No Right Answer: Best TV Doctor

 Pages 1 2 3 NEXT
 

Best TV Doctor

If you've been transported into TV ala "Pleasantville" rules, and you need to see a doctor fast, who do you want covered by your insurance? The boys debate whether Dr. House or Dr. Cox is the one to probe their rears for the cure.

Watch Video

You're BOTH wrong! The best doctor is of course, this guy.

I'd have to say David Tennant.

Don't know what it is but when I first saw the title, I immediately thought this would be a debate on their favorite version of Dr.Who...

OT: I'd go with the medical equivalent of Sherlock Holmes myself.

EDIT: Ha! looks like I'm not the only one who thought this way.

Agree with the 4 guys above me on all counts. Also, since the Doctor always has a sidekick, the perfect companion for this conundrum is Dr. Martha Jones

David Tennant....hands down.

ALLONS-Y!

Tony Tony Chopper: Best. Doctor. Ever!

Upon reading the title I was expecting a Doctor Who video but this is still good. You made good points on both doctors.

SomeLameStuff:
You're BOTH wrong! The best doctor is of course, this guy.

Damn, beaten to it. Anyway, both sides invalid, the best doctor is of course The Doctor.

I'm gonna go ahead and say what everyone else is saying....The best TV Doctor is obviously THE Doctor.

But in that debate, the right answer was Dr. Cox.

I'm going to cut slack and take the video's title as "Best TV Medical Doctor" rather than "Best TV Doctor". Because obviously with the latter title you are to paraphrase one of the contenders.

Wrong wrong Wrong wrong... Wrong WRONG wrong wrong, Your wrong, Your wrong.

Dr. Cox and doctor House were actually the first two doctors that popped into my head when I saw this title. Weird. I'd like doctor Cox much more, personally.

SomeLameStuff:
You're BOTH wrong! The best doctor is of course, this guy.

They said it to begin with "Who, Is The Best Doctor."

And damn you for the ninja. ;)

Sylvester McCoy.

That is all.

I would toss in a vote for THE Doctor. I do love him so.

However, if we're talking strictly medical doctors from medical shows, I'll vote Dr. Gregory House hands down every time.

I hope the Escapist PAID for this episode!

OT: The BEST Dr is McCoy!

Give me Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman, any day.

Yow!

Dr. House dammit!

Okay, I like the show, but would NEVER want to be treated by Dr. House.

Okay, sometimes it's a patient that get referred to (dumped on) House because every other doctor in the state has given up and they're going to die anyway. But all too often it's because Cuddy has force House into clinic duty and he's bored or high and decides that the patient with a minor cough doesn't just need some Robitussin, but finds some insignificant rash which Dr. House thinks must be the sign of something terrible. So he immediately admits the patient and starts a course of treatment which results in vomiting blood and a coma. It won't be until after they've removed the patient's spleen and amputated a leg that they stumble on the real cause of the rash and send them off to live happily ever after with their new prosthesis. The reaction is always, "Thank you for saving my life." Rather than, "Was that rash really that dangerous?" Of course the answer is, "As far as you know, and Cuddy will back me up. Not just because I'm boning her, but she knows this place would be shut down in a heartbeat if anyone ever got the idea they could file a malpractice suit for the Mengele-like treatment I give my patients."

I want a doctor like Martin Ellingham. "Go home. Eat right. Get some rest. And stay out of my surgery unless you have a real medical problem.'

Yup there's only one doctor...The Doctor.

Wow, we totally didn't realize how everyone would assume we were talking about Dr. Who instead of medical doctors. Sound off if you want us to do an episode on THE doctor, and which two choices we should debate with!

This video though us all a very important lesson. Kyle likes cox.

PotatoeMan:
This video though us all a very important lesson. Kyle likes cox.

This made me laugh more than I'm proud of.

+1 to the mass of posters who vote for The Doctor.

Firefilm:
Wow, we totally didn't realize how everyone would assume we were talking about Dr. Who instead of medical doctors. Sound off if you want us to do an episode on THE doctor, and which two choices we should debate with!

Yes Please. And try to settle the "Matt Smith vs. David Tennant" debate within that topic. Maybe if I have more people on my side, those Tennant loyalists will stop complaining whenever I mention how much I like Matt Smith.

*not petty or vindictive at all*

As the best medical doctor, I like Dr.Cox from scrubs, and as the best Doctor who, I like Christopher Eccleston.

Christopher Eccleston.

DOCTOR WHO.....no other Doctor can compare

I think the best doctor to treat me would be a medical doctor.

mew4ever23:

SomeLameStuff:
You're BOTH wrong! The best doctor is of course, this guy.

Damn, beaten to it. Anyway, both sides invalid, the best doctor is of course The Doctor.

Agreed. And if I had a choice of nurse, I would choose between these two:

mastermerrick:

Agreed. And if I had a choice of nurse, I would choose between these two:

I hope someday to meet you in glory of battle where I will crush the life from your worthless human form. Try and get some rest.

1: Yeah, should have seen the Doctor Who response coming... I was expecting 1 or 2, but not nearly the entire response page. Still, I'd like to see that in another video.

2: Out of the choices given: tough choice, but I gotta go with Doctor House.

3: Personal choice: Tony Tony Chopper from One Piece. We're going by anime logic, so band-aids heal everything.

InterAirplay:

Firefilm:
Wow, we totally didn't realize how everyone would assume we were talking about Dr. Who instead of medical doctors. Sound off if you want us to do an episode on THE doctor, and which two choices we should debate with!

Yes Please. And try to settle the "Matt Smith vs. David Tennant" debate within that topic. Maybe if I have more people on my side, those Tennant loyalists will stop complaining whenever I mention how much I like Matt Smith.

*not petty or vindictive at all*

Okay, the David Tennant vs. Matt Smith debate would be (at best) who's the 2nd best Doctor (or 3rd if you ask David Tennant because he'd probably put Peter Davidson 1st). Because everyone knows, no one can challenge the greatness that is Tom Baker.

Who is Doctor Cox? I've never heard of him.

After a Google search, I now know about a few porn flicks, and I guess he's from a show called Scrubs.

Dr. Simon Tam is the best T.V. Doctor ever. If you have to Google that name, shame on you.

anyone else think they were talking about Doctor Who?
I was dissapointed

 Pages 1 2 3 NEXT

Reply to Thread

Log in or Register to Comment
Have an account? Login below:
With Facebook:Login With Facebook
or
Username:  
Password:  
  
Not registered? To sign up for an account with The Escapist:
Register With Facebook
Register With Facebook
or
Registered for a free account here