Which would you take home?
Staffordshire Bull Terrier
6.3% (10)
6.3% (10)
Shiba Inu
13.2% (21)
13.2% (21)
German Shepherd
33.3% (53)
33.3% (53)
Samoyed
3.1% (5)
3.1% (5)
Malamute
24.5% (39)
24.5% (39)
They are all awful! My dog is the best!
18.9% (30)
18.9% (30)
Want to vote? Register now or Sign Up with Facebook
Poll: Dogs! Which would you want?

 Pages 1 2 3 NEXT
 

I love dogs, but I won't be able to have one for another 2 years at least until I finish uni, move out and get a job. Still, I always think about what breeds I particularly like. I will probably end up getting a heinz from a shelter because of all the good reasons that come with that (lovely dogs/better health/cost/helping etc.)

But until then, which of these breeds (ones I am particularly fond of) do you think is the nicest/coolest/smartest/best looking/best pet. Basically, which one would you take home, given the choice? (This is presuming the dog is a standard example of the breed's temperament and attributes). Do any of you have these dogs? If not, what kind do you have? Nice dog ownership stories are very welcome to make me extra jealous.

If you hate dogs and would never have one? Make a thread about cats?

Links to pictures in case people aren't familiar with breeds:
Staffy
image
Shiba
image
German Shepherd
image
Samoyed
image
Malamute
image

Staffy, my mate has one and its awesome.

I'm partial to huskies (malamute? I'm not big on dog terminology but I've never heard that term before), myself. You're probably going to have a hard time finding a recognizable breed though.

I really hate smaller dogs, so good on you for picking the larger ones, I say.

Saladfork:
I'm partial to huskies (malamute? I'm not big on dog terminology but I've never heard that term before), myself. You're probably going to have a hard time finding a recognizable breed though.

I really hate smaller dogs, so good on you for picking the larger ones, I say.

Yeah, smaller dogs are usually the noisier ones of the bunch. I regret getting my little terrorist.

I'd go with a Husky (Malmute?). Such a gorgeous looking dog and they look the closest to wolves. I've always wanted a pet wolf.

Saladfork:
I'm partial to huskies (malamute? I'm not big on dog terminology but I've never heard that term before), myself. You're probably going to have a hard time finding a recognizable breed though.

I really hate smaller dogs, so good on you for picking the larger ones, I say.

Alaskan Malamute is kind of a bigger version of a Siberian Husky. I think they're a little less spirited and more soppy.
And yeah, I'm a fan of bigger dogs. Small ones are annoying. I like my dogs looking like dogs.

And a pet wolf would be cool on paper, but I don't think it would work. Hence my preference of spitz type doggies (oldest dog type, most closely related to wolves).

Try crossing an English Cocker Spaniel with a short hair smooth coat style terrier, you will get the ultimate cuddly dog with the cutest nature ever.

I have a cocker spaniel x manchester terrier, she's like a snuggly little rotweiler with floppy ears.

Of your options, Malamute looks the best to me.

But we have a Border Collie at home, who essentially beats every other dog hands down. ^_^

Man, I love German Shepherds. So imposing, so strong. And those satellite dishes for ears! Perfect. :) (Although, Shiba Inus are super cute)

I can't decide between the Shiba Inu (which was my favourite in Nintendogs) and Malamute. I really kinda want a Corgy, though! I had a three year old Golden Retriever two years ago. He died of cancer and I posted a whine-thread here on the Escapist to make me feel better. It helped. I love you all <3

Anyway, so now I want that Corgy, but my parents won't have it, so I'm gonna have to wait until I'm done studying, move out and get a job. But I want it so much...

The one that looks like a Siberian Husky most likley. But if I had to choose any dog, then definetly a Gran Danois. It's just an enormous calm and happy dog. Not too much work, which I like.

Wikipedia:
As pets, once mature, Alaskan Malamutes have a very quiet, dignified temperament and are loyal to their owners.

Sounds like the malamute is my kind of dog. Plus it looks like a domestic wolf.
Not sure I'd like having to manage that coat, though...

My Puggle is the best, I wouldn't trade him for any other dog out there

C F:

Wikipedia:
As pets, once mature, Alaskan Malamutes have a very quiet, dignified temperament and are loyal to their owners.

