The Largest Constructed Magic Tournament Ever

The Largest Constructed Magic Tournament Ever

GP Richmond set the record for largest constructed Magic tournament.

Read Full Article

Maybe it's just how the photos were, but everyone looks really unhappy to be there lol.
Well, you say you had fun so that's good :)

Every time i think of getting into modern properly i just see the price of fetches and the massive price-spikes recently of cards after banndings/ unbannings and it really puts me off. If wizards really wants to format to take off in the card shops and at the local level it needs to re-print more modern staples. Here in the UK modern isn't widespread at all and that's because not many people have any kind of access to the cards needed to build a viable top level modern deck.

i still can't get into it.... (modern that is)
let's talk about the superior maser format,
EDH.
anyone, anyone?

Weaver:
Maybe it's just how the photos were, but everyone looks really unhappy to be there lol.
Well, you say you had fun so that's good :)

Well I was trying to not get in folks faces, so most people are likely thinking. It's also about getting paired with the right players at the right time. Round 9 my opponent and I got quite jokey about us playing non-interactive magic (Storm vs Hexproof) while the players to our left were playing a GW mirror and were mock sports announcing each other's plays.

Scrumpmonkey:
Every time i think of getting into modern properly i just see the price of fetches and the massive price-spikes recently of cards after banndings/ unbannings and it really puts me off. If wizards really wants to format to take off in the card shops and at the local level it needs to re-print more modern staples. Here in the UK modern isn't widespread at all and that's because not many people have any kind of access to the cards needed to build a viable top level modern deck.

Personally what I think WotC should do is re-print the Onslaught fecthes in a upcoming Standard set. M15 might be nice because it would allow a brief window of letting non-older format players experience fetches and shocks. Not only will this help to alleviate the pressure on the Zendikar fetches, bringing prices down without tanking them, but it also makes certain color combinations in Modern less awkward.

Slycne:

Scrumpmonkey:
Every time i think of getting into modern properly i just see the price of fetches and the massive price-spikes recently of cards after banndings/ unbannings and it really puts me off. If wizards really wants to format to take off in the card shops and at the local level it needs to re-print more modern staples. Here in the UK modern isn't widespread at all and that's because not many people have any kind of access to the cards needed to build a viable top level modern deck.

Personally what I think WotC should do is re-print the Onslaught fecthes in a upcoming Standard set. M15 might be nice because it would allow a brief window of letting non-older format players experience fetches and shocks. Not only will this help to alleviate the pressure on the Zendikar fetches, bringing prices down without tanking them, but it also makes certain color combinations in Modern less awkward.

I agree that the onslaught fetches seem like a very strange omission. Personally i don't like fetches, i agree with the "Loading Screen" criticism in that they only seem to serve to add more needless setup and shuffling to competitive play. They either need to re-print a full compliment of fetches in a set everyone has easy access to and that would bring the onslaught fetches into modern or they need to ban fetches. Re-printing them in something like a commander set for instance would make those decks silly expensive (again) and also wouldn't fix the modern playable absence problem.

I don't think people can really complain even if Wizards does tank the value of fetches because if they remain in the format they are an essential part of almost every single competitive deck. They made sol-ring extremely common to help make commander possible for example.

Having land bases that make up the bulk of a deck's price is bad for the format. It's not like they're reprinting dual lands here; modern is supposed to be the flagship non-rotating format. They've already given us two blocks containing all the shocklands.

Scrumpmonkey:
snip

I would disagree on fetches only being a hindrance to competitive play. There's plenty of little tricks and interactions even outside of Brainstorm formats with an on demand shuffle/tutor. Like for instance psuedo-scry by fetching in response to the Delver of Secret trigger or currently Blood Moon is seeing a lot more play so knowing what to fetch is important. On the simplest level, more decisions make for more interesting and skillful play.

Ultimately the math behind raw demand will always make the land bases the bulk of any non-mono color decks price and there's really no way around that. Not every UW deck wants to run Supreme Verdict or even the full 4, but every single one wants a playset of Hallowed Fountain.

Slycne:

Scrumpmonkey:
snip

I would disagree on fetches only being a hindrance to competitive play. There's plenty of little tricks and interactions even outside of Brainstorm formats with an on demand shuffle/tutor. Like for instance psuedo-scry by fetching in response to the Delver of Secret trigger or currently Blood Moon is seeing a lot more play so knowing what to fetch is important. On the simplest level, more decisions make for more interesting and skillful play.

Ultimately the math behind raw demand will always make the land bases the bulk of any non-mono color decks price and there's really no way around that. Not every UW deck wants to run Supreme Verdict or even the full 4, but every single one wants a playset of Hallowed Fountain.

Hallowed Fountain is a $10 card though. You can get it in the Theros Even deck. Misty Rainforest is an $80-$100 card. This isn't very tenable.

