dont know how he died. Only how he lived. Ya know, to keep the hope in Gotham alive. I was really dissapointed when he "died" but oh well. Maybe he still lives =D

Abako
Muckraker
Posts: 270
Joined: 30 Jun 2008

LesIsMore:

Abako:

Indigo_Dingo:

Abako:
I hate robin. Always have since the phrase Jiminy-Jillickers Batman! (spelling?)

Wasn't that Fallout Boy?

I have no clue as I detest Fallout Boy. Maybe it is and I heard that from a friend but that phrase just sticks in my head. I hated all of robins little 'Holy shit'-esque phrases

No, not the band Fallout Boy, but in "The Simpsons" the hero Radioactive Man has a sidekick named Fallout Boy who has that slogan. There's an episode where they film the Radioactive Man film in Springfield and Milhouse gets cast as Fallout Boy - and now I feel old since I remember when the show was actually good.

OOOHHHH! I remeber that now! your right. Huh. Well I still hate robin, little punk lol.

WlknCntrdiction
Infamous Scribbler
Posts: 594
Joined: 8 May 2008

Putting in Bane breaking Batmans back, now that would be epic:D

Juan Regular
Beat Writer
Posts: 146
Joined: 3 Jun 2008

I'd like to see the riddler. They might even get Jim Carrey for the role again.

But I think no matter what Nolan does he'll deliver another great movie. I mean, look at his movies so far: Following, Memento, Batman and the Prestige. Great director.

PedroSteckecilo
Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1756
Joined: 7 Feb 2008

Batgirl might work, Batman needs something he can care about again to humanize him.

DannyDeparted
Copy Clerk
Posts: 64
Joined: 12 Mar 2008

If they're going to keep up the style they've been going with, the Riddler could really be an asset to them. Re-vamped, made much darker so as to really screw with Batman's head; What's worse than a villain than launches an all out attack on the mind of the Hero. Joker proved this. I think if they're to pull it off Hugo Weaving could make an excellent Riddler, particularly considering his performance in V for Vendetta and as Agent Smith. He just has that air of dark intelligence to him.

That being said, Batman still needs someont to show off his funky kung-fu on. So a second villain, more intent on beating Batman to a pulp owuld be advisable. Hush and the Riddler have history together and could make a good pair. Or they could go for The Reaper, or Mr Freeze or something.
Or hell, even go for Cluemaster and really get the Bat thinking.

Eogris
Anonymous Source
Posts: 7
Joined: 18 Jun 2008

Is it possible the next big villain will be batman himself?

I had a feeling that the next movie would be ALLL about commissioner gordon chasing batman. there doesn't have to be a HUGE bad guy, just someone to get batman out and stopping crime. The riddle would work very nicely i believe, he would just have to be extremely dark and insane.

Charile97L
Anonymous Source
Posts: 1
Joined: 22 Jul 2008

I think there's a possibility that there won't be a third movie. just because they made a second one, doesn't mean there will be a third.

nolan isn't sure, and i'm sure he won't get on board unless the story is amazing. bale has said many times that he won't do it unless nolan is involved.

i know they're under contract for 3, but that's no guarantee of anything.

personally, i think the riddler can be a nasty, nasty villan, if you've read some of the darker graphic novels he can be quite cagey. plus, that accountant

SPOILERS who figured out batman's ID in the movie was named Mr Reese (ie Mysteries)... either that was a nod, or they're setting something up. also, there's no guarantee that Ra's is dead, nor is there a guarantee that TF is either. SPOILERS

just my two cents.

Tanthalos
Beat Writer
Posts: 216
Joined: 25 Mar 2008

I say bring out one of the super creepy minor Batman villians like Jane Doe.

Jane Doe watches your behaviour and speech pattern and then when the time is right she skins you, wears it like a wet suit and takes over your life.

GothmogII
Infamous Scribbler
Posts: 547
Joined: 6 Apr 2008

Abako:

Indigo_Dingo:

Abako:
I hate robin. Always have since the phrase Jiminy-Jillickers Batman! (spelling?)

Wasn't that Fallout Boy?

I have no clue as I detest Fallout Boy. Maybe it is and I heard that from a friend but that phrase just sticks in my head. I hated all of robins little 'Holy shit'-esque phrases

Wasn't he just a parody on the Simpsons? I thought they were making fun of that old Batman series.

Anyhoo...what's all this about villians being minor and not worthy of inclusion? *shrug* I mean, most of the choices listed so far have nearly all got good face time in the various Batman related media you can think off, and not really minor in any sense. That said...if there's to be a third film, it -would- probably be a better known face...

Bane - Is actually quite an intelligent villian on-top of his strength, I hate the way he was dumbed down in that god awful Batman & Robin. And what they did to Mr.Freeze too!
Either of them would be great, and with Mr.Freeze, he's still got that 'tragic past' thing to drawn on, so not too hard to give him another go.

