Topic Index
Mac ads

Username:Password:
Log In
 (Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7)
BANNED
Posts: 4378
Joined: 21 Aug 2008

Michael_McCloud:
I'm not saying it's not funny, It just doesn't seem to appeal to me in any way. So what if some fisherman in west Timbuktu uses Windows? I want a better reason than "Everybody else is doing it" to side with a company.

I really hope someone else can see the irony here.

Like, I dunno, the specs of it all, whether or not I'll have to worry about viruses and anti-spyware programs clogging up the processor.

For someone who says they were born with Safari in their hand, you don't know a lot about Mac OS X.

http://blogs.zdnet.com/security/?p=2242

Honestly, even if a guy with a beret, goatee, and a set of bongos showed up and said "I'm a PC", I still wouldn't have given a damn. Likewise, if a fisherman took the place of the cool artist stereotype man, I honestly wouldn't have cared, so long as the fisherman brought the same points across.

Outside of personal preference, what valid points has Apple's advertising made to you?

In short, the quirky good-natured atmosphere of the commercials isn't what bothers me. What bothers me is that their only selling point (apart from parental control, it seems) is "Hey, look at who all is using our computers! Isn't that great? You should buy one now!"

You're not realizing that Microsoft isn't here to try and win the OS competition.

They already have.

And it's not just about marketshare when it comes to being a tech winner and a hero...Just look at the iPhone.

Strange, it says Microsoft Exchange ActiveSync...Not Macintosh OS XChange AppleSync :p

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 2997
Joined: 13 Aug 2008

Calling the ads pompous is like calling Asia big. It's an epic understatement.

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1830
Joined: 20 Mar 2008

Eggo:

I really hope someone else can see the irony here.

Irony? Do tell. Though granted, better might not have been the right word. More specific, perhaps.

Okay, everyone else is doing it. That's nice. Why is everyone doing it?

For someone who says they were born with Safari in their hand, you don't know a lot about Mac OS X.

http://blogs.zdnet.com/security/?p=2242

No, I knew about that, but here's the thing: Damn near everyone uses Windows. Why would you take the time to write a virus for a system that few of us use? Secondly, the article suggests anti-spyware not to protect against pre-existing viruses, but to help protect against anything that might be made in the future,

...making the whole virus writing process more difficult.

Moreover, though it's a good idea to run several antivirus programs, it's not next to mandatory as with the predicament for Windows. And third, you're missing the point of what I was trying to say in my first post.

Outside of personal preference, what valid points has Apple's advertising made to you?

The fact that it has pretty much anything you'd need for editing and artwork pre-installed on the mac (including a built-in camera); that it doesn't freeze nearly as often as Windows (or at all, in my case); the whole business with the viruses; that I can run either OS on a Mac, freeing up entertainment choices; that it runs Microsoft Office (though I use NeoOffice anyway). Just to name a few. Again, however, missing the point.

You're not realizing that Microsoft isn't here to try and win the OS competition.

They already have.

You seem to be barking up the wrong tree here. I'm not trying to say which side is better, or who is trying to do what to who. I'm just saying that I like Mac's to-the-point "Look what I can do" style of advertising better than to Microsoft's "We're all PCs" advert. I'm not trying to convert anyone here, and I really wasn't going into superiorities of either side in my first post anyway. Both sides have pros and cons, and it's just a matter of choice. Just because someone doesn't agree on the quality of advertising doesn't mean they're trying to burn down the other side's rose garden.

I don't give a damn about the OS competition. I just like the way Mac makes their commercials more, and part of that is from trained bias. The commercial isn't influencing my opinion on which one to buy, and it's not making me laud/loathe one side or another. I'm just stating an opinion on your original subject.

Sheesh, not even here can someone make a contrary statement without getting a cattle prod shoved up their arse.

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1578
Joined: 4 Sep 2008

Michael_McCloud:

Eggo:

I really hope someone else can see the irony here.

Irony? Do tell. Though granted, better might not have been the right word. More specific, perhaps.

*Raises hand* OOH OOH!!! I KNOW!!! PICK ME!!!!

Michael_McCloud:
I'm not saying it's not funny, It just doesn't seem to appeal to me in any way. So what if some fisherman in west Timbuktu uses Windows? I want a better reason than "Everybody else is doing it" to side with a company.