I don't think they are only a hindrance, i do get their usefulness and some of their interactions and i understand why they are such powerful cards and integral to the format in some ways. But as they stand they are also a massive barrier to entry in terms of cost and a bit of a time-wasting annoyance. Watching some MTG matches in the eternal formats is just a shuffle-a-thon. It can be really baffling to newer players especially.

Also whist I'm in angry old man mode Miracles+Brainstorm=TOTAL BULLSHIT :P

Scrumpmonkey:
Hallowed Fountain is a $10 card though. You can get it in the Theros Even deck. Misty Rainforest is an $80-$100 card. This isn't very tenable.

Wasn't referring specifically to the price, but the nature and ratio that lands are almost always going to be the most expensive cards regardless simply due to the quantity of decks that want a playset of the lands versus any specifically powerful spell. Supreme Verdict is to Hallowed Fountain as Cryptic Command is to Scalding Tarn. Shock lands were once $50, and they will indeed start growing again once they rotate out of Standard - after the initial flood settles.

A lot of the issue currently with Zenidkar fetches is that the player base for Magic has roughly doubled since that block. There just isn't enough of those cards to go around. It's also worth noting that we're currently seeing the spike on fetches. After Pro-Tour into GP Richmond into the upcoming Modern PTQ season, Modern staples are inflated.

Also whist I'm in angry old man mode Miracles+Brainstorm=TOTAL BULLSHIT :P

Heh, that's nothing. The real Legacy version of that deck is Counterbalance + Sensei's Divining Top + miracles. That's a deck that actually takes tons of time to shuffle, look at cards, etc.

Slycne:
Personally what I think WotC should do is re-print the Onslaught fecthes in a upcoming Standard set. M15 might be nice because it would allow a brief window of letting non-older format players experience fetches and shocks. Not only will this help to alleviate the pressure on the Zendikar fetches, bringing prices down without tanking them, but it also makes certain color combinations in Modern less awkward.

Well, if I was to start the Rumor-O-Tron again, and repeat the last theories I heard on Reddit, the best time to reprint all the fetches (ALL o' dems) would be in the next block (Huey). Most people think Wizards won't want to put them into a core set, since it's generally used as an intro-to-magic set (and land that doesn't produce mana is confusing), and they will want to print all of them at the same time (someone tweeted about wanting to print full dual land cycles only once).

So, if I've got my (totally unverified by anyone ever) rumors correct: All of the fetches will be reprinted in the next set, to go along with the scry lands. This would keep Standard really balanced, lower the prices of current fetches (I am officially scared to take them out of my house at this point), move the Onslaught fetches to modern, and allow them to make more landfall cards/reprint Cosi's Trickster (you know, if they wanted... I wouldn't argue...).

Catrixa:
Well, if I was to start the Rumor-O-Tron again, and repeat the last theories I heard on Reddit, the best time to reprint all the fetches (ALL o' dems) would be in the next block (Huey). Most people think Wizards won't want to put them into a core set, since it's generally used as an intro-to-magic set (and land that doesn't produce mana is confusing), and they will want to print all of them at the same time (someone tweeted about wanting to print full dual land cycles only once).

So, if I've got my (totally unverified by anyone ever) rumors correct: All of the fetches will be reprinted in the next set, to go along with the scry lands. This would keep Standard really balanced, lower the prices of current fetches (I am officially scared to take them out of my house at this point), move the Onslaught fetches to modern, and allow them to make more landfall cards/reprint Cosi's Trickster (you know, if they wanted... I wouldn't argue...).

It's certainly possible, but then again the fetch reprint rumormill and theorizing is secondary to only Half Life 3 these days. It's going to happen eventually, but I'm more or less in "I'll believe it when I see it" mode. On the plus side, I got quite the laugh out of finally double sleeving my fecthes this week. It meant really protecting some pretty hilarious cards also in the decks.

Don't worry Slippery Bogle, now you're extra safe!

Catrixa:
Cosi's Trickster

I nominate Aven Mindcensor for a reprint instead.

Slycne:
It's certainly possible, but then again the fetch reprint rumormill and theorizing is secondary to only Half Life 3 these days. It's going to happen eventually, but I'm more or less in "I'll believe it when I see it" mode. On the plus side, I got quite the laugh out of finally double sleeving my fecthes this week. It meant really protecting some pretty hilarious cards also in the decks.

Don't worry Slippery Bogle, now you're extra safe!

Catrixa:
Cosi's Trickster

I nominate Aven Mindcensor for a reprint instead.

I was just thinking of random stuff (mostly "please reprint Steppe Lynx in a set with fetches" on repeat), but yeah, Mindcensor definitely needs it the most. I dunno, I'd take the manlands cycle too (and maybe some new enemy ones?), but I'd bet it'll be something that doesn't come into play tapped all the time. I guess they could not print any duals in the next block, but that seems really unlikely.

 

Reply to Thread

Log in or Register to Comment
Have an account? Login below:
With Facebook:Login With Facebook
or
Username:  
Password:  
  
Not registered? To sign up for an account with The Escapist:
Register With Facebook
Register With Facebook
or
Register for a free account here