Season Three of MLP: FiM killed the show

 Pages PREV 1 2 3 4 5 6 NEXT
 

Hazy992:
Why don't you just accept that the show is not made for us and move on? It's a neat little cartoon but to expect so much from a show that is intended for young children is quite frankly ridiculous.

I mean stuff like this:

EternalNothingness:
A bullying PSA.

Is a perfect example of you expecting far too much from it. Why on Earth are you surprised that a show intended for children has an episode talking about bullying?

You're looking at the wrong place for your entertainment. Go watch a show like Breaking Bad or Sons of Anarchy if you want something more fulfilling.

Daystar Clarion:
Why do I always feel like I'm missing something when it comes to MLP. I just don't get it :D

You're really not. It's just a fun little show about multicoloured talking ponies, that's really all there is to it :D

Screw ponies.

Pocoyo is better.

Also narrated by Stephen Fry.

I win.

image

Can someone tell me why is SO much deal for Twilight becoming a alicorn?
Also do you really blame Season 3 being bad.....because Rarity doesn't have her own episode?
I mean, it is a cartoon for crying out loud.

I may not be a fan of the show, but...

EternalNothingness:
they should be listening to us--their fanbase--so that they could fix any mistakes they've made in Season Three so far.

Yeah, it's not like fans ever have conflicting opinions about what a show's good qualities are. ¬_¬

Wow. Three Pony threads in one day. Where the hell have you guys been since Season 3 started? The gospel must be spread!!

OT: I don't necessarily think Season 3 has killed the show. That's sounds like a bit of hyperbole to me. Sure, there hasn't been as many episodes that wowed me like in the last two seasons, but so far, I'm still enjoying it. Besides, the season's not over yet, there might still be some really good episodes on the way.

Daystar Clarion:
Screw ponies.

Pocoyo is better.

Also narrated by Stephen Fry.

I win.

image

Pocoyo is a douche, with his stupid fucking beanie. It's all about the duck with the green bowler hat

image

Hazy992:

Daystar Clarion:
Screw ponies.

Pocoyo is better.

Also narrated by Stephen Fry.

I win.

image

Pocoyo is a douche, with his stupid fucking beanie. It's all about the duck with the green bowler hat

image

Please, it's all about Sleepy Bird.

image

Sleepy Bird is where it's at.

Binnsyboy:
I may not be a fan of the show, but...

EternalNothingness:
they should be listening to us--their fanbase--so that they could fix any mistakes they've made in Season Three so far.

Yeah, it's not like fans ever have conflicting opinions about what a show's good qualities are. ¬_¬

Especially when most of the times the hardcore fans want to see:
-The lesbian wedding of Lyra and Bon Bon come canon.
-Octavia confess her love to DJ-Pon3.
-ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship, ship...........and ship.
-Also this may help:

image

MLP is dead? YAY!!!!!!

Seriously, That's the best news so far this year!

Daystar Clarion:

Hazy992:

Daystar Clarion:
Screw ponies.

Pocoyo is better.

Also narrated by Stephen Fry.

I win.

image

Pocoyo is a douche, with his stupid fucking beanie. It's all about the duck with the green bowler hat

image

Please, it's all about Sleepy Bird.

image

Sleepy Bird is where it's at.

That bird has a distinct lack of green bowler hat. Pass

Also it's just an Angry Birds ripoff. IDGAF if it came out first, it still rips off Angry Birds :D

Hazy992:

Daystar Clarion:
Screw ponies.

Pocoyo is better.

Also narrated by Stephen Fry.

I win.

image

Pocoyo is a douche, with his stupid fucking beanie. It's all about the duck with the green bowler hat

image

Daystar Clarion:

Hazy992:

Daystar Clarion:
Screw ponies.

Pocoyo is better.

Also narrated by Stephen Fry.

I win.

image

Pocoyo is a douche, with his stupid fucking beanie. It's all about the duck with the green bowler hat

image

Please, it's all about Sleepy Bird.

image

Sleepy Bird is where it's at.