Sounds like the malamute is my kind of dog. Plus it looks like a domestic wolf.
Not sure I'd like having to manage that coat, though...

Slightly easier than the Samoyed though. But he's so fluffy!

I had a Staffy x Rohdesian Ridgeback. She was a little excitable, but was that most gorgeous pup I've ever known. I was devastated when I had to find a new home for her. So, out of your options, I have to go the Staffy. How can anyone say no to that smile.

Out of any breed though, I pick the Swedish Vallhund. Very rare, to the point the we're on the edge of extinction as recently as WW 2. Such a kind hearted breed. I was lucky enough to have a reputable breeder in the town I was living last year, so I got to meet a few of her dogs, and some 8 day old pups. As soon as I am settled again, and not being shafted by work or contemplating an international relocation, this will be the pup I get. A grey, Female Vallhund named Storm.

Screw domesticated dogs, I'll tame a big bad grey wolf.

image

German Shepherd. Smart motherfuckers. Now if I could get a hybrid between a GSD and a Lab, I'd be the happiest bastard on the planet.

MammothBlade:
Screw domesticated dogs, I'll tame a big bad grey wolf.

image

It's all fun and games, until it accidentally kills you when challenging you for the position of pack leader.

Domesticated dogs are far less aggressive when it comes to stuff like that - namely because those that were, were shot and never got the chance to breed and propagate their genes i.e. such behavior were breed out of them.

Assuming you had done your reseach on each of the dog breed behivour, I would go with the Shiba. However I'm not dog expect so my I may change my mind (when I do the research first).

deadish:

MammothBlade:
Screw domesticated dogs, I'll tame a big bad grey wolf.

image

It's all fun and games, until it accidentally kills you when challenging you for the position of pack leader.

Domesticated dogs are far less aggressive when it comes to stuff like that - namely because those that were, were shot and never got the chance to breed and propagate their genes i.e. such behavior were breed out of them.

If it did that, it would become a lone wolf, not pack leader. Sure, most domesticated dogs are the distant descendants of omega wolves. And that's boring.

Though you've not mentioned them in the list, I'd go with a labrador. They're incredibly smart dogs who are massively dumb at the same time. Though you have to be careful because they'll eat you out of house and home if you give them the chance. We had to put child locks on our fridge and cupboards because the lab we had worked out how to open them

MammothBlade:

deadish:

MammothBlade:
Screw domesticated dogs, I'll tame a big bad grey wolf.

image

It's all fun and games, until it accidentally kills you when challenging you for the position of pack leader.

Domesticated dogs are far less aggressive when it comes to stuff like that - namely because those that were, were shot and never got the chance to breed and propagate their genes i.e. such behavior were breed out of them.

If it did that, it would become a lone wolf, not pack leader. Sure, most domesticated dogs are the distant descendants of omega wolves. And that's boring.

Well, if it's your wolf then it will see itself as part of your pack and it will challenge you for leadership like it does in the wild with other wolves. I know you are probably just joking, but if you ever do somehow get a wolf as a pet, I sure hope you know what you are doing.

Go to an animal shelter and rescue a mutt. Save money, save a life, make a friend that will love you for their entire life. Many pure breeds are pretty but scruffy shelter mutts have character.

My mutt appears to be some sort of Besenji / Whippet breed and was found nested by the side of the freeway where some heartless human abandoned her. She's more loyal and loving than any dog I ever had before. Save a shelter mutt, forget expensive pure breeds and designer dogs!

Whichever is more low maintenance.

Just looking at the pictures though: Shiba or Malamute. Because they look fluffy and soft, albeit not so fluffy as that white thing which will undoubtedly leave a shittonne of hair everywhere.
I will mention that cats are softer and cuddlier and more low maintenance though.

Treeinthewoods:
Go to an animal shelter and rescue a mutt. Save money, save a life, make a friend that will love you for their entire life. Many pure breeds are pretty but scruffy shelter mutts have character.

My mutt appears to be some sort of Besenji / Whippet breed and was found nested by the side of the freeway where some heartless human abandoned her. She's more loyal and loving than any dog I ever had before. Save a shelter mutt, forget expensive pure breeds and designer dogs!

