Also I think if Nintendo partnered up with some of the other companies we could have the coolest Smash Bros. EVER!
Also Characters that I forgot to include in the first list.
Spyro and Crash.

jeremyTH:

Characters that should be taken out.
Clones.(Except Luigi)
Jigglypuff
Ice climbers.

Whats wrong with the Ice Climbers?

Line up: Sonic Series-Sonic, Shadow Knucles
MArio Series-Mario luigi peach bowzer dk (no diddy kong)toad
Zelda Series-Ganon, Link+Midna, Zelda/Sheik
MGS Series-Solid Snake (old)
Pokemon Series-Pokemon Trainer(3 starters in the next series) Ash (Charzard, Pikachu, Vote among fans for 3rd) Brock, Misty ect
Fox Series- Fox FAlco Wolf
Fire Emblem- Lyn (Roots yo) Ike Ephraim Lyon
Samus- Samus (and only samus not zero suit)
Kirby- Meta Knight Kirby
Star Wars- Starkiller, Anakin, Luke, Vader
Oblivion - Listener, Arch Mage, Arena Champ, Master of the Fighters Guild, Grey Fox, Champian of Cyrodil, Sheogorath
Spore- Steve
Knights of the Old Republic- The Exile,Reven
Mass Effect- Shepard, Wrex, Garrus
Halo- arbiter Cheif Oracle
Too Human- Loki, Baldur, Thor
Warcraft 3- Arthas, Illidan, Kael, Sylvannis
Trilby Art of Theft- Trilby
Guitar Hero 3- Slash
Splinter Cell- Sam Fisher
Civilization Revolution- Napoleon, Abe Lincoln, Genghis Khan

megaman. nuff said.

I think I'll expand on my original listing.

Crash, Coco and Crunch Bandicoot, Dr N. Cortex, Tiny, X, Zero, Sigma, Vile, Eliwood, Lyndis, Hector, Nergal, Soma, Julius, Graham, Spyro, Hunter and Ripto.

That should do it.

Pacman c'mon!!

I would have to say Megaman X.

The Sorrow:
Rorschach
Dr. Manhattan
Sandor Clegane
Gregor Clegane
Robert Baratheon
Ilyn Payne

I would camp out for it.

I would prefer Syrio Forel to Illyn Payne. But for characters that might actually happen, I would love to see Amaterasu from Okami.

I rather have them cut characters and spend more time on gameplay or online features. Take a page from the 360 Nintendo because this wii stunt is getting old.

Mudkip!

I like Mudkip, he's a cool guy, fights other pokemons and doesn't afraid of anything!

XD lmfao!

Beowulf DW:

However, wouldn't that mean that Toon Zelda would turn into Tetra? Or Toon Sheik (o_0)?

Makes sense to be Tetra. Adult Zelda turns into a ninja, toon Zelda turns into a pirate!!

Another thought I've had, how about Earth Worm Jim?

Up B: Jet bike, flies in direction stick points (so any of 8 ways) really quick, then it breaks and falls down, propellying.
Side B: Whip, Jim pulls his head out and whips himself. Can also be used as a grab and edge grab.
B: Ray gun, similar to fox, but with stun
Down B: ???

Final Smash... gets in a fight with peter puppy (evil monster) and the giant dust clowd of violence works its way around the level, sucking in anyone it meets and doing loads of damage :D

They should have every single pokemon, and make it turn based, and have it as an explorable world with random battles, and have a story line involing collecting stamps NO WAIT badges.

That would be a great game but nintendo would never go for it. Super Smash Brothers PokemonTurnBassedWithRandomBattlesForBadges doesnt have quite the same ring as Brawl.

FLSH_BNG:
Mudkip!

I like Mudkip, he's a cool guy, fights other pokemons and doesn't afraid of anything!

XD lmfao!

Must...resist...urge...to make 4chan reference....

SirSchmoopy:
I rather have them cut characters and spend more time on gameplay or online features. Take a page from the 360 Nintendo because this wii stunt is getting old.

Yeah, thats why the 360 is outselling the Wii. Oh wait....

If they went with a similar system to the PsN, then it would work, but I highly doubt that Wii owners would stand for paying for online.

Miis for starters.

seeing as they have Game&Watch in there why not have some of the current characters in there original grpahics? from back in th' day?
Like fighting in original Mario Sprites?
Although they've have to think of ways to make 'em fight, it'd still be an interesting twist, or at least have a level that turns them into sprites.

The Blob thing from that game... about the blob, i'm actually thick and forgot what the title of the game was.

Uhm. Agreement in getting rid of Ice Climbers.
I dunno what it is about those little twats but they rub me the wrong way...

I can't really think of anymore that haven't likely been mentioned before.
So i'll stick at that.

* Toad
* the Sentinel (although he wouldn't really move around too much)
* Chuck Norris (or if it really has to be established game characters - Raiden)
* the sentry droids from portal
* I would regard lego darth vader as non-negotiable

Although the bet new character for that game would be someone very large - yahtzee was bang on the money about the painful zoom-half-a-mile-out clusterf**kery of some of the fights in that game.

Isaac and/or Felix from Golden Sun!

one of THE best RPGs I have ever played, I was excited and dissapointed when he was shown as only an Assist Trophy, but I was also hopeful, they obviously haven't forgotten about the series, and just them making him into 3D can give the hope of a Wii game :)

Tenamor:
Isaac and/or Felix from Golden Sun!

one of THE best RPGs I have ever played, I was excited and dissapointed when he was shown as only an Assist Trophy, but I was also hopeful, they obviously haven't forgotten about the series, and just them making him into 3D can give the hope of a Wii game :)

Focusing on what?