Refer to my previous post as to why this is ironic. If you're too lazy to go back and look (like you're maybe too lazy to take time to learn to use a computer) I'll spell it out.

MACS ARE A FAD!!! People (and by people, I mean college kids who have never used one in their lives who bought one as their laptop) only buy Macs because these ads make them cool. The advertisements work extremely well, considering their purpose: To make PCs seem uncool. Macs are 'whats in' right now.

Better?

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1830
Joined: 20 Mar 2008

Gxas:

Michael_McCloud:

Eggo:

I really hope someone else can see the irony here.

Irony? Do tell. Though granted, better might not have been the right word. More specific, perhaps.

*Raises hand* OOH OOH!!! I KNOW!!! PICK ME!!!!

Michael_McCloud:
I'm not saying it's not funny, It just doesn't seem to appeal to me in any way. So what if some fisherman in west Timbuktu uses Windows? I want a better reason than "Everybody else is doing it" to side with a company.

Refer to my previous post as to why this is ironic. If you're too lazy to go back and look (like you're maybe too lazy to take time to learn to use a computer) I'll spell it out.

MACS ARE A FAD!!! People (and by people, I mean college kids who have never used one in their lives who bought one as their laptop) only buy Macs because these ads make them cool. The advertisements work extremely well to considering their purpose: To make PCs seem uncool. Macs are 'whats in' right now.

Better?

*points to the bottom part of previous post, sips tea, ruffles newspaper and walks away*

Try to, you know, read the entire post before you go blathering on about things, alright? Alright.

Oh, and I'm not lazy enough to not learn how to use a computer. Unless, you know, my scratch-built gaming computer was poofed into existence by fairies.

BANNED
Posts: 4378
Joined: 21 Aug 2008

I apologize; I must have misconstrued what you were saying in respect to Microsoft and it's marketing. Although it seems you're misconstruing what Microsoft's advertisements set out to do. You can't fault it (as you initially were) for not doing something Microsoft never intended for it to do anyway.

The fact that it has pretty much anything you'd need for editing and artwork pre-installed on the mac (including a built-in camera); that it doesn't freeze nearly as often as Windows (or at all, in my case); the whole business with the viruses; that I can run either OS on a Mac, freeing up entertainment choices; that it runs Microsoft Office (though I use NeoOffice anyway). Just to name a few. Again, however, missing the point.

Mac OS X comes with very amateur editing and content creation suite that is easily surpassed with freely available software (on both Mac OS X and Windows). Outside of hipster "artists," it really isn't an advantage for the OS X; it's just more bloatware on my studio Mac Pro.

And if Windows is freezing often for you, then you're doing something very wrong. I've built dozens of Vista machines in the last year and...they're all running beautifully. Maybe I'm just really lucky?

Modern Windows machines don't get bogged down by respectable AV software. I wish I could say the same for Mac programs like Digital Performer and even Logic Pro. Why is it that my quad core/4GB Vista computer is far more responsive than my octo-core/16GB Mac Pro?

And the rest isn't really advantages for OS X. Just more reason why Apple can't live without Microsoft.

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1578
Joined: 4 Sep 2008

Michael_McCloud:
Try to, you know, read the entire post before you go blathering on about things, alright? Alright.

Do it everytime. The problem is that the end your last post has nothing to do with why Macs aren't a fad and you don't see the irony in your post. I'll quote and address each part of the post I plan on responding to, thank you very much.

Michael_McCloud:
, and I'm not lazy enough to not learn how to use a computer. Unless, you know, my scratch-built gaming computer was poofed into existence by fairies.

Sorry, the camera I have in your house stopped working some time ago so I haven't been able to keep up with your personal life and what you've built for a while now. I'll be sure to update it next time I'm nearby.

Muckraker
Posts: 262
Joined: 5 Nov 2008

I honestly can't stand Mac ads, or anything Apple advertises in general. Apple sells mainly to consumers who are looking for style over quality. "Oh look, our monitor and computer is in ONE CASE! Isn't that neat?!" No, it's a gimmick. Ever tried upgrading a Mac? Have fun getting around that screen, buddy.

Sure, Macs aren't terrible, they're just not as good as they're made out to be, and they do have their advantages (less viruses, slightly more stable OS). But really, I'm out to get the best out of my system, and I'm simply not going to be doing anything crazy with a Mac. The Mac commercials exaggerate Windows' faults above and beyond what they actually are. Hell, the only problem I've encountered on my Vista machine is a slight issue with compatibility, that can easily be solved by changing one property of the program.

