| (Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4) | |
No! It's about you being in the game. Think about it, your blood or heart being transferred into a person from the past, that could, ooh say, be featured in a FUCKING GAME! Besides, this is just Sony in that region, not all of Sony. | |
They're off their meds again, huh? I knew it couldn't last. | |
Heh any press is good press from sonys point of view i guess. | |
A little off-topic: I really respected Rommel as a commander. I'd love to study more on him in the future. OT: What are they trying to say? I amreally confused here. | |
The transferring blood thing kinda makes sense, but why a Nazi? Surely an action hero/heroine would have made a lot more sense rather then what's likely to be the villain in a game if he ever appeared in one. | |
Well... I gotta admit... Erwin Rommel was a pretty cool guy. | |
:O ... Just WTF again. They will never learn. >.< | |
controvercy and to catch peoples attention. | |
I would donate blood to him. OT: Wha? Who? Wh? A buuuuuuuuuuuuh? | |
It took me forever to find both swastikas in the picture. It was like Where's Waldo. EDIT: Sony should hire someone else to do their advertising. The people they have now are doing it wrong. | |
I don't know about anyone else but, the second ad? The one with the heart? Yeah, that's the sort of shit that's might put people off buying a PS3. I know it's not meant to be taken seriously, but it's freaky! And not good freaky! D: | |
OK, this is, odd. Why are Sony trying to make us out as messiahs who help everyone and everything? Do the media hate us that much? | |
Ha ha haaa.... oh Sony y are you so bad at adds. | |
All i want to know is, who the hell is the target audience, some WW11 vets that knew that nazi in particular was an okay fellow? | |
On one hand, what the fuck?* On the other hand, Rommel. Rommel is one of the greatest military commanders to have ever lived, and unlike many German commanders, he nor those under his command where ever accused of war crimes. He refused and defied orders to kill any Jews he encountered, and any POW's where treated well. Oh, and he was involved in the July 20 plot against Hitler. I'd give blood to him. EDIT: * To clarify, despite Rommel being a figure worthy of respect and praise, this is an advertising blunder. | |
SONY's advertising campaigns simply baffle me. Those ads don't make me want to buy a PS3, or donate blood.......... ..........they kinda make me want to hurl.......... | |
Who's the target audience? BUT ANYWAY... I hope to god this is a case of lost in translation. | |
I'm from Chile and I must say that I'm... annoyed... surprised? I can't express my exact feelings. But neither can Sony. What is this supposed to mean? Was Sony Chile responsible for those terrible ads or did American or Japanese thought we chileans are so crazy? Whoever made those ads should be fired. Now I completely ruled out any possibility to buy a PS3 myself (yes, that's the effect you've got with that ads, Sony) and keep myself a proud Chilean PC player. Please, people, don't get the feeling we chileans are the target group to those terrible unrespectful ads. | |
That ad like nothing before makes me want to pick up a PS3. If it's hinting at a game where you get to play as Rommel...I'll sell the heart I'm apparently giving to Joan of Arc to play that. That you're that far in the game that the ads depict you being there to give that kind of aid bespeaks to me of deep immersion, real experience, and beautifully rendered scenes (though what's up with that skirt on that nurse...the hell is that?). First Sony's gonna steal the wife and kids I don't have to give me more time to game, and now they're letting me save Rommel. If only there was a minigame where you and Patton get to have a chat and a tea... | |
Maybe its Sonys way of saying the PS3 is so awesome that you will be willing to give your blood and heart for it.....I don't really know, but it is fun looking at these and trying to figure the ad out. | |
Sony Marketing Guy 1: Hey guys, you know who Chilean loves. Rommel and Jeanne of Arc. | |
Who the fuck cares? Everyone knows that the consoles are nothing like that, it's common-fucking-sense. | |
You know, sometimes I think Sony's Ad department just gets bored and does stuff like this for shits and giggles. Either that or they're absolutely, irrevocably insane... | |
When I first saw these two ads I thought they were advertisements for the next Silent Hill game. The nurses looks a bit creepy and in the Joan-of-Arc pic notice that the gamers legs are locked down. Also, in most WWII games, you are spilling Nazi blood, not donating it to them. | |
yes, but you must ask yourself, when mother's see that, will they use common sense. | |