No love for Loula the dog?

Oh well...

Hoplon:
MLP is dead? YAY!!!!!!

Seriously, That's the best news so far this year!

It's not dead, it's just that SOME FANS act like it is.

By the way, real talk, are MLP memes getting posted really such a horrible monstrosity in your day to day life that the show's hypothetical end makes you so happy?

Hazy992:
snip

An arsecrack hat for arsecracks.

TopazFusion:
snip

Loula isn't nearly sleepy enough.

SweetShark:

That may be one of the most fucked up things I've seen from the fandom. Granted, I try not to delve deep into that part at all, but I just feel dirty reading that.

SweetShark:

-Octavia confess her love to DJ-Pon3.

But in all seriousness that episode would be f'kin' awesome.

Dangit2019:

Hoplon:
MLP is dead? YAY!!!!!!

Seriously, That's the best news so far this year!

It's not dead, it's just that SOME FANS act like it is.

By the way, real talk, are MLP memes getting posted really such a horrible monstrosity in your day to day life that the show's hypothetical end makes you so happy?

Well, if he hate the show and want to see it get cancelled, sure, why not.
Btw, I am watching MLP too and I created fanarts, so no a hater.

Daystar Clarion:

Hazy992:
snip

An arsecrack hat for arsecracks.

Yeah well...shut up! So nyer!

*mumble grumble* doesn't even wear a green bowler hat... swear revenge on world...*mumble grumble*

Loop Stricken:

SweetShark:

-Octavia confess her love to DJ-Pon3.

But in all seriousness that episode would be f'kin' awesome.

Indeed, for Bronies it would be. Not for the whole family as the cartoon is for.
The only thing close to this is for Octavia and DJ-Pon3 becoming friends for the first time.
This would be FAR more effective and a life lesson for not judging others for their personal taste [in this situation, the music Octavia and DJ-Pon3 like to hear].

Dangit2019:

SweetShark:

That may be one of the most fucked up things I've seen from the fandom. Granted, I try not to delve deep into that part at all, but I just feel dirty reading that.

With all seriousness, I think this pic was joke intended to show to us how some ships can become very obscure. Buuuuuuttttttt.....

Hagi:

TopazFusion:

Hagi:
Your threads aren't quite as weird as they used to be!

Well, his last thread lived up to expectation.

Hagi:
But still... the guy's got a reputation to uphold. I mean for god's sake there's only a single "dis gon b gud" picture posted so far and people are actually engaging his arguments, what's the world come to?

Isn't it a logical fallacy to dismiss an argument based on the person giving the argument? I thought it was...

What is this logic you speak of? In a MLP thread by EN? You poor fool...

Ok, I am lost again.
What it is EN?

EDIT: A! Yes, the OP. Sorry for asking.

SweetShark:
With all seriousness, I think this pic was joke intended to show to us how some ships can become very obscure. Buuuuuuttttttt.....

If you want to see a shipping chart that's not a joke, have a look at this . . .

http://fc03.deviantart.net/fs71/i/2012/108/9/e/ship_png_by_ciscoql-d4wif6p.png (too big to embed)

It was made by collaborating fanfics.

Some ... 'interesting' ships in there, such as Tom the boulder, and Twilight's doll, not to mention all of the mane 6 with themselves, apparently...

Franchises go up and down hill all the time. As a brony, I don't see the big deal.

Look on the upside! You got some inflated Pinkie Pie for your troubles!

TopazFusion:

SweetShark:
With all seriousness, I think this pic was joke intended to show to us how some ships can become very obscure. Buuuuuuttttttt.....

If you want to see a shipping chart that's not a joke, have a look at this . . .

http://fc03.deviantart.net/fs71/i/2012/108/9/e/ship_png_by_ciscoql-d4wif6p.png (too big to embed)

It was made by collaborating fanfics.

Some ... 'interesting' ships in there, such as Tom the boulder, and Twilight's doll, not to mention all of the mane 6 with themselves, apparently...