P.S. iPods aren't cool, end of story. It's a hard drive with music playing software and a fancy name slapped on. Any other MP3 player on Earth does the same damn thing, so why spend bundles of money on a name?

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1668
Joined: 10 Sep 2008

I though they were genuinly funny until they started getting silly.
"I'm a mac, and cannot upgrade, therefore I'm superior"

..umm the main reason I bought a PC was so I could keep it up to date easily if I so choose :S

but some of the earlier ones were definately funny, and brilliant marketing.

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1830
Joined: 20 Mar 2008

Gxas:

Do it everytime. The problem is that the end your last post has nothing to do with why Macs aren't a fad and you don't see the irony in your post. I'll quote and address each part of the post I plan on responding to, thank you very much.

Looking back I do agree with you there. That would be my bad.

Sorry, the camera I have in your house stopped working some time ago so I haven't been able to keep up with your personal life and what you've built for a while now. I'll be sure to update it next time I'm nearby.

Yes, please do. And be sure watch out for Fluffy, you know how he is about strangers with cameras.

Pulitzer Laureate
Posts: 871
Joined: 20 Dec 2007

The only thing that the Mac commercials have made me do is hate Justin Long.

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1578
Joined: 4 Sep 2008

Michael_McCloud:

Gxas:
Sorry, the camera I have in your house stopped working some time ago so I haven't been able to keep up with your personal life and what you've built for a while now. I'll be sure to update it next time I'm nearby.

Yes, please do. And be sure watch out for Fluffy, you know how he is about strangers with cameras.

^^^ The reason I love the Escapist. Any flame war is resolved over time by people agreeing to disagree. (I still miss you all... RIP Shivari, Juandonde, TaxiDriver...)

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1830
Joined: 20 Mar 2008

Eggo:
I apologize; I must have misconstrued what you were saying in respect to Microsoft and it's marketing. Although it seems you're misconstruing what Microsoft's advertisements set out to do. You can't fault it (as you initially were) for not doing something Microsoft never intended for it to do anyway.

It's alright, internet folks get so worked up over consoles that sometimes anything sounds like a challenge. I've done the same thing as you.

And yes, I do see your point with Microsoft's premise here.

Mac OS X comes with very amateur editing and content creation suite that is easily surpassed with freely available software (on both Mac OS X and Windows). Outside of hipster "artists," it really isn't an advantage for the OS X; it's just more bloatware on my studio Mac Pro.

And if Windows is freezing often for you, then you're doing something very wrong. I've built dozens of Vista machines in the last year and...they're all running beautifully. Maybe I'm just really lucky?

Modern Windows machines don't get bogged down by respectable AV software. I wish I could say the same for Mac programs like Digital Performer and even Logic Pro. Why is it that my quad core/4GB Vista computer is far more responsive than my octo-core/16GB Mac Pro?

And the rest isn't really advantages for OS X. Just more reason why Apple can't live without Microsoft.

Yeah, those were just half-assed ripped from the commerials, just to show that Mac makes a show of why you should buy theirs, whether it's actually better or not. I was more focused on the style of the advertising rather than the content anyway, as we've come to realize.

Pulitzer Laureate
Posts: 871
Joined: 20 Dec 2007

Gxas:
(RIP Shivari, Juandonde, TaxiDriver...)

Shivari? She left the Escapist?

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1578
Joined: 4 Sep 2008

mydogisblue:

Gxas:
(RIP Shivari, Juandonde, TaxiDriver...)

Shivari? She left the Escapist?

Haven't seen her around for months. Maybe I'm just not looking at threads she is though.

Copy Clerk
Posts: 116
Joined: 18 Dec 2008

Meh. Everyone in my household and almost everybody I know owns a Mac. I use my Macbook for Adobe Creative suite and my Powerbook G4 for Final Cut Pro 4. The Mac ads, while amusing the FIRST time they were shown, are now just pretentious and annoying.

Yes, buy a Mac. No, don't act like a douche. There, I have already outdone the advertisements.

That also goes for the 'spin-off' PC ads. I mean, you don't combat the douche by becoming a douche. In the end, though, it just comes down to personal preference of the OS.

Kudos to Linux for not giving a shit.