I'm pretty sure I will (when I can actually manage a dog!) That or a staffy (most dogs in shelters in the UK are staffies or staffy crosses). There have been a few really sad tv shows about both abandoned dogs and the dark side of purebreds.

For those in the UK, this is a really interesting documentary: http://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/b01cqp75/Pedigree_Dogs_Exposed_Three_Years_On/

I didn't know about most of the diseases they discuss here, and I know a fair bit about dogs.

Also, yay for you! I'm glad you gave her a good home.

weirdsoup:
Though you've not mentioned them in the list, I'd go with a labrador. They're incredibly smart dogs who are massively dumb at the same time. Though you have to be careful because they'll eat you out of house and home if you give them the chance. We had to put child locks on our fridge and cupboards because the lab we had worked out how to open them

Shit, don't do that. Half the people that get Labradors go blind...

Crenelate:

And yeah, I'm a fan of bigger dogs. Small ones are annoying. I like my dogs looking like dogs.

Now, this is a terrible misconception, though admittedly one encouraged by teacup dogs, ridiculous pampering of obsessive owners and, of course, media attention.

While some small breeds admittedly display a lot of energy, like the jack and parson russel terriers, in a healthy environment with a complementary owner, they should maintain a friendly and relatively calm disposition.

Small dogs often wind up with owners who are incompetent because of their size; yapping and biting and signs of distress can be easily ignored when you can easily overpower the creature. Big dogs on the other hand, are a blatant threat and are much more likely to be gotten rid of at early signs of behavioral issues.

Small dogs can be just as brave, loyal and as intelligent as their larger counterparts. In fact, some smaller dogs are even more intelligent or longer lived than their larger counterparts, such as the miniature schnauzer to the standard and giant breeds. (according to general tests and age averages, of course)

That being said, there's nothing wrong with having preferences with breeds, but dismissing a majority of dogs out there over inaccurate stereotypes just does them no justice.

That being said, I would personally go for the Shiba inu. I could better handle the size of such an animal, and while the breed tends to be very headstrong, I prefer that sort of personality in a dog. I don't want a pet that's all too eager to please.

Bull terriers are not my cup of tea, my mother would be furious if I ever got a german shepherd and didn't have a very disciplined relationship with the dog, (she was bitten pretty badly as a child and is hyper aware of potentially dangerous large breeds) Samoyeds are a bit too simple and require a lot of grooming, and while I like malamutes a lot, they are a lot of dog, and I'm never planning on living in a climate that comfortably suits them.

I have a german shepherd so I'm biased toward having a german shepherd. My reasoning is that they tend to be smart, strong, loyal, and good family dogs.

Erana:

Crenelate:

And yeah, I'm a fan of bigger dogs. Small ones are annoying. I like my dogs looking like dogs.

Now, this is a terrible misconception, though admittedly one encouraged by teacup dogs, ridiculous pampering of obsessive owners and, of course, media attention.

While some small breeds admittedly display a lot of energy, like the jack and parson russel terriers, in a healthy environment with a complementary owner, they should maintain a friendly and relatively calm disposition.

Small dogs often wind up with owners who are incompetent because of their size; yapping and biting and signs of distress can be easily ignored when you can easily overpower the creature. Big dogs on the other hand, are a blatant threat and are much more likely to be gotten rid of at early signs of behavioral issues.

Small dogs can be just as brave, loyal and as intelligent as their larger counterparts. In fact, some smaller dogs are even more intelligent or longer lived than their larger counterparts, such as the miniature schnauzer to the standard and giant breeds. (according to general tests and age averages, of course)

That being said, there's nothing wrong with having preferences with breeds, but dismissing a majority of dogs out there over inaccurate stereotypes just does them no justice.

That being said, I would personally go for the Shiba inu. I could better handle the size of such an animal, and while the breed tends to be very headstrong, I prefer that sort of personality in a dog. I don't want a pet that's all too eager to please.

Bull terriers are not my cup of tea, my mother would be furious if I ever got a german shepherd and didn't have a very disciplined relationship with the dog, (she was bitten pretty badly as a child and is hyper aware of potentially dangerous large breeds) Samoyeds are a bit too simple and require a lot of grooming, and while I like malamutes a lot, they are a lot of dog, and I'm never planning on living in a climate that comfortably suits them.