I...I....I.........what?
Ok........I need to analysed this first what I see:

-A Rock shipped with an Apple Tree.
-A Sack of flour shipped with a backet of...vegetables?
-Discord shipped with the...........purple mustache dragon from the second episode of Season 1.
-Angel shipped with Gummy...
-Granny Smith shipped with Big Mac.
-Why some lines start and end to only one character........wat...what?.....

This is a joke right?

EternalNothingness:
snipped to keep my sanity

God fucking damn it Eternal Nothingness. Your perpetual fanboy bitching is both disruptive and drags down every fandom you are a part of. You are like a parody of the angry star trek fans I'd here about on t.v. as a kid.

Bronies have never been important to the show. They were going to make it how they wanted, or rather how Hasbro allows, wether the older fanbase came in or not. All the fan nods are just to throw us a bone out of the boundless kindness of there hearts.

Just watch the show or find some new shit to watch and then bitch about because it doesn't live up to your standards.

SweetShark:
I...I....I.........what?
Ok........I need to analysed this first what I see:

-A Rock shipped with an Apple Tree.
-A Sack of flour shipped with a backet of...vegetables?
-Discord shipped with the...........purple mustache dragon from the second episode of Season 1.
-Angel shipped with Gummy...
-Granny Smith shipped with Big Mac.
-Why some lines start and end to only one character........wat...what?.....

This is a joke right?

Not a joke.

And selfcest is a thing, apparently...

SweetShark:
-A Rock shipped with an Apple Tree.
-A Sack of flour shipped with a backet of...vegetables?
-Discord shipped with the...........purple mustache dragon from the second episode of Season 1.
-Angel shipped with Gummy...
-Granny Smith shipped with Big Mac.
-Why some lines start and end to only one character........wat...what?.....

This is why they say FiM ship is magic.

Ok........I will do a test here people.
If I press this on Google an find out this ship really exist, I done, I am really done!!

*google Diamond Dogs X Spike*

Oh THANK YOU GOD!!!!! THANK YOU!!!!
I didn't had results!!!! THANK YOU!!!!!!!

EternalNothingness:
They are trying too hard to make another MLP out of Littlest Pet Shop, even though that toy-based series will never out-MLP MLP.

Implying MLP isn't a toy based series? Practically every cartoon Hasbro produces is toy based.

Wait no, nevermind. Your ponies are obviously a higher art form, made to teach humanity crucial lessons of understanding and happiness so we can discover true enlightenment and finally achieve Nirvana. Totally not some suit's plan to make a twenty minute commercial for little girls or anything.

Daystar Clarion:
snip

Hazy992:
snip

Oh you guys. I missed your thread derailing debates.

Genocidicles:

EternalNothingness:
They are trying too hard to make another MLP out of Littlest Pet Shop, even though that toy-based series will never out-MLP MLP.

Implying MLP isn't a toy based series? Practically every cartoon Hasbro produces is toy based.

Wait no, nevermind. Your ponies are obviously a higher art form, made to teach humanity crucial lessons of understanding and happiness so we can discover true enlightenment and finally achieve Nirvana. Totally not some suit's plan to make a twenty minute commercial for little girls or anything.

See, now your getting it!

/sarcasm

Yeah, both shows are commercials at heart, Mlp's just a very good commercial. Littlest Pet Shop...I don't know. It's not my thing, but if someone else enjoys it, who am I to judge them?

I was finding the show to begin declining in quality, too. Then, I discovered other slice-of-life-action-fantasy works, such as the animé, Rosario + Vampire, and my happiness returned to me. Regular Show, El Goonish Shive... I must find more!

First off, Is EN the same guy who used to make those insane Sonic threads including one where he went on a rant about there being a Sonic balloon in the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade? Anyways I don't see the show declining in quality, each season has had its bad spots but fans just ignore them and focus on the good parts which are the majority.