BANNED
Posts: 4378
Joined: 21 Aug 2008

Yeah, let's talk about all the attacks on Apple the Microsoft spin-off advertisements have mounted.

Muckraker
Posts: 262
Joined: 5 Nov 2008

Eggo:
Yeah, let's talk about all the attacks on Apple the Microsoft spin-off advertisements have mounted.

I'm all over it. The one I've seen gets on my nerves, too. I realize it was just a counter to Apple's ads, but Microsoft seems to have taken a "HAHA, I'M POPULAR TOO, SO PROVE ME WRONG" approach. I honestly don't care if Hank the plumber likes PCs better than Macs. How about giving me some facts to go off of?

BANNED
Posts: 4378
Joined: 21 Aug 2008

TriggerAF:

Eggo:
Yeah, let's talk about all the attacks on Apple the Microsoft spin-off advertisements have mounted.

I'm all over it. The one I've seen gets on my nerves, too. I realize it was just a counter to Apple's ads, but Microsoft seems to have taken a "HAHA, I'M POPULAR TOO, SO PROVE ME WRONG" approach. I honestly don't care if Hank the plumber likes PCs better than Macs. How about giving me some facts to go off of?

You're completely missing the point of these ads. And the approach isn't "I'm popular too."

Muckraker
Posts: 262
Joined: 5 Nov 2008

Eggo:

You're completely missing the point of these ads. And the approach isn't "I'm popular too."

Honestly, that's just what I got out of it. They made it seem like PCs are the best, because a lot of people use them, but of course, I could very possibly be dead wrong.

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 3364
Joined: 23 Oct 2007

Gxas:
DO NOT ACTUALLY TYPE THE CONTENTS OF THE SPOILER INTO YOUR TERMINAL WINDOW!!!!!

The fact of the matter is that Macs are now a fad to any person in college who has used a PC all of their life. It doesn't matter if you say you think it is better than a PC or not, the reason you bought that computer was simply because it is 'hip' right now. Sure, you may like that it has no learning curve to it. hell, I'll agree with you on that point. What I would love to do is have one of these Mac users I referred to above open Terminal and type in four simple keystrokes:

That would solve a whole lot in my opinion.

I warned you!!! I did!!

Just for the record, it's:

That clears all folders without any confirmation prompts.

Pulitzer Laureate
Posts: 731
Joined: 12 Dec 2007

sv93:

CoverYourHead:
Agreed. I have a Mac, it's great. I don't mind the commercials, but I dislike the new PC commercials. I think we can all agree though; when it comes to commercials TiVo rules.

Hmm, I have yet to see these new PC adds can you send me a link to one or something? Just PM it don't waste the forum space. and yes TiVo does rule!

xitel:
I thought they were kind of funny to begin with, but they've gotten old.

Yeah, all the first ones were funny. Now only a few of the new ones are funny.

The new PC ads were basically starting off with the enrdy guy saying "I'm a PC", then it went through a whole bunch of other people saying "I'm a PC, and this is my office", ranging from out on the ocean to open markets and everywhere else. I thought it was a nice riposte to the Mac ads.

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 2380
Joined: 29 Oct 2008

I like both but I only own a PC. Thing is, I'm not just a gamer, I'm a musician and own a lot of recording equipment. PCs are better for gaming but MACs are better for like... everything else, really.

I don't particularly want one but I don't have a personal vendetta against them. I hate the way the PC-owner is portraid in the MAC adverts but to be fair the new PC adverts are pretty funny :P So it doesn't bother me that much.

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 2194
Joined: 10 Jul 2004

intergral:
Meh. Everyone in my household and almost everybody I know owns a Mac. I use my Macbook for Adobe Creative suite and my Powerbook G4 for Final Cut Pro 4. The Mac ads, while amusing the FIRST time they were shown, are now just pretentious and annoying.

Yes, buy a Mac. No, don't act like a douche. There, I have already outdone the advertisements.

That also goes for the 'spin-off' PC ads. I mean, you don't combat the douche by becoming a douche. In the end, though, it just comes down to personal preference of the OS.

Kudos to Linux for not giving a shit.

My point exactly. It's really personal preference.
As an extensive Mac user for video editing for school and freelance work, I can't honestly say either OS is better. The only reason why I chose Mac OS X is because of the professional software that is OS X exclusive (Final Cut Studio 2).

