University Threatens Criminal Charges Over Firefly Poster

 Pages 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 NEXT
 

University Threatens Criminal Charges Over Firefly Poster

image

A professor at the University of Wisconsin is facing threats of criminal action for putting up a poster featuring a quote from the sci-fi television series Firefly.

"You don't know me, son, so let me explain this to you once: if I ever kill you, you'll be awake. You'll be facing me. And you'll be armed." If you're a Firefly fan, that quote will be instantly recognizable as one spoken by Captain Malcolm Reynolds, explaining to a new passenger one of the many interesting philosophies that governs his life. It also apparently had some resonance with Professor James Miller of the University of Wisconsin, who hung a poster featuring that quote and a picture of Captain Reynolds, also known as actor Nathan Fillion, on his office door.

But on September 16, he received an email from University Police Chief Lisa A. Walter, telling him that she had taken the poster down because "it is unacceptable to have postings such as this that refer to killing." When Miller complained, Walter told him, "The poster can be interpreted as a threat by others and/or could cause those that view it to believe that you are willing/able to carry out actions similar to what is listed," and furthermore, that if he put it back up or posted anything similar, he could be charged with disorderly conduct.

So Miller, a theater professor, replaced it with a different poster: a silhouette of a riot-gear-clad policeman putting a beatdown on someone, with the caption, "Warning: Fascism. Fascism can cause blunt head trauma and/or violent death. Keep fascism away from children and pets." A few days later, that poster was gone too and Miller received another email from the chief, saying it was taken down because it "depicts violence and mentions violence and death."

And this time around, the university's "threat assessment team" was called in and concluded, in consultation with the University General Counsel's office, that the poster could be reasonably expected to "cause a material and/or substantial disruption of school activities and/or be constituted as a threat," and should therefore be removed. Raymond Hayes, the interim Dean of the University's College of Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences, has arranged a meeting with Miller on September 30 to address "the concerns raised by the campus threat assessment team."

The day after his second poster was removed, Miller took the matter to the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, which contacted University of Wisconsin Chancellor Charles W. Sorenson with a request that the university stop censoring Miller, apologize for threatening him with criminal charges and cancel the threat assessment meeting.

"Colleges and universities are supposed to foster brave and bold environments of freewheeling intellectual inquiry and expression. If a quote from a network science fiction show is a bridge too far, something has gone seriously wrong," said FIRE President Greg Lukianoff. "As both president of FIRE and a huge Firefly fan, I call on the chancellor of UW-Stout to rein in his overreaching administration and to restore both free speech and basic common sense."

As of press time, Sorensen had not responded to the request.

Permalink

You can insult me. You can insult my country. Hell, you can insult my family. But, when you insult the Captain... you've just stepped over the line, buddy.

On a lighter note, what in the hell is a "threat assessment team" and why would any university need one?

I love how the second poster put was basically a more covert way of getting a picture of the chief saying "I'm a big stupid weiner head whose stupid!".

I love eggheads and lawyers they think they know everything, but they have not an ounce of common sense among them.

Bring back firefly!

I'm not big on suing...but he should drill them.

Screw anyone that is so stupid they'd be alarmed by that poster.

Good lord...does no college trust Google yet?

Can he take a photo of the local police and/or the "Threat assessment team" and add caption

"Warning: May contain stupid" and put that on his door instead?

Eh, if there are rules against that sort of thing, the guy knew what he was getting into.

Now, if he wants to challenge the rule, sure, but do that beforehand, not as a reaction. If it's a stupid rule, it was stupid rule before your poster got banned.

If there aren't actual rules, and someone just decided it on the spot...sucks.

Ah Universities, so dedicated to protecting the rights and priviledges of others. As long as they're the RIGHT priviledges.

Let's make sure there's never any mention of Genocide, Wars, Apartheid, or all that horrible history/future - let's just make sure that it's nice happy utopian future, sponsored by a benevolent corporation.

Here's a clue, Chancellor Charles W. Sorenson, the reason you HAVE that University is because somewhere in the past - one of your relatives killed someone elses.

It'd be a real shame to censor that. Especially in a place of learning.

This seems like a waste of government money. It was clearly a quote and not an actual message to students, threatening them...

Never seen Firefly.

I suggest a police officer giving a ticket to a kid on a Big Wheel for his next poster.

Ahahahaha...man...the fear is strong with these ones.

Large groups of people enacting laws produce some stunningly thoughtless interpretations of said laws.

Free thinkers lack basic quality control on their impulses.

I'm calling this a no-score draw.

I like this profressor, he has a good sense of humor. Really though, we're not talking about kids here. This is a university, a place wherein full grown adults have come to further their education, I hardly think that these posters can be considered genuinally pernicious, especially given the jocular nature of the latter one.

That's just patently absurd and utterly hysterical.

Absolutely nobody with half a brain would ever perceive a TV series poster as a threat of violence, and you'd kind of hope people did have a minimum standard of intelligence and rationality at a university.

The fact that they call in a "threat assessment team" on a theatre professor who like a TV series really goes to show that rationality and perspective isn't always found where you'd hope to find it the most. This better not be a publicly run university, or there are some serious concerns over Freedom of Expression at play here as well.

