Game Theory: Until Dawn's Tragic Hero

Until Dawn's Tragic Hero

Until Dawn is all about making sure you make the right choices to make it out alive... But what if the most important character in the game is the only one who gets NO CHOICE in whether they live or die. What does that mean for you playing the game? What does that say about the game itself? Get ready for a completely new understanding of Until Dawn! (plus a few spoilers!)

Watch Video

I was never keen on how fast the game was to declare josh evil and be done with it, nor how easy it was to miss the clues that showed you just how far gone he truly was.

This was a great video. I don't own a PS4 so I had to watch a walkthrough of this game. Unfortunately the person who was playing didn't find the psychiatrist notes, so I really didn't grasp how bad Josh's condition was until those hallucinations he sees towards the end. I feel games like Until Dawn, Life is Strange, and Spec Ops: The Line all have underlying messages in them that try to draw attention to mental health issues, which is definitely a good thing.

flying_whimsy:
Everyone else would end up with manslaughter charges for the sisters.

Just saying, Matt was a part of that group (he's the one with the selfie stick), while both Chris and Sam were elsewhere in the house when the prank happened (Sam was trying to find Hannah to warn her, Chris was passed out with Josh).

OT: I thought this video was great. Josh definitely struck me as a tragic character when I saw it the first time and its cool to see his condition broken down like that.

On a related note, there is actually a psychological condition where one believes that they're turning into a Wendigo. It's rare but has been found among Amerindian populations that have Wendigo legends.

The process of becoming a Wendigo sounds kind of mental-disorder-esque. Unlike most monsters which require physical contact with the creature to become one (virus metaphors), becoming a Wendigo only requires that you resort to cannibalism. So Hannah is rejected by her peers and abandoned by everyone who she cared about. She becomes sick and, desperate to survive, does anything that will help her continue living. Gradually, she becomes unable to control her actions and seeks the destruction of the relationships she once held dear (notice that she doesn't eat the kids, just kills them when she captures them). At this point, there is no saving her, no finding the Hannah that once existed.

It sounds like a very extreme case of depression that was left untreated if you take away the monster parts of it.

flying_whimsy:

I was never keen on how fast the game was to declare josh evil and be done with it, nor how easy it was to miss the clues that showed you just how far gone he truly was.

Not sure how you got that out of the story:

flying_whimsy:

I was never keen on how fast the game was to declare josh evil and be done with it, nor how easy it was to miss the clues that showed you just how far gone he truly was.

So, why is Josh innocent for his prank getting people murdered but the Beth/Hannah prank manslaughter? How is it any different besides Josh being loopier than a hula hoop? Josh being insane doesn't get him off the hook for the much more extreme "pranks" he tries to pull.

Not to mention that realistically even if there were only blanks in the gun, putting it directly to your skin and firing would have killed Chris. Who was also passed out drunk with Josh and thus shouldn't be involved in the revenge scheme anyways.

EyeReaper:
Not to mention that realistically even if there were only blanks in the gun, putting it directly to your skin and firing would have killed Chris. Who was also passed out drunk with Josh and thus shouldn't be involved in the revenge scheme anyways.

Can that actually kill you though? Because if it's just hot exhaust fumes the worst it could do is burn your skin, or blind you should you fire it in your eye (thank you, In Bruges). Not that I'm an expert on blanks or hot gas.

Casual Shinji:
Can that actually kill you though?

It was how Bruce Lee's son Brandon died filming the movie "The Crow". Granted it wasn't so simple as shooting it right into his skin, but it can still be deadly.

Casual Shinji:

EyeReaper:
Not to mention that realistically even if there were only blanks in the gun, putting it directly to your skin and firing would have killed Chris. Who was also passed out drunk with Josh and thus shouldn't be involved in the revenge scheme anyways.

Can that actually kill you though? Because if it's just hot exhaust fumes the worst it could do is burn your skin, or blind you should you fire it in your eye (thank you, In Bruges). Not that I'm an expert on blanks or hot gas.

Quite a few cases of people offing themselves like that actually. The pressure would have shattered Chris' skull in that area and propelled shards into his brain.

MC1980:

Casual Shinji:
Can that actually kill you though? Because if it's just hot exhaust fumes the worst it could do is burn your skin, or blind you should you fire it in your eye (thank you, In Bruges). Not that I'm an expert on blanks or hot gas.