I prefer this bundle of softwares over what AVID and Adobe have to offer. I use all three quite a bit to make a sound decision, and it just so happens FCS2 appealed to me more because of its interface and cost.

I still have Vista installed on my Mac Pro, and sure it has its flaws, but so does OS X.

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1870
Joined: 13 Oct 2008

Mac:ima mac
PC: And i'm a PC
Mac: i fel a litle tird, 4 yers takes it outta mi
PC: Well I just got upgraded, I will last longer than you and geuss what else?
MAC:wht?
PC: I'm a PC and am not being a TOTAL FUCKWAD ABOUT IT! Learn to type! You stole my MS Word program you gen Y piece of $hit, USE IT! after 4 years you get thrown out and replaced for annother 2000 dollars whilst i get upgraded for less than a grand and STILL kick you ass without needing to have all my programs moved over! so go and DIE!
...
...
...
sorry, those adds pissed me off my PC kicks any MAC in the ba...knees.

PCs represent part of a user. like a car. whilst macs are basicly SmartCar for 2's. they look cool and can do most day to day stuff but at the end of the day, they didnt exactly destroy all other cars, did they?

and sorry to all fellow gen Yers. but with all the "corey worthington" style flak we get from the media already i didnt think you would mind.

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1578
Joined: 4 Sep 2008

RAKtheUndead:

Gxas:
DO NOT ACTUALLY TYPE THE CONTENTS OF THE SPOILER INTO YOUR TERMINAL WINDOW!!!!!

The fact of the matter is that Macs are now a fad to any person in college who has used a PC all of their life. It doesn't matter if you say you think it is better than a PC or not, the reason you bought that computer was simply because it is 'hip' right now. Sure, you may like that it has no learning curve to it. hell, I'll agree with you on that point. What I would love to do is have one of these Mac users I referred to above open Terminal and type in four simple keystrokes:

That would solve a whole lot in my opinion.

I warned you!!! I did!!

Just for the record, it's:

That clears all folders without any confirmation prompts.

Really? I was told it worked either way. Whatever, as long as it clears everything I'm happy.

Beat Writer
Posts: 132
Joined: 9 Oct 2008

Gxas:

Bored Tomatoe:

Ok, so its a way of software-frying a mac?

Yes. The perfect practical joke for a 'hip mac user' with tons of money.

Okay, this little run of hypocritical condescension kinda took the cake for me.

First off, plenty of us mac users are quite aware of Unix commands and how to use them(though there is definitely a set that do not). This command, by itself, will not perform the horrible action you desire. It will simply erase all the files in the current directory(if you have proper file permissions for those files). The correct set of commands are

cd /
sudo -u root rm -rf *.*

or more specifically, on mac, you open the terminal while logged in as an administrator with permission to sudo to root. Then you would enter the commands

cd /
sudo rm -rf *.*

This does a forced erasure of all files and directories starting at the root directory and doing so as the root user(which is a higher level of privilege than even the administrator, and you will have to enter a password to complete the action). The reason this permanently bricks a machine is that the firmware is also a directory(/dev) from the root directory, as fair as the Unix operating system is concerned, and root has access to those firmware directories. So, this command will delete the firmware from the machine for every device, including the CPU, motherboard chipset, GPU, harddrive chips, DVD/CD-ROM drive chips, etc(the next time you are on a Unix machine, take a glance at the /dev directory).

Actually doing this to someone's machine is not a practical joke; it's a serious act of vandalism because the machine is a literal brick at that point. If you are such a small person that you would actually do this to someone's mac just because you can't stand the unjustifiable smugness of a select few, then you prove that you are much less a person than they are.

NEVER, EVER, EVER DO THIS!!

Edit: Had to add admonishment at the end.

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1578
Joined: 4 Sep 2008

geizr:

Gxas:

Bored Tomatoe:

Ok, so its a way of software-frying a mac?

Yes. The perfect practical joke for a 'hip mac user' with tons of money.

Okay, this little run of hypocritical condescension kinda took the cake for me.

Actually doing this to someone's machine is not a practical joke; it's a serious act of vandalism because the machine is a literal brick at that point. If you are such a small person that you would actually do this to someone's mac just because you can't stand the unjustifiable smugness of a select few, then you prove that you are much less a person than they are.

NEVER, EVER, EVER DO THIS!!

Edit: Had to add admonishment at the end.