Clayface...well, I've only ever seen the Batman: The Animated Series version of him, which I believe is significantly different than the comic book portrayals of Clayface. i.e. An actor disfigured in an accident, and mutated by an experimental restorative cream. That...and Ron Perlman did his voice :3 Still, plenty of room for drama there.

ultra_v_89
Beat Writer
Posts: 187
Joined: 7 Feb 2008

Tanthalos:
I say bring out one of the super creepy minor Batman villians like Jane Doe.

Jane Doe watches your behaviour and speech pattern and then when the time is right she skins you, wears it like a wet suit and takes over your life.

Jesus Christ, that would probably be dark enough. It would probably screw with capturing the prepubescent market, but that would be a good thing for hardcore fans. In my opinion, there is no clarification the two-face is dead, plus the manky side looked awsome, so I believe if they make a 3rd, he'll make an appearance. Other than that, Riddler or Bane FTW.

DannyDeparted
Copy Clerk
Posts: 64
Joined: 12 Mar 2008

***Spoiler Warning*** ok i'm fairly sure that Ra's is dead, i was watching that scene just thinking 'he could survive that, he could survive that' that was until the dam thing blew up all over the place. Sure he is a ninja though so he might have slipped out a window...lol. As for Two Face, i'm not convinced he is dead. i've seen it twice and he definately breathes at least once laying on the ground. Maybe they've just locked him up and for the sake of his reputation claimed he died. Which would be an interesting predicament if he was broken free in the future and hell, maybe Batman doesnt even know about it, cause he did take off in a hurry after the fall. ***Spoiler Warning***

My money's certainly on the Riddler (once more, would love Hugo Weaving in that role), as well as someone more physical like maybe Hush, the two of them do have history together.

Tanthalos
Beat Writer
Posts: 216
Joined: 25 Mar 2008

I believe everyone should read "Arkham Asylum: Living Hell" and then have this discussion, there are so many minor charcters who so deserve screen time. So many characters that you can have make amazing cameos but no one ever sees them because they were not in the movies or cartoons.

P.S. We need more Harley Quinn

PedroSteckecilo
Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1756
Joined: 7 Feb 2008

The problem with the following villains...

Clayface
Manbat
Ra's Al Ghul
Mr. Freeze
Poison Ivy
Solomon Grundy

Is that they're all "too comic booky" and wouldn't fit the now much more realistic and serious standard set by The Dark Knight. They can't brink back Ra's because after doing a "riveting crime drama that was acclaimed for its lack of comic book stupidity" they would never DARE have another super weapon style plot.

GothmogII
Infamous Scribbler
Posts: 547
Joined: 6 Apr 2008

PedroSteckecilo:
The problem with the following villains...

Clayface
Manbat
Ra's Al Ghul
Mr. Freeze
Poison Ivy
Solomon Grundy

Is that they're all "too comic booky" and wouldn't fit the now much more realistic and serious standard set by The Dark Knight. They can't brink back Ra's because after doing a "riveting crime drama that was acclaimed for its lack of comic book stupidity" they would never DARE have another super weapon style plot.

Humm...well, that's why they need to 'update' them no? The nuclear powered man of yesteryear is now the genetically warped fiend or nanomonster of today?

The_root_of_all_evil
Gone Gonzo
Posts: 3460
Joined: 13 Feb 2008

Tanthalos:

P.S. We need more Harley Quinn

Seconded.

@Pedrosteckecilo

Nonsense. You just need a real world analogy.

Clayface : Ignore the shapeshifting and concentrate on the mimicry; but add in the pain of losing his memories.
Manbat : See Venom
Mr. Freeze : Take away his ice-blaster and turn him into an Eco-Terrorist fighting to save the Polar Ice-caps.
Poison Ivy : Remove the seduction, keep the lesbian angle hinted at in the comic books and put her forward as an Anita Broderick character.
Solomon Grundy : He's basically Frankenstein's Monster, so treat him that way. Maybe S.T.A.R. Labs have a cloned organ donor that biologically incubates new cancer treatments; but, unbeknownst to them, it's developed consciousness.

In fact...all four human ones could have easily been I-IV (See what I did there :)) if codename V was number 5. Manbat could just be Batman's nightmare.

PedroSteckecilo
Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1756
Joined: 7 Feb 2008

Good reworks Root...

I don't think they'll do Freeze or Ivy, too many bad memories of Batman&Robin.

But I'm now really intruigued at the prospect of a gritty/realistic Clayface with Mimcry abilities, if paired with another good villain that'd be pretty awesome.

DannyDeparted
Copy Clerk
Posts: 64
Joined: 12 Mar 2008

Be nice, if they do keep with the 'completely, to the degree of boringness, scientificly viable villains'. To give us Riddler and Hush, or replace Hush with Clayface, Bane, or someone like that if Nolan's feeling more adventurous

The_root_of_all_evil
Gone Gonzo
Posts: 3460
Joined: 13 Feb 2008

INT. The Superbowl Stadium.