EternalNothingness:

TopazFusion:
Now just hold on to your horses[1] here.

This is only a short season. So things are bound to be rushed, and characters are bound to miss out on episodes.

Also, "listen to bronies"? You know the show wasn't originally made for bronies, right?

And you know what I blame for the short season? Hasbro's decision to waste all of their resources on The Littlest Pet Shop cartoon! They are trying too hard to make another MLP out of Littlest Pet Shop, even though that toy-based series will never out-MLP MLP. Who cares about Zoey the dog or Sunil the mongoose? What about Twilight and Pinkie Pie? What about the Mane Six's friendship, rather than some teenage girl who takes care of seven miniature animals?

As for the show not originally being meant for bronies... well, it should be! Hell, John de Lancie, the voice of Discord, formed a Kickstarter project to create a brony documentary, which is out right now! And don't forget about Equestria Daily, which is heavily by bronies, for bronies.

But, since what you're saying is that the show was meant for little girls, not bronies... then I hope there are thousands of little girls all over the world watching this show, as they send angry letter to Hasbro criticizing the decisions they've made for Season Three. Little girls can be just as much brutally honest and passionate about G4 MLP, and if they spot something they deeply despise in the show, those same girls should have as much of a say about the show as us bronies.

Okay, I'm not getting into the debate here (mainly because I'll be away for a couple of days now on a trip and thus without internet, but also mainly because I hate getting involved in actual debates on the internet because they never stay as debates and always end up with one side repeating the same idiotic statements and opinions without evidence and ultimately one party or the other becoming little better than a troll). However, I will say this now.

You are getting way too uptight and serious about this. It's a TV show, made for children, NOT for 'bronies'. It was based on an existing franchise made years ago for CHILDREN. You have absolutely zero say in what goes in to that show, and it's pointless claiming otherwise.

You know something? I'm a massive Doctor Who fan, up there on the same level as RootOfAllEvil and TimeLord. But if the show starts to suck, the worst I'll do is complain online. I won't demand that the writers start listening to what I want because I'm not a professional writer, I don't write screenplays and TV shows for a living, and I don't have a financial investment like they do in maing sure the show stays good. If I want my own ending I'll write a fanfic. And then I'll delete said fanfic unless it's actually any good, which is the only time I'll post it online (because there are enough bad fanfics out there and I have pride in the quality of my own writing work, original or fanfic).

As a fan, NOT a writer, you have no say in what goes on to the finished product. If the creator choose to give you an input then that's great and should be applauded IF your ideas are any good, but that's entirely their prerogative. I say all this as both a creator and as a consumer of media - the creator is the only person who has any right to how the creation of their work should take place. Yes, they shpuld listen to fans, but half the time that doesn't do anything and the fans come up with equally crap or stupid ideas anyway. Hell, I was firmly on Bioware's side through the whole ME3 debacle, and that's me as a staunch fan of the games. They created it, not the gamers, so they were the ones who should choose how the story ended.

I'm going to end on a simple note here and leave you with an article explaining far better than I can just how self-entitled and selfish pricks the internet has made us all.

http://www.cracked.com/blog/4-reasons-internet-has-made-everyone-entitled-dick/

Pay special attention to Entry #2.

[1] hur hur hur

No idea what you're talking about. I've seen every episode so far and it's been almost nothing but good. Good storylines, good character growth especially from Applejack and Dash in their respective episodes, and John De Lancie came back. That right there is enough to make it worth it.

My ONLY complain, and it's small, is the music which was my initial draw to the whole series to start with. Nothing so far save for Babs Seed has really been an earworm that's stuck with me, but that might come down to just personal taste. Otherwise, it's all been good.

 Pages PREV 1 2 3 4 5 6 NEXT

Reply to Thread

Log in or Register to Comment
Have an account? Login below:
With Facebook:Login With Facebook
or
Username:  
Password:  
  
Not registered? To sign up for an account with The Escapist:
Register With Facebook
Register With Facebook
or
Registered for a free account here