Well in all seriousness I was totally kidding. With the way computers (especially Macs) are priced nowadays, I would never ever dream of doing this to someone. Way to go Mr. Literal.

As to my 'hypocritical condescension': I wasn't referring to you at all. See, the thing you don't realize is that people nowadays buy Macs because they are Macs. Not because they know what makes a Mac different from a PC. That was who I was referring to; The people I went to high school with who had never heard of a Mac before last year and then bought one. The people who have absolutely no idea whatsoever what Unix is. Those people are who I was referring to as 'hip Mac users'. You obviously know a thing or two about Macs because you know how to use Unix. These people I am referring to have no clue whatsoever. Don't try to lump yourself into the mix because you want to pick a fight. Believe me, I've won. Macs are, indeed, a fad nowadays. To those of you, like you and my grandparents, who have used Macs for years: kudos to you. You are in no way better than us PC users at all. To those of you who bought a Mac because these ads told you that Macs are so much better than Vista and all PC products and don't get viruses ever, way to go. Apple basically lied out their asses to get you to buy their product and you know what? It worked!!!

Look, I never, ever, said that I was in any way shape or form, better than any Mac user. You all assumed that I did because I don't use your OS. You know what? I'm too lazy to learn how to use a Mac because a PC can do everything a Mac can. What's the point in learning a new OS if mine can do the exact same shit as yours? Oh? Whats that? Yeah, ok. I can't take my PC out of the box and do everything yours can immediately. I don't care though.

PC = Mac = Linux

NONE IS BETTER THAN THE OTHER!!! IT IS ALL PERSONAL PREFERENCE!!!!

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 2722
Joined: 26 Jun 2008

They're just annoying now. I like my PC. SO what if their are viruses, as long as you're smart you can avoid them.

Pulitzer Laureate
Posts: 796
Joined: 6 Dec 2007

geizr:

Gxas:

Bored Tomatoe:

Ok, so its a way of software-frying a mac?

Yes. The perfect practical joke for a 'hip mac user' with tons of money.

Okay, this little run of hypocritical condescension kinda took the cake for me.

First off, plenty of us mac users are quite aware of Unix commands and how to use them(though there is definitely a set that do not). This command, by itself, will not perform the horrible action you desire. It will simply erase all the files in the current directory(if you have proper file permissions for those files). The correct set of commands are

cd /
sudo -u root rm -rf *.*

or more specifically, on mac, you open the terminal while logged in as an administrator with permission to sudo to root. Then you would enter the commands

cd /
sudo rm -rf *.*

This does a forced erasure of all files and directories starting at the root directory and doing so as the root user(which is a higher level of privilege than even the administrator, and you will have to enter a password to complete the action). The reason this permanently bricks a machine is that the firmware is also a directory(/dev) from the root directory, as fair as the Unix operating system is concerned, and root has access to those firmware directories. So, this command will delete the firmware from the machine for every device, including the CPU, motherboard chipset, GPU, harddrive chips, DVD/CD-ROM drive chips, etc(the next time you are on a Unix machine, take a glance at the /dev directory).

Actually doing this to someone's machine is not a practical joke; it's a serious act of vandalism because the machine is a literal brick at that point. If you are such a small person that you would actually do this to someone's mac just because you can't stand the unjustifiable smugness of a select few, then you prove that you are much less a person than they are.

NEVER, EVER, EVER DO THIS!!

Edit: Had to add admonishment at the end.

I'm curious, seeing as I don't really know a lot of Unix stuff. (Windows and Linux works for me just fine) To what extent is the Mac bricked after this command. You mention firmware being erased. Is it not possible to install that again? I'm in no way trying to mixed up in all af this, but I would like to know. Is it really completely bricked forever and ever (or at least an almost equivalent degree) or is it possible for a user to salvage the wreckage?

Edit: Oh, the hell with it. i might as well say my piece. I don't really like Mac. I'm sure it's an okay computer but I don't want one. The times I've tried them and had to work on them I've felt constrained. It seemed I had very little freedom. But that may just be me, so anyone should go ahead and get one if they feel like it. I just never will.
That being said, the ads are not helping to bring me over. Infact they do the oposite. They alienate me from the Mac userbase and the brand as a whole. By watching a Mac ad I don't think: "Oh, Mac sure seems like a good system." No, I end up thinking: "Man, what a bunch of half truths and blatant lies." They really don't give me any reasons to buy the thing. They just lie to me. How is that going to win me over?