Quite a few cases of people offing themselves like that actually. The pressure would have shattered Chris' skull in that area and propelled shards into his brain.

But then how do they film suicide or execution scenes in movies? There have been numerous movies were someone has a gun to their head, which is then fired. If blanks truly are that lethal you'd think they would never dare film a sequence like that. They're obviously using some pyrotechnics that are completely harmless. And I assume that's what Josh used for his pranks, because his dad is a bigshot from Hollywood.

Casual Shinji:

MC1980:

Casual Shinji:
Can that actually kill you though? Because if it's just hot exhaust fumes the worst it could do is burn your skin, or blind you should you fire it in your eye (thank you, In Bruges). Not that I'm an expert on blanks or hot gas.

Quite a few cases of people offing themselves like that actually. The pressure would have shattered Chris' skull in that area and propelled shards into his brain.

But then how do they film suicide or execution scenes in movies? There have been numerous movies were someone has a gun to their head, which is then fired. If blanks truly are that lethal you'd think they would never dare film a sequence like that. They're obviously using some pyrotechnics that are completely harmless. And I assume that's what Josh used for his pranks, because his dad is a bigshot from Hollywood.

There are a few different kinds of prop guns used in movies. Blank-fire guns are the most common, basically real guns that have been slightly modified to fire blanks, and are lethal when misused. There are also function guns (very realistic looking for closeups, but incapable of firing anything) and rubber guns for when you need a bunch of cheap guns to be held by goons. There are specially made suicide guns, with sealed barrels, that do not create a muzzle flash (that's added in post) and cannot fire anything out of the barrel, neither a round nor gases; they just bang and expel the expended cartridge.

Based on the fact that Chris didn't die, we can assume that Josh gave him a suicide gun, but it's still dangerous (they have failed in the past, and you always have a weapons master check over the guns before they're used on set). If you told me that a deranged man had acquired a suicide gun and loaded it (suicide guns require special blanks, btw, not the standard 5 in 1s) I wouldn't want it anywhere near me, despite the class of weapon being generally safe. Even if the weapon itself was correctly prepared, there is still a lot of hot pressurized gas coming out of the extractor along with the spent casing, and Chris (who IIRC had put the gun under his chin) might have seriously burned his throat and injured his trachea. For shots like that, it's a lot easier and safer to have someone put a function gun under their chin, the director yells bang, and they make it look real in post-production.

Thunderous Cacophony:
and Chris (who IIRC had put the gun under his chin) might have seriously burned his throat and injured his trachea.

Casual Shinji:
snip

For some reason I misremembered him holding the gun to the side of his head, instead of his throat. My bad on that one. Also, just rewatched the scene and saw there was no muzzle flash or smoke coming from the barrel of the gun, so yeah, you're most likely correct about it being one of those gimmick guns. Looks like the makers of the game were more knowledgable than me. (Go figure, right?)

EternallyBored:

flying_whimsy:

I was never keen on how fast the game was to declare josh evil and be done with it, nor how easy it was to miss the clues that showed you just how far gone he truly was.

Not sure how you got that out of the story:

I wouldn't say it killed the sympathy for him. You can still feel bad for what happened to him and his sisters but at the same time dislike him for what he did.

I think we can both agree that everyone in the game is a horrible person and they all deserve to get punched in the face a few times.

Patinator:

Casual Shinji:
Can that actually kill you though?

It was how Bruce Lee's son Brandon died filming the movie "The Crow". Granted it wasn't so simple as shooting it right into his skin, but it can still be deadly.

Well, wasn't the whole issue that there was a bullet stuck in the prop-gun's barrel that basically ended up being helped along by the blank, rather than the blank being at fault? Blanks can still be dangerous, but that's kind of like slipping on a well-waxed floor and landing in a bed of spikes. Sure, the slip on the floor could have gone pretty badly even without that bed of spikes, but something that's already lethal to begin with being in the mix kind of skews things.

The whole business of Brandon's death just makes me cringe harder the more I hear about the comedy of errors behind it. Using live rounds to create dummy rounds instead of actually getting/creating actual dummy rounds, sheesh.

 

Reply to Thread

Log in or Register to Comment
Have an account? Login below:
With Facebook:Login With Facebook
or
Username:  
Password:  
  
Not registered? To sign up for an account with The Escapist:
Register With Facebook
Register With Facebook
or
Register for a free account here