Thousands of people cheering. The Superbowl is underway.

Cut to

INT. Dressing Room

CLAYFACE sits and looks in the miror. Reflected back at him is the tired look of a man haunted by his memories.

SCOOTER(O.S.) : Ten minutes, Mr. Beckham!

CLAYFACE looks up at the door, sighs and looks back at the mirror. On the bench next to him is a newspaper, the headlines read "WAYNE INDUSTRIES PROVE LINK TO CANCER IN MAJOR PHARMACEUTICAL PRODUCTS."

CLAYFACE : Damn them.

He smashes his fist onto the paper. As he lifts it off, little lumps of flesh remain on the paper.

CLAYFACE : Why are they trying to ruin my life?

He reaches over for a hypodermic needle. There's a small amount of green liquid inside.

CLAYFACE : Keep calm now. Only five shots left.

Taking out a rubber tube, he wraps it around his arm and taps his wrist with his fingers.
Gently he moves the hypodermic into place and stabs it into his arm.

CLOSE UP on his face.

First the agony, then the ecstasy and then his face starts to mould. Slowly, as if trying on a new glove, but eventually his face transforms to Beckham's.

The new Beckham looks into the mirror again.

CLAYFACE(mimicking Beckhams accent) : I'm very pleased to be here at ...

He looks mock-confused for a moment, and then his face drops into serious confusion.

CLAYFACE(normal accent) : at...

Looking round, we follow his eyes as they pan across the room. Hundreds of photos stare back at him, all with different faces.

CLAYFACE(panicking) : at...at...

Under his view, we see all the faces melting slowly. He quivers, almost literally, but then...

CLAYFACE(shouts) : THE SUPERBOWL!

SCOOTER (O.S.) : Are you alright in there Sir?

CLAYFACE looks at the door and squints as if in pain.

CLAYFACE(Beckham's accent again) : Fine. Tell Victoria I'll be out in a moment.

He walks back to the mirror and we focus on the lumps of flesh slowly sinking into the picture of Bruce Wayne.

CLAYFACE(normal voice) : Next time, Mr. Wayne. I'll be you.

Jhereg42
Copy Clerk
Posts: 109
Joined: 11 Apr 2008

One possible route being ignored is to extend the Ra's al Ghul storyline. He had two daughters, Nyssa and Talia, that were involved in his organization. Talia even had a relationship with Wayne in the comics that resulted in a son.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ra%27s_Al_Ghul#Sensei

AnGeL.SLayer
Press Junketeer
Posts: 398
Joined: 8 Oct 2007

Who said it had to be an original villain? Perhaps they have someone new in mind...

^_^

LesIsMore
Paperboy
Posts: 17
Joined: 22 Jul 2008

http://www.latimes.com/entertainment/news/la-et-batmanvillains-2008-pg,0,1485774.photogallery?1

Here's a solid article talking about possibilities, with a couple interesting ones. I like the thought of Black Mask as a versus to Batman, and a more deranged Riddler in the vein of Cillian Murphy's Scarecrow sounds better the more I think of it, especially with David Tennant in the role.

Plus, here's a quote of his from an old comic: "You don't understand. .. I really didn't want to leave you any clues. I really planned never to go back to Arkham Asylum. But I left you a clue anyway. So I... I have to go back there. Because I might need help. I... I might actually be crazy." I like the idea of a villain with little control but who can't help it, as a counter to the Joker who has no control and doesn't want any.

Anton P. Nym
Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1224
Joined: 18 Sep 2007

PedroSteckecilo:
Batgirl might work, Batman needs something he can care about again to humanize him.

I used the same reasoning to conclude that Selina Kyle would be perfect... despite the Catwoman flick that missed the litter tray and stank up the place, the Wayne/Kyle : Batman/Catwoman symmetry would be right down Nolan's alley.

Besides, I think it's too early in the series yet for Batgirl unless the storyline clock winds a long way forward between TDK and its sequel.

-- Steve

alygishere
Paperboy
Posts: 33
Joined: 17 Jun 2008

If I were Nolan i would pick bane because he can outwit batman and he si stronger and that would make an interesting movie or black mask , i don't know anything about him but i like the name :D

Stammer
Infamous Scribbler
Posts: 667
Joined: 16 Apr 2008

The thing I like about the Batman franchise is it's not just doing the whole Dragon Ball Z thing where it's one super-powered guy versus an even stronger super-powered guy, and the hero has to become stronger to overpower the even stronger super-powered guy. Once the even stronger super-powered guy is defeated, he makes way for a yet even more powerful super-powered guy.

No, Batman is everyone outwitting each other. The only actual "super" villains are Freeze and Ivy, and maybe a couple other guys. For the most part though, it'