Beat Writer
Posts: 132
Joined: 9 Oct 2008

teh_gunslinger:

geizr:

Gxas:

Bored Tomatoe:

Ok, so its a way of software-frying a mac?

Yes. The perfect practical joke for a 'hip mac user' with tons of money.

Okay, this little run of hypocritical condescension kinda took the cake for me.

First off, plenty of us mac users are quite aware of Unix commands and how to use them(though there is definitely a set that do not). This command, by itself, will not perform the horrible action you desire. It will simply erase all the files in the current directory(if you have proper file permissions for those files). The correct set of commands are

cd /
sudo -u root rm -rf *.*

or more specifically, on mac, you open the terminal while logged in as an administrator with permission to sudo to root. Then you would enter the commands

cd /
sudo rm -rf *.*

This does a forced erasure of all files and directories starting at the root directory and doing so as the root user(which is a higher level of privilege than even the administrator, and you will have to enter a password to complete the action). The reason this permanently bricks a machine is that the firmware is also a directory(/dev) from the root directory, as fair as the Unix operating system is concerned, and root has access to those firmware directories. So, this command will delete the firmware from the machine for every device, including the CPU, motherboard chipset, GPU, harddrive chips, DVD/CD-ROM drive chips, etc(the next time you are on a Unix machine, take a glance at the /dev directory).

Actually doing this to someone's machine is not a practical joke; it's a serious act of vandalism because the machine is a literal brick at that point. If you are such a small person that you would actually do this to someone's mac just because you can't stand the unjustifiable smugness of a select few, then you prove that you are much less a person than they are.

NEVER, EVER, EVER DO THIS!!

Edit: Had to add admonishment at the end.

I'm curious, seeing as I don't really know a lot of Unix stuff. (Windows and Linux works for me just fine) To what extent is the Mac bricked after this command. You mention firmware being erased. Is it not possible to install that again? I'm in no way trying to mixed up in all af this, but I would like to know. Is it really completely bricked forever and ever (or at least an almost equivalent degree) or is it possible for a user to salvage the wreckage?

Edit: Oh, the hell with it. i might as well say my piece. I don't really like Mac. I'm sure it's an okay computer but I don't want one. The times I've tried them and had to work on them I've felt constrained. It seemed I had very little freedom. But that may just be me, so anyone should go ahead and get one if they feel like it. I just never will.
That being said, the ads are not helping to bring me over. Infact they do the oposite. They alienate me from the Mac userbase and the brand as a whole. By watching a Mac ad I don't think: "Oh, Mac sure seems like a good system." No, I end up thinking: "Man, what a bunch of half truths and blatant lies." They really don't give me any reasons to buy the thing. They just lie to me. How is that going to win me over?

As I understand it, it's bricked. It takes a factory reinstall to get the system to work again.

And I would like to give an apology to Gxas in that I reacted poorly. I let some of the other comments on this thread rile me.

To the haters, yes, there are some serious asshole mac users, but there are also some serious asshole PC users. Yes, there are some idiot mac users, but there are also some idiot PC users. Macs have their advantages and disadvantages; PCs have their advantages and disadvantages. As a mac user, I fully agree that macs are not the top-end when it comes to gaming, but, with the introduction of the intel macs, they are not that bad either(in fact, they are usually good enough such that other factors come into play in the buying decision).

While macs are not as much a target for viruses, trojans, or malware, they are not invulnerable(though it is debatable that they may be marginally more difficult to infect due to the way permissions are handled). Even with a mac, one should have a good firewall(properly configured and updated), a good anti-virus(properly configured and updated), keep the OS updated with fixes, and use good user practice. This is simple general computer literacy and usage.

For some, these things are obvious and easy, but for others, they're not. However, those for whom it is not obvious are not automatically idiots just because they can't do something you can do. It is not reasonable to expect everyone that uses a computer(be it Mac or Windows) to be an expert in technology(however, it is very likely most Linux users ARE technology experts), just the same as not everyone that drives a car knows how to take it apart and put it back together again. There will always be those who choose a machine and, yet, understand very little about its operation and use. If this were not true, services such as The Geek Squad would not have a market such as they do.