Chuck Norris and Daffy Duck

People I personally want in SSBX:
-Crono
-Magus
-Megaman
-Serge (Chrono cross)
-Lynx (chrono cross)
-Glenn (Chrono cross) {defineitely the dual wield version, he'd kick so much ass, he couldnt use items}
-a belmont
-Mewtwo {wtf did he go? clone character of who?}
-Shadow or knuckles
-Dominic Deegan {yes from the comic, he's awesome, yes I'm jealous of luna}
-A character that uses a lance as her main weapon, long range melee attacks.

Other things I'd like to see.
-More skins for the character, I want a lot of them, like say 10 or more each. shouldn't be too hard, I mean, sure certain dudes cant have it like snake, he's kind alimited, but bowser certainly they can find 10 combinations, especially when black and red wasnt used.....

-more levels, and not just clone levels

-a better build a stage feature.

- and a create a character thing IDK how it would work, but even if it was select characters attacks, you've now copied them, build your dude, then I'd be ok with that. iNfact thats even better.

WolfLordAndy:

Beowulf DW:

However, wouldn't that mean that Toon Zelda would turn into Tetra? Or Toon Sheik (o_0)?

Makes sense to be Tetra. Adult Zelda turns into a ninja, toon Zelda turns into a pirate!!

Another thought I've had, how about Earth Worm Jim?

Up B: Jet bike, flies in direction stick points (so any of 8 ways) really quick, then it breaks and falls down, propellying.
Side B: Whip, Jim pulls his head out and whips himself. Can also be used as a grab and edge grab.
B: Ray gun, similar to fox, but with stun
Down B: ???

Final Smash... gets in a fight with peter puppy (evil monster) and the giant dust clowd of violence works its way around the level, sucking in anyone it meets and doing loads of damage :D

Best. Post. Evar!!1!

So, Earth Worm Jim^

Zero from megaman cause he's cooler than that blue punk. :P

and Felix........the Cat, from his game on the NES, he could have a transformation ability dependent on what environment he's in, and it could be balanced out by making his better forms a more difficult combo.

There are 3 main reasons we can't have Chuck Norris as a playable character:
1. Chuck Norris would always win, making the game unfair.
2. Only Chuck Norris is good enough to play as Chuck Norris.
3. Chuck Norris is too good to play video games,

Megaman X
Fawful (Mario and Luigi: Superstar Saga)
Covenant Hunter
Portal Chick
Black Ork
Yuri (Red Alert 2)
De Blob
Protoman
Zero
Vile (Megaman X)
Magtheridon (Warcraft)
Russian Attack Bear (Red alert 3)
Headcrab
Gordon Freeman
Ivan (Golden Sun)

coakroach:

Yuri (Red Alert 2)
Russian Attack Bear (Red alert 3)
Headcrab

I lold
That would be so awesome

Bowser Jr./Shadow Mario-Super Mario Sunshine
5th (or 6th?) gen Pokemon-Pokemon
New Ganon (give him new B and B-up moves)-Zelda
New Toon Link (atlest one wind waker move, in new FS)-Zelda

and take off:
PT (swap with 5th or 6th gen pokemon)
R.O.B (I like him, but he doesn't fit in SSB)
Lucas (or Ness)
Ganon (see New ganon)
Toon link (see new Toon Link)

Mr. T

I predict some more WarioWare characters to be included, a different Pokemon and Dark Samus as a playable character.

A zombie (mrh?)
Purple Tentacle?
Leo and Aeris from VGCats (Leo has the legendary Rat-flail and Aeris has... herself?)

Michael Jackson.
Marty McFly.
The Main Character from the Ape Escape Games.
Ronald Macdonald.
And...
Mr. Staypuft - as an assist trophy ofcourse.

Altaïr ibn La-Ahad from Assassin's Creed and Leon S. Kennedy from Resident Evil 4

The PC from harvest moon who has gone insane would be a lovely addition.

Indigo_Dingo:
Yeah, thats why the 360 is outselling the Wii. Oh wait....

Oh so Sales = Fun Games? Oh wait... horrible logic isn't a useful argument.

The Wii is a toy at best and the amount of games I have bought for Wii I can count on one hand since Smash Brothers which was a boring over hyped rehash. The Wii is selling because it's opening a new market of gamers not because it's a better overall system. My mother won't be playing halo3 anytime soon but I'm sure shes the kind sucker who would play Wii Sports. Thus, it's getting old unless you really are looking forward to listening to music on your DS lolololololol

LV Solace:
- and a create a character thing IDK how it would work, but even if it was select characters attacks, you've now copied them, build your dude, then I'd be ok with that. iNfact thats even better.

I had the same idea!

Banjo & Kazooie: they were almost born to be in super smash bros

also, Glover from the N64 should be an assist trophy, he'd roll by on his big toy ball or just slap people up

Wallace and Gromit: They'd behave similarly to the ice climbers except with a transformation move that switches between the primary character.

Baby Bowser from Mario Sunshine: He would use his paintbrush as a primary weapon and cover you with goo and stuff and
he would also have a transformation move that turned him into dark mario

ubermantj:
Chuck Norris and Daffy Duck

Damn strait, Chuck as Walker would be awesome. Thank God for imagination.