You make really good points. A friend has a mini Schnauzer and it barks incessantly whenever anyone goes into the house, which seems to me like a combo of bad training and poor socialization. I always feel sorry for the dog though, because it must get so stressed out barking it's head off all the time.

I prefer the look of larger dogs, and the have the benefit of being able to withstand rough and tumble, massive cuddles and for making you feel safer when you're out on your own. If I wanted something small I'd probably just get a cat instead.

My mum is scared of German shepherds too, but my dad had a few as a kid so he loves them

Malumutes they are just so cuddly, I want one!

If I get a dog. I want a mother fucking dog. Not a nasty, yipping, over energetic ugly little rat that my dog could swallow without chewing.

I hate dogs. But for what it's worth I voted for the shiba.

Mr Cwtchy:
Of your options, Malamute looks the best to me.

But we have a Border Collie at home, who essentially beats every other dog hands down. ^_^

The Collies are unequivocally the smartest breeds of dog, and the best looking (opinion). They are medium-sized, friendly and loyal but demand a lot in return.

Temperament and the needs of the dog are the most important factors that should be considered before taking on a life long commitment. My last dog was an Irish Terrier (also medium-sized) who had a lot of character. He had playfulness, intelligence and stubbornness in equal parts. His needs were a fraction of that of a Collie's. Though I would love to have another Border Collie, I know it would be selfish of me, as I know i don't have the time or space to fully stimulate and care for it. My first Collie demanded constant stimulation, and I dont think I will be able to provide such levels until im retired! (But thats me and my plane of existence...)

Erana:

Crenelate:

And yeah, I'm a fan of bigger dogs. Small ones are annoying. I like my dogs looking like dogs.

Now, this is a terrible misconception, though admittedly one encouraged by teacup dogs, ridiculous pampering of obsessive owners and, of course, media attention.

While some small breeds admittedly display a lot of energy, like the jack and parson russel terriers, in a healthy environment with a complementary owner, they should maintain a friendly and relatively calm disposition.

Small dogs often wind up with owners who are incompetent because of their size; yapping and biting and signs of distress can be easily ignored when you can easily overpower the creature. Big dogs on the other hand, are a blatant threat and are much more likely to be gotten rid of at early signs of behavioral issues.

Small dogs can be just as brave, loyal and as intelligent as their larger counterparts. In fact, some smaller dogs are even more intelligent or longer lived than their larger counterparts, such as the miniature schnauzer to the standard and giant breeds. (according to general tests and age averages, of course)

Thank you for saying that :)

Another thing to remember is that small dogs are, well, small. This means that everything else is big to them. A big dog may not feel threatened when you reach out to pet him, but to a little dog you're a freaking giant. It's scary, and most people don't know (for a lack of a better term) "dog manners." For instance, staring at a dog can be very threatening, because it's stalking behavior. If the dog doesn't know you, and you stare at him, he might think you're planning to strike. And if he's smaller than you, he may decide that acting tough is the best way to scare you off.

As for what breed I want, I love the idea of a Husky (and may need to look into those Malamutes), however ideas do not always match reality. They're beautiful dogs, but I don't know that I have the energy to take care of a dog that needs to run that much. If I ever am able to handle it, though, I'd love to get one and name it Togo :D

We have a West Highland Terrier at home, and he is one of the most calm dogs around... awlays has been! Unless he sees a bird on his garden of course..

Personally though I would get a Border Collie... they really are awesome dogs! Easy to train, and very well behaved! Also have a lot of personality!

Not fond of purebreds, too many physical issues come with all that inbreeding. I'll take some form of labrador crossbred with larger guard breeds (at least 3 mixed), thanks. My current dog is a half-breed coon/blood hound, and she's also a halfwit. My dad's dog is a purebred Newfoundland, and he had weak hips and eye problems in his first year (aside from his frailties, he's awesome, though).
I think I'll go for a strong mutt next time.

 Pages 1 2 3 NEXT

Reply to Thread

Log in or Register to Comment
Have an account? Login below:
With Facebook:Login With Facebook
or
Username:  
Password:  
  
Not registered? To sign up for an account with The Escapist:
Register With Facebook
Register With Facebook
or
Registered for a free account here