$2.50 Reviews: Eastern Promises (2007)

$2.50 Reviews:

Eastern Promises

image

After teaming up with Viggo Mortensen in 2005's A History of Violence, director David Cronenberg decided that since he did a good job in that film, that using him again would be a good idea. This time, Mortensen plays the driver and undertaker for a Russian mob family. They've done some things they would rather not reveal to the police, so when the half-Russian Anna Khitrova (Naomi Watts) starts snooping around with a diary of a 14-year-old prostitute, they become worried.

I kind of want to know what that motion means.<br />Then again...

As with many Cronenberg movies, the plot isn't entirely complex. The basic plot structure has been used quite often. This isn't all that important though, as it means that the film can do a better job focusing on its characters, as opposed to an intricate plot. Nikolai Luzhin is the character played by Mortensen, and he is an interesting character. He commands the screen every time he is on it. He's a quiet character, who has many subtleties to him. The rest of the Russian mob isn't as entertaining, but since Nikolai is almost always on the screen at the same time, they don't really matter. Unfortunately, Anna's character did seem underutilized. Watts doesn't get much to work with in terms of her character, and doesn't appear anywhere near as often after the first half hour or so. She still manages to play a big role in the plot, but most of the screen time goes to the Russian mobsters.

Speaking of the Russians, almost 1/3 of the dialogue of the film is in Russian. None of the lead actors are Russian, meaning that they are speaking in a dialect not native to them. In this regard, all the actors do an amazing job. It might just be due to the fact that I don't speak Russian, but I would never have been able to tell that they were putting the accent on. Even when conversing in English, the accents seemed nearly flawless, with the only issue being some of the words spoken in too soft a tone to pick up properly.

Eastern Promises has been noted for a few things. One of these is its accurate portrayal of Russian mobs. Mortensen actually went and talked with real gangsters in order to research the tattoos used in the film. The film feels authentic in the way it portrays the life of a mobster. From the way they talk to the way they act, it all seems believable. The only part that seemed off was during some scenes, where there were only Russians, it would have seemed more realistic to have them speak Russian. They switch back and forth, and dwell primarily in the English side of dialogue. I know that it is marketed internationally, and to many people, reading subtitles is undesirable, but it takes away a slight bit of the authenticity the film strives for. Not a big chunk, mind, but enough to be noticeable.

Because he doesn't look creepy at all, just standing there like that...

Another thing that Eastern Promises has been praised for is the plot twist it has near the end of the film. This is the biggest thing the film comes to having a big problem. I didn't find it surprising in the least, as it is hinted at again and again throughout the film. When it came, it felt anticlimactic, and it didn't do what a good twist should do. It barely had any change on the characters, it didn't change the previous plot any, and it didn't affect the perspective of the audience. It makes the film a slight bit more interesting, but that's it. It could have been revealed at the start, and just seeing the transformations of characters would be interesting by itself. It's not a terrible twist, but it felt unnecessary. The only thing it does is make the ending ambiguous, something that I am thankful for.

Too often are endings completely finite in their conclusion. There are many times in which nothing is left up to the imagination of the viewer. Eastern Promises goes the opposite route; it makes you think about the characters at its conclusion. You aren't quite sure where they all end up in life, and in the case of Nikolai especially, you never get to know what his background is. This makes him even more interesting, as not knowing what he went through before this film fits its theme perfectly.

Eastern Promises isn't your standard film. The plot is basic, and doesn't try to do anything that hasn't been done before, but the true beauty of the film lies in its characters, Nikolai especially. He's an incredibly interesting character, whose background is never revealed. This makes him even more enticing, and the acting done by Viggo Mortensen is definitely deserving of the Oscar Nomination he got for the role. His Russian seems great, and his accent is nearly flawless. The twist ending could have been better, but it does allow the film to lead up to a satisfactory conclusion.

If you are a fan of my reviews, and you want to boost my ego receive notifications when new reviews are posted, please join this user group.

Great review. I've been wanting to see this film for a while, just haven't gotten around to doing it. I'll go to the blockbuster soon.

Great stuff Marter! This review really worked for me. I didn't catch any errors either. Again, you're sounding very sure of what you're saying, which is reassuring to read.
And you removed the credits box

It's been a while since I've seen this film, but I've been thinking about re-watching it with a History of Violence (which I haven't seen yet).

Another very accurate review notched on your sleeve.

Viggo Mortensen's perfromance is really the only tentpole that keeps this movie upright. I would almost compare it to Anthony Hopkins in Silence of The Lambs, though that movie had a lot more going in its favor.

Marter:
This is the biggest thing the film comes to having a big problem.

That probably could have been phrased better. Apart from that the review was awful and you fail lolololololol. By which I mean good.

For some odd reason I have had no inclination to watch this until now. I may have to go looking for it tomorrow.

voetballeeuw:
I'll go to the blockbuster soon.

zombiesinc:
It's been a while since I've seen this film, but I've been thinking about re-watching it with a History of Violence (which I haven't seen yet).

Yeah, you both go watch it! (And zombie...give A History of Violence a shot) :)

Marter:

zombiesinc:
It's been a while since I've seen this film, but I've been thinking about re-watching it with a History of Violence (which I haven't seen yet).

Yeah, you both go watch it! (And zombie...give A History of Violence a shot) :)

It's been on my ever-growing to-watch list! It isn't available on Netflix *sigh* but I'll watch it soon enough!

zombiesinc:
It's been on my ever-growing to-watch list! It isn't available on Netflix *sigh* but I'll watch it soon enough!

My list is ever-growing as well...sucks, doesn't it?

Although, always having something to watch is a good thing, I guess.

Marter:
My list is ever-growing as well...sucks, doesn't it?

Sucks because I simply won't always have the time to watch as many as I'd like. >.<

Although, always having something to watch is a good thing, I guess.

I've fallen into the routine of watching at least one film a night. But it seems more than one film is added to my list every day. :o

zombiesinc:
I've fallen into the routine of watching at least one film a night.

I'm in that routine as well.

But I'm reviewing one each day as well...=p

Marter:

zombiesinc:
I've fallen into the routine of watching at least one film a night.

I'm in that routine as well.

But I'm reviewing one each day as well...=p

SINCE WHEN?! O.O

I jest, I jest ;)

A great review, but I disliked this film. Cronenberg...go back to body horror!!! Ah jokes...he can do whatever he wants. But both collaborations with Viggo I didn't enjoy.

zombiesinc:
SINCE WHEN?! O.O

I jest, I jest ;)

Since mid-late August. :p

Although, I haven't always gotten to one each day, I still try.

zombiesinc:

Marter:

zombiesinc:
It's been a while since I've seen this film, but I've been thinking about re-watching it with a History of Violence (which I haven't seen yet).

Yeah, you both go watch it! (And zombie...give A History of Violence a shot) :)

It's been on my ever-growing to-watch list! It isn't available on Netflix *sigh* but I'll watch it soon enough!

Bah! You kids think you have it all with your gosh darn Netflix.

superbatranger:
*rant snip*

If it makes you feel any better, I don't use Netflix.

Marter:

superbatranger:
*rant snip*

If it makes you feel any better, I don't use Netflix.

Well, you have the choice. But, with piracy as bad as it is here, it's not that surprising. It irks me, but it's not surprising.

 

Reply to Thread

This thread is locked