Rate the song above you!

 Pages 1 2 NEXT
 

Alright, this works like this:

Rate the song above you (which requires you to actually listen to it) on a scale from 1 to 10 with a short reasoning, then post a song from YouTube. I'll get this going.

Already love butterflies and hurricanes so a 9.

chosen as the song I was already listening to as I opened this forum

Wouldn't let me listen to it so I'll just give it a (two) It's not the best thing I have never heard, but it's not the worst thing that I have ever heard either.

EDIT: this is for the first song.

For the record you accidentally double posted this forum.

other http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/18.317170-Rate-the-song-above-you

Freakout456:
Already love butterflies and hurricanes so a 9.

chosen as the song I was already listening to as I opened this forum

7 or an 8. I've never heard that song before. I gotta find more about that band.

Anyway here's a song that youtube that really deserves more views.

Freakout456:
Already love butterflies and hurricanes so a 9.

chosen as the song I was already listening to as I opened this forum

Very nice, I need to look into this band. I'm assuming we're going on a traditional 10 point scale? If so, solid 8.5

My contribution:

Great band, great song.


Edit: Song above me changed. Enjoyable. I'll give it a 7.

Too slow and melancholy for my taste. I give it a 3, maybe a 4.

Yokai:
Snip

This is pretty good actually, I was prepared for something soulless and chaotic with no melody, but that's not what I got! Pretty much the opposite, in fact. Thanks for showing me this excellent music, 8.5/10

EDIT: In the case of these really long songs, I don't think anyone would mind if you listened to a 4+ minute selection. In the case of the above, I'd advise skipping to about 03:26

Metalhandkerchief:
snip

I wasn't impressed with that one. The songs lacked enough variety to carry itself for 10mins.

3-4

dantoddd:

I wasn't impressed with that one. The songs lacked enough variety to carry itself for 10mins.

3-4

surprisingly enjoyable 8/10
dont know how to embed videos so ill just post the link
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hnCw1zXtaLs&feature=relmfu

Darth Carr:

dantoddd:

I wasn't impressed with that one. The songs lacked enough variety to carry itself for 10mins.

3-4

surprisingly enjoyable 8/10
dont know how to embed videos so ill just post the link
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hnCw1zXtaLs&feature=relmfu

I'd give it a 8.

Darth Carr:

dont know how to embed videos so ill just post the link
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hnCw1zXtaLs&feature=relmfu

pretty bland boilerplate electro imo i'll give it a 4.5/10

i'm gonna go with something educational! listen and be enlightened!

walrusaurus:

Darth Carr:

dont know how to embed videos so ill just post the link
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hnCw1zXtaLs&feature=relmfu

pretty bland boilerplate electro imo i'll give it a 4.5/10

i'm gonna go with something educational! listen and be enlightened!

I beat you to that song by one minute :P

6 out of 10. Highly educational and catchy, but I feel would be better if I understood the subject matter more.
Forgot how to embed

Meh. 6/10. Not much into that kind of music. Personal tastes.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PHhox4_SeHQ

edit: can't get video to work properly

edit 2: video above me changed

walrusaurus:

Darth Carr:

dont know how to embed videos so ill just post the link
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hnCw1zXtaLs&feature=relmfu

pretty bland boilerplate electro imo i'll give it a 4.5/10

i'm gonna go with something educational! listen and be enlightened!

Thought it'd be the usual dry affair, actually pretty cool. 7/10 because I learnt something!
No idea how to embed, damn.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wWTAkBRe6aI

7/10

@Kenbo Slice: 7/10 it's a good track as far as hardcore/metal goes, not my style though. I tend to gravitate towards more European bands for this type of music as the American ones has some weird resemblance to teen pop no matter how "hard" they are... EDIT: This was for "Sinner"...

@Walrusaurus: lol. Interesting... I really can't say more than that. 6/10

SO MANY POSTS in too short amount of time! >_<

I am Vulgaris Magistralis
and on a Mammoth I ride around

teh_Canape:

I am Vulgaris Magistralis
and on a Mammoth I ride around

5/10, not a fan of the vocal style, has some catchy riffs tho

opeth1989:

5/10, not a fan of the vocal style, has some catchy riffs tho

that's kinda the point, it's sort of a parody song
like, a heavy metal Weird Al

opeth1989:

teh_Canape:

I am Vulgaris Magistralis
and on a Mammoth I ride around

5/10, not a fan of the vocal style, has some catchy riffs tho

10/10 Opeth is pretty amazing.

9/10, always been a fan of Opeth.

opeth1989:

teh_Canape:

I am Vulgaris Magistralis
and on a Mammoth I ride around

5/10, not a fan of the vocal style, has some catchy riffs tho

Considering how every post is about a minute after the last one, I dunno if people are actually listening to these songs..

Umm.... Shouldn't this be in the Forum games section?

6/10 i liked the guitar but not the vocals

That Helloween song has been a regular at parties up where I live for ages!!! 11/10! lol (Though the Sonata Arctica version is better IMO DON'T SHOOT MEH)

EDIT: I've created a monster...
._.

--

2/10 I hate screamo with a passion...

7/8 I kinda liked it

Sacman:
2/10 I hate screamo with a passion...

7/10. It was pretty solid, but to be honest I could barely understand what he was saying. I've only heard a little Dinosaur Jr. so I can't judge it off other songs.

@Unicorn; a solid 7.5/10 It's got a very upbeat sense to it, I like it.

unicron44:

Sacman:
2/10 I hate screamo with a passion...

7/10. It was pretty solid, but to be honest I could barely understand what he was saying. I've only heard a little Dinosaur Jr. so I can't judge it off other songs.

It's cool when they play live their instruments are so loud it makes the singing pretty much inaudible, especially bass heavy songs...<.<

OT: 8/10 quite good... never heard of them before...<.<

Hardly his best rendition, vocally but I think more people would appreciate the guitar work more than the straight acoustic...<.<

Also whatever effect he's using sounds like it's trying to tear my eyes out...

Edit: To the person directly above me...

6/10 I liked the sound but it's quite repetitive and insubstantial...<.<

unicron44:

Not quite my style, but not the worse thing I've heard either, I'll give it a 5/10

 Pages 1 2 NEXT

Reply to Thread

This thread is locked