The university could've saved themselves a lot of trouble by calling it unprofessional and inappropriate instead of claiming it promoted violence.

Curse their sudden but inevitable betrayal!

That's like getting rid of Jack and the Beanstalk because a Giant gets killed because he chased the thief that stole from him!

And the lines never depict violence, per se. He just says if I was going to confront you, we would be on equal footing.

The 'Threat Assessment Team' which obviously has WAY too much time on its hands is probably because of the whole 9/11 thing and given how often schools get shot up in America... /sigh

Yep. I'm pretty sure he was correct with the whole fascism thing there. Interpreting a poster as a substantional threat is only applicable to currupt and easily paranoid government officials.
They should have the students fill the campus with as many posters as the walls can support. That'll show 'em!

Christ Almighty, the stupidity... and at a university, no less. -.-

They didn't take the hint to leave well alone when he put up the fascism poster?

He should now post a poster accusing the university of communism and the censorship of free ideas.

So his next poster should include:

Take my love, take my land
Take me where I cannot stand
I don't care, I'm still free
You can't take the sky from me
Take me out to the black
Tell them I ain't comin' back
Burn the land and boil the sea
You can't take the sky from me
There's no place I can be
Since I found Serenity
But you can't take the sky from me...

That's just ridiculous.
I wonder if the guy started singing "You can't take the sky from me"?

EDIT
And ninja'd. Which is worrying considering I am playing Shogun2 Total War and I just assassinated the entire Shogun family.

kaltes:
He should now post a poster accusing the university of communism and the censorship of free ideas.

You can't stop the signal!

I am a student in my last semester of college on this campus. I'm 37 and laugh at quite a bit of the PC crap that goes on here. But worry not. This threat assessment thing is just a warm up to make sure the process works for post November 1st conflicts with students who are following the law and conceal carrying their firearms, but not following the universities wishes by leaving them at home.

The poster can be interpreted as a threat by others and/or could cause those that view it to believe that you are willing/able to carry out actions similar to what is listed

cause a material and/or substantial disruption of school activities and/or be constituted as a threat

Really? They think someone will interpret it that way? Do they believe their students are this stupid? Unlike them, the students still have common sense.
Oh and what in the world is that and why would a university need something like that?

campus threat assessment team

American Universities, producing a fine line of robots since 1996. Also thats when the monkeys took head office. Hmm.

His new poster needs to be a group of robots standing together with a man passing through a door. Captioned "Free minded open thinkers only.

I don't even like Firefly all that much. And Fillion is one of the most annoying actors that tends to be in the kind of shows I watch. So no one can accuse me of just being a little butt-hurt when I say this. So here goes.

WTF?!

No seriously, WTFFFF! WHAT THE FUCKING FUCKERDY FUCK FUCK?

He's take the right course of action, contact the people who have enough clout to kick up a fuss to help him out.

But this shouldn't even be a freaking issue. I am frankly appalled the a supposed institution of enlightenment would take offence at something so unimportant and un-offensive. Would they take a poster of Clint Eastwood saying 'Go on Punk, make my day' Down? Somehow I doubt it. Then, to top it off, to take down a poster about fascism down. That's just so... I actually wonder if they know how totalitarian they made themselves look.

I hope he gets a formal apology from them. Because I'd then frame it and hang it on my fucking door next to the original poster.

One of my lecturers has a fake road sign saying "Quantum junction: Get in both lanes". That doesn't mean he advocates dodgy driving, he is simply making a joke, and if you can't see that then you shouldn't be anywhere near a university.

Sparrow:

On a lighter note, what in the hell is a "threat assessment team" and why would any university need one?

Obama?

OT: Some little hitler getting their fix. I hope it horribly backfires.

Beryl77:

The poster can be interpreted as a threat by others and/or could cause those that view it to believe that you are willing/able to carry out actions similar to what is listed

cause a material and/or substantial disruption of school activities and/or be constituted as a threat

Really? They think someone will interpret it that way? Do they believe their students are this stupid? Unlike them, the students still have common sense.
Oh and what in the world is that and why would a university need something like that?

campus threat assessment team

The same reason an out-of-the-way, dull state with little value to be attacked by terrorists felt they deserved the same amount of money New York got to bolster its anti-terrorism security after the events of 9-11. It's called pandering to the most common denominator and making sure they are pleased as can be, to keep your job secure.

I'm a huge fan of Firefly, but this teacher is so shǎ guā.

Put it on your 'my face space book', not on your office door.

Well, it's political correctness GONE MAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAD!!!

But seriously, that's insane.

Beryl77:
Oh and what in the world is that and why would a university need something like that?

campus threat assessment team

As far as I know, those were established in a knee-jerk reaction after Vtech.
Although I assumed it was for protection against, you know, actual violence not posters that mention "violent acts" or some shit.
Quite the bastardization, even if the idea was somewhat dubious in the first place.

Are these people stupid or is the University of Wisconsin run by the Thought Police? Either way, this doesn't make the American education system look very good.

 Pages 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 NEXT

Reply to Thread

Log in or Register to Comment
Have an account? Login below:
With Facebook:Login With Facebook
or
Username:  
Password:  
  
Not registered? To sign up for an account with The Escapist:
Register With Facebook
Register With Facebook
or
Register for a free account here