My first thought was that it's an artistic metaphor playing on the countless WW2 games on the market. Essentially that we've become fanatics of the genre. But the Jean d' Arc ad has me baffled. Not sure of the recurring theme other than donors for historic figures... let's make a rundown. CAUTION: The following is unadulterated rambling, and I don't know if it's going to go anywhere. I will put things I deem potentially relevant and not obvious in bold. It's very apparent that in both pictures, two nurses are helping gamers donate heart and blood to these people. Both of these things are often spiritual in meaning and likely contribute to the message. For both players, the character portrayed is to their right. In gaming, the far left is relative to "Player 1" and the port on the right, next to it as "Player 2". Perhaps this is to portray a gamer-type camaraderie between the gamer and figure, which also explains the gamers looking at the figures and smiling. Also, you can see the same white bowl in each photo. I imagine this is an important fact. There's also a little bottle of oil (?) on the end tables in each photo On to the differences... In the Nazi photo, the nurses appear very attentive. One is looking at the bowl and the other at the patient, both with calm faces. In the Jean photo, they don't look as professional. The one holding the bloody rope is staring off into the distance, while the other seems to be looking at the bowl. This brings a new comparison: A nurse in each photo is looking at the white bowl. Now let's compare the figures themselves: Erwin Rommel and Joan d' Arc. Both Erwin and Joan were admirable military leaders in time of war. Both of them died at the hands of the courthouse, under less than fair circumstances. So what we see is two very similar pictures of modern gamers making very fanatic/ affectionate donations to admirable commanders who met their ends in unjust courthouses. The white bowl and oil bottle are also likely has some significance, and is acknowledged by the nurses in both ads. My theory is that it shows how gamers admire valiant commanders, since playing a game is also a form of controlling fighters. The bowl and glass are still in question to me, but it also means to portray gamers fueling their friends, the historic commanders. Why? I'm not sure. If anyone can add onto what I have or help piece this together, I'd appreciate it. I really think there's a hidden message in this. | |
The only proper reaction to this is "LoLWUT?" | |
I just don't get it, it's okay to have 'artsy' ads but despite the trope True Art Is Not Incomprehensable! | |
Which is why my interpretation of the ad was: If you buy a PS3, the Nazis are going to need all the blood transfusions they can get! | |
Sony's trying to say that their product can immerse you in the game world, I do believe. Besides that, what I read of Rommel, he was a genuinely decent fellow, more German than Nazi. | |
Well maybe, but they sure as hell wouldn't be getting them from me! =) | |
Oh thank god about the Erwin Rommel thing. I thought I was all alonw with that. Plus, I don't get it either. | |
Ah come on guys. All Sony wanted to do was to raise sales among Nazis and KKK member customers. And for that, I applaud them. Because, if racists can't kill people they hate in games, they'll start doing it in real life. God, sony is dumb. | |
maybe they should have gone with Patton? | |
| (Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4) | |
Chilean PS3 Ad Shows Gamer Giving Blood to Nazi Officer
Sony's marketing department has once again come under fire for a Chilean print ad for the PS3 that depicts a modern-day gamer giving a blood transfusion to a Nazi officer.
Oh, Sony. You were doing so well, too!
A Chilean advertisement for the PS3 developed by major ad firm BBDO has generated quite a deal of controversy, since it depicts a (quite clearly modern-day) gamer donating blood to a *gasp* Nazi! If the uniform didn't tip you off, how about the faint swastikas at the head of the bed?
Now, apparently the Nazi in question is the original Magnificent Bastard Erwin Rommel, who was actually fairly respected by allies and foes alike for being a decent chap - as far as Nazis go, anyway. Rommel's supposed virtue aside, though, this just seems strange.
The other ad in the set is much less controversial, but no less perplexing: It shows a happy (again, modern-day) gamer donating his still-beating heart to Joan of Arc. I'm just... I'm honestly baffled. I cannot figure out for the life of me what the hell these ads are supposedly trying to communicate. "If you buy a PS3, you'd donate blood to a Nazi"? Has Sony intentionally and irrevocably invoked Godwin's law on itself?
If there's one group of people who gamers (or, indeed, anyone else) probably wouldn't want to be compared to, it's the Nazis. Even with Sony's other controversial ads, I was usually able to make some sense of it. But these? I got nothing.
I guess the chemicals are back in the water supply for Sony's ad people. We should have known that their momentary lucidity wouldn't last.
(Keep the comments clean, folks. We'll be watching.)
(Adme.ru, via Engadget)
Permalink