Technology is very complex and most of it is crap, in my opinion(including my mac). The choice comes down to the trade-off of what crap you can stand and what crap you can't stand. When things break you pay a cost, no matter what. The cost may be in your own time and effort to fix it yourself, or the cost may be in your money to have someone else fix the machine or to replace it. The choice comes down to personal values--which do you find more valuable, your time or your money?

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 3310
Joined: 10 Oct 2008

Mac ads suck and I want to kick the Mac guys ass. I could to because he looks like some skinny ass snide, snobby, Gap wearing geek who needs an ass whipping.

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 3364
Joined: 23 Oct 2007

geizr:

teh_gunslinger:

geizr:

Gxas:

Bored Tomatoe:

Ok, so its a way of software-frying a mac?

Yes. The perfect practical joke for a 'hip mac user' with tons of money.

Okay, this little run of hypocritical condescension kinda took the cake for me.

First off, plenty of us mac users are quite aware of Unix commands and how to use them(though there is definitely a set that do not). This command, by itself, will not perform the horrible action you desire. It will simply erase all the files in the current directory(if you have proper file permissions for those files). The correct set of commands are

cd /
sudo -u root rm -rf *.*

or more specifically, on mac, you open the terminal while logged in as an administrator with permission to sudo to root. Then you would enter the commands

cd /
sudo rm -rf *.*

This does a forced erasure of all files and directories starting at the root directory and doing so as the root user(which is a higher level of privilege than even the administrator, and you will have to enter a password to complete the action). The reason this permanently bricks a machine is that the firmware is also a directory(/dev) from the root directory, as fair as the Unix operating system is concerned, and root has access to those firmware directories. So, this command will delete the firmware from the machine for every device, including the CPU, motherboard chipset, GPU, harddrive chips, DVD/CD-ROM drive chips, etc(the next time you are on a Unix machine, take a glance at the /dev directory).

Actually doing this to someone's machine is not a practical joke; it's a serious act of vandalism because the machine is a literal brick at that point. If you are such a small person that you would actually do this to someone's mac just because you can't stand the unjustifiable smugness of a select few, then you prove that you are much less a person than they are.

NEVER, EVER, EVER DO THIS!!

Edit: Had to add admonishment at the end.

I'm curious, seeing as I don't really know a lot of Unix stuff. (Windows and Linux works for me just fine) To what extent is the Mac bricked after this command. You mention firmware being erased. Is it not possible to install that again? I'm in no way trying to mixed up in all af this, but I would like to know. Is it really completely bricked forever and ever (or at least an almost equivalent degree) or is it possible for a user to salvage the wreckage?

Edit: Oh, the hell with it. i might as well say my piece. I don't really like Mac. I'm sure it's an okay computer but I don't want one. The times I've tried them and had to work on them I've felt constrained. It seemed I had very little freedom. But that may just be me, so anyone should go ahead and get one if they feel like it. I just never will.
That being said, the ads are not helping to bring me over. Infact they do the oposite. They alienate me from the Mac userbase and the brand as a whole. By watching a Mac ad I don't think: "Oh, Mac sure seems like a good system." No, I end up thinking: "Man, what a bunch of half truths and blatant lies." They really don't give me any reasons to buy the thing. They just lie to me. How is that going to win me over?

As I understand it, it's bricked. It takes a factory reinstall to get the system to work again.

Must try that command out properly on my Linux test system, although I reckon in the case of Linux, and that machine, that it would only need a re-installation in order to work. I could also do it on a virtual machine, but that doesn't have any firmware, and would only lead to the equivalent of a "format c:".

I'm pretty sure that most firmware is in ROM for that very reason. BIOS memory is on flash ROM, as is some of the firmware on a modern graphics card, but I'll be using a test system with a 4MB ATI Rage 3D, so no flash firmware there.

Gone Gonzo
Posts: 2142
Joined: 23 Dec 2007

I like the way microsoft almost had a direct response of "I'm a pc (scene switches to giant boxer) Got a problem with that?"

Paperboy
Posts: 16
Joined: 16 Dec 2008

Would it not be funny to go into a big retail store like best buy in the computer department And yell really loud at people looking at macs Saying MACS SUCK!!!!!!!
lol That would be funny but i would never do it

 (Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7)
Topic Index

Reply to Thread

You must be logged in to post.
Username:  
Password:  
  

Not registered? Sign up for a free account!

Forum Jump: