Fire Daemon: Anyway of getting a list of proposed banned websites. I sure do hope the old 'Scapist isn't on it.
I doubt it. The Escapist isn't exactly a radical site, nor does it supply child pornography.
No, this firewall is more aimed towards the aforementioned (child porn and extremism)... a great idea in theory, but terrible in practice. Instead of blocking sites (which can just be ignored through proxies), the average Australian has to pay more for our already slow Internet. And this is the same government that promised the Australian public a fibre optics network.
The Iron Ninja: Australia? On behalf of your neighbour, the country known as New Zealand, I present to you our thoughts on the matter.
We offer our deepest condolences towards you and your silly government, and hope it get's well soon.
My puku is not happy with this. Fuck government censorship. This is just further evidence of why we should have a constitutional bill of rights enshrining free speech. My biggest concern is that this is silently going to filter a lot of radical sites giving information on things the government doesn't want known.
Hm, I wonder if they do that the US will swoop in and say BAD AUSTRALIA! One of the good aspects of the US is that we usually intend to do good (not saying we always accomplish good things), and one of the things we would probably step in on is if one of our allies government decided to oppress their own people.
We have too many of our own goddamn problems and we're in no posistion to tell anyone to do anything. We've lost respect inside and out thanks to high commandant asshole in the White House. Obama's whole term is just going to be spent cleaning up the mess...
Hevoo: Thank God I live in America, and Thank my founding fathers for the First Amendment.
Doesn't the first Amendment only count on private property?
This annoys me. The government are a bunch of <censored> trying to rule us with this idea of <censored>. It makes me so <censored>!!!
No, we can more or less say whatever the hell we want (to a point- you can't claim your going to kill the President or something) wherever we want without -legal- consequence. Storming into your job screaming expletives will still get you fired.
TsunamiWombat: No, we can more or less say whatever the hell we want (to a point- you can't claim your going to kill the President or something) wherever we want without -legal- consequence. Storming into your job screaming expletives will still get you fired.
I though the First Amendment was about the government and free speech: while the government can't legally touch you for saying something (to en extent), owners of private property can ask you to leave, or even sue for defamation.
That blows, and sometimes it makes me glad I don't live in Australia. But when I think that, I'm promptly reminded that in the UAE, we got it worse.
We have Little Big Planet, Call of Duty 4, and Grand Theft Auto 4 banned here, and not only that, movies here are censored like crazy, and the internet sites here are blocked. They banned myspace and Facebook for a little while before the eventually caved in and unblocked them. Flickr is banned over here for no discernible reason except that they think of flickr as some sort of porn site.
I understand why they do that in Dubai though. This is an arab country. They have to conform with the standards of the culture here. But when we're talking about Australia here, that's just horse shit.
buy teh haloz: That blows, and sometimes it makes me glad I don't live in Australia. But when I think that, I'm promptly reminded that in the UAE, we got it worse.
We have Little Big Planet, Call of Duty 4, and Grand Theft Auto 4 banned here, and not only that, movies here are censored like crazy, and the internet sites here are blocked. They banned myspace and Facebook for a little while before the eventually caved in and unblocked them. Flickr is banned over here for no discernible reason except that they think of flickr as some sort of porn site.
I understand why they do that in Dubai though. This is an arab country. They have to conform with the standards of the culture here. But when we're talking about Australia here, that's just horse shit.
WHY DO YOU HAVE LITTLE BIG PLANET BANNED? WHAT THE FUCK MAN!
Also ladies and Gents, from now on Australians (Myself included) have access to one website.
Dr. Cox?
I'm fairly sure if they took porn off the Internet, there'd only be one website left, and it'd be called "Bring Back the Porn!" - Dr. Cox, Scrubs
Dose the Australian government think its every ones perants no children you cant look at that but im 34f*** hell no no no I know what's best and don't swear
Hevoo: Thank God I live in America, and Thank my founding fathers for the First Amendment.
Too bad the conservatives only believe in First Amendment rights when it applies to them. Freedom of speech, As long as it's good Christian speech. Preferable if it's denouncing Homosexuals, condemning liberals, or calling Obama a Muslim.
Urging people to murder Homosexuals? Totally fine. Denouncing Islam as being the cause of terrorism? Sure why not. Constantly blaming Darwin and Evolution for everything bad that has ever happened? Go for it. Seperation of Church and state? HATE SPEECH!! CHRISTIAN NATION!! BAAAAAAAAAW!!
may i say spot on?
on topic: that sucks ); why do these people like destroying the lives of Australians???
Fire Daemon: Anyway of getting a list of proposed banned websites. I sure do hope the old 'Scapist isn't on it.
It's actually not too hard to imagine that this site would be deemed "inappropriate"... I really only come here to watch the Yahtzee diatribes so I can't comment on the rest of the site. However, his videos contain certain words, and imply certain actions, that would be easy to consider as off-limits for the cockwits pushing this legislation.
The blacklist currently, and in the future, will NOT be available even under Freedom of Information. They're at 10,000 sites so far and that's only for the test phase.
There is NO MANDATE regarding the limitations of this proposal. Senator Conroy has made no mention of what "inappropriate" means, though there are indications that the blacklist will include subjects such as abortion, euthanasia and drug use. Nominally this will be for pro- or instructional sites, but I'm sure we all know how good filters are at blocking everything with certain key words.
http://nocleanfeed.com - I'm not associated with them, but it's a good place to start if you want to get involved. Check out the list of issues that the filter will have.
Australians can get used to pinging 9000 if this thing rolls out...
Hevoo: Thank God I live in America, and Thank my founding fathers for the First Amendment.
Too bad the conservatives only believe in First Amendment rights when it applies to them. Freedom of speech, As long as it's good Christian speech. Preferable if it's denouncing Homosexuals, condemning liberals, or calling Obama a Muslim.
Urging people to murder Homosexuals? Totally fine. Denouncing Islam as being the cause of terrorism? Sure why not.
Constantly blaming Darwin and Evolution for everything bad that has ever happened? Go for it. Seperation of Church and state? HATE SPEECH!! CHRISTIAN NATION!! BAAAAAAAAAW!!
The irony in this post materialized into a gooey ooze and starting seeping out of my monitor.
Nice try derailing the thread though.
On topic : My condolences to the Aussies out there. Don't know as much as I probably should about your government, but hopefully this gets struck down at some point. Sure, getting rid of the child porn and crap like that may not be a bad thing in and of itself, but giving the government the power to blacklist sites they don't deem worthy of access is a dangerous road to go down. (Not the "ouch I cut off my finger dangerous", the "ouch my rights are waning" dangerous.)
*sigh* 5 years from now when I have nothing but an online dictionary and a picture of Jesus available on the web I'll remember fondly my days here.
I don't get why they are putting it on private connections. They have no real reason and it's just too much. Slower internet, and probably only a few sites left. I bet they'll try to ban gaming/flash games sites alongside the more obvious ones for some idiotic reason.
Hevoo: Thank God I live in America, and Thank my founding fathers for the First Amendment.
Too bad the conservatives only believe in First Amendment rights when it applies to them. Freedom of speech, As long as it's good Christian speech. Preferable if it's denouncing Homosexuals, condemning liberals, or calling Obama a Muslim.
Urging people to murder Homosexuals? Totally fine. Denouncing Islam as being the cause of terrorism? Sure why not.
Constantly blaming Darwin and Evolution for everything bad that has ever happened? Go for it. Seperation of Church and state? HATE SPEECH!! CHRISTIAN NATION!! BAAAAAAAAAW!!
1. Urging to kill Gays? Who? Only nut cases say that, and most people are not nut cases. 2. Denouncing Islam? Hmmmmm, I will concede to this point. But for the most part people dont Denounce this. But they dont do it directly, Its more subconsciously then anything. 3. Blaming Darwin and Evolution? No, they have a belief that god created the earth, granted what they believe is wrong. THey can still believe it.
You are retarded, stop watching Msnbc, and the ZEITGEIST for 5 seconds.
People can say what they want, and for the people who believe the above they are on the fringe of society. You need to chill the out, and thank whomever, that you live where you live.
Everything you named is in the minority, of our society no nation is perfect or people, you always will have nut cases. If people were perfect we would not need governments.
In short your an Idiot.
Now that was just plain impolite.
I am aware that the people saying it are a minority. The point is that nobody objects. No one stands up and says, "You know that's some pretty fucked up shit you just said."
But if someone so much as asks them to not put up a manger in the capitol building then all of a sudden it's "Persecution".
The point is that they only care about Free Speech if they (or someone they agree with) is the one speaking. Sure liberals are all about Political correctness. But at least they shut everyone up, rather than only shutting up one side.
Your a idoit still..
And you are the impolite.
Liberal or Neo-Con, they are both wrong. They have turned into the extreme of there ideas, and now disagree or agree on the same thing, for different reasons.
Also people do object to what these Neo-Cons say all the times, same with what liberals say.
The Iron Ninja: Australia? On behalf of your neighbour, the country known as New Zealand, I present to you our thoughts on the matter.
We offer our deepest condolences towards you and your silly government, and hope it get's well soon.
My puku is not happy with this. Fuck government censorship. This is just further evidence of why we should have a constitutional bill of rights enshrining free speech. My biggest concern is that this is silently going to filter a lot of radical sites giving information on things the government doesn't want known.
Hm, I wonder if they do that the US will swoop in and say BAD AUSTRALIA! One of the good aspects of the US is that we usually intend to do good (not saying we always accomplish good things), and one of the things we would probably step in on is if one of our allies government decided to oppress their own people.
The U.S. government doesn't have the moral standing right now to say a damn thing about this (unfortunately) 8 years ago we could have gone to them and said "you make this mandatory and we stop trading with/sanction you." Now we just have to watch.
DarkBlood626: Dose the Australian government think its every ones perants no children you cant look at that but im 34f*** hell no no no I know what's best and don't swear
DarkBlood626: Dose the Australian government think its every ones perants no children you cant look at that but im 34f*** hell no no no I know what's best and don't swear
It hurt my head to read this.
I've read it 10 times and don't understand what he's trying to say. I thought he was trying to say he was 34 years old at one point, but that doesn't make sense considering the post.
The Iron Ninja: Australia? On behalf of your neighbour, the country known as New Zealand, I present to you our thoughts on the matter.
We offer our deepest condolences towards you and your silly government, and hope it get's well soon.
My puku is not happy with this. Fuck government censorship. This is just further evidence of why we should have a constitutional bill of rights enshrining free speech. My biggest concern is that this is silently going to filter a lot of radical sites giving information on things the government doesn't want known.
Hm, I wonder if they do that the US will swoop in and say BAD AUSTRALIA! One of the good aspects of the US is that we usually intend to do good (not saying we always accomplish good things), and one of the things we would probably step in on is if one of our allies government decided to oppress their own people.
The U.S. government doesn't have the moral standing right now to say a damn thing about this (unfortunately) 8 years ago we could have gone to them and said "you make this mandatory and we stop trading with/sanction you." Now we just have to watch.
Let them do what they want, it sucks that all over the world everyone is slowly losing there freedoms.
Alphavillain: What's with this? I thought Aussies were laid-back happy-go-lucky types, not law-enforcing killjoys. Have I been misinformed?
Yeah, I know man
I game with a ton of Auss, and they are all so chill and funny(<3 Auss). And there Government seems like the biggest D-bag in the world.
Maybe it's some kind of cosmic balancing act. You have to have so much uptightness in one country, so the government guys in Oz go crazy. But I hear that many games are banned or at least censored in Japan and Germany as well.
Alphavillain: What's with this? I thought Aussies were laid-back happy-go-lucky types, not law-enforcing killjoys. Have I been misinformed?
Yeah, I know man
I game with a ton of Auss, and they are all so chill and funny(<3 Auss). And there Government seems like the biggest D-bag in the world.
Maybe it's some kind of cosmic balancing act. You have to have so much uptightness in one country, so the government guys in Oz go crazy. But I hear that many games are banned or at least censored in Japan and Germany as well.
The Iron Ninja: Australia? On behalf of your neighbour, the country known as New Zealand, I present to you our thoughts on the matter.
We offer our deepest condolences towards you and your silly government, and hope it get's well soon.
My puku is not happy with this. Fuck government censorship. This is just further evidence of why we should have a constitutional bill of rights enshrining free speech. My biggest concern is that this is silently going to filter a lot of radical sites giving information on things the government doesn't want known.
Hm, I wonder if they do that the US will swoop in and say BAD AUSTRALIA! One of the good aspects of the US is that we usually intend to do good (not saying we always accomplish good things), and one of the things we would probably step in on is if one of our allies government decided to oppress their own people.
The U.S. government doesn't have the moral standing right now to say a damn thing about this (unfortunately) 8 years ago we could have gone to them and said "you make this mandatory and we stop trading with/sanction you." Now we just have to watch.
Let them do what they want, it sucks that all over the world everyone is slowly losing there freedoms.
If we do that somewhere along the line, the U.S. will make some treaty with them that forces them to censor what goes on the internet here (under the Constitution treaties are to be given more importance that the Constitution itself.)
Last I checked, didn't Japan have a ton of porn games for their consoles and portables?
The Iron Ninja: Australia? On behalf of your neighbour, the country known as New Zealand, I present to you our thoughts on the matter.
We offer our deepest condolences towards you and your silly government, and hope it get's well soon.
My puku is not happy with this. Fuck government censorship. This is just further evidence of why we should have a constitutional bill of rights enshrining free speech. My biggest concern is that this is silently going to filter a lot of radical sites giving information on things the government doesn't want known.
Hm, I wonder if they do that the US will swoop in and say BAD AUSTRALIA! One of the good aspects of the US is that we usually intend to do good (not saying we always accomplish good things), and one of the things we would probably step in on is if one of our allies government decided to oppress their own people.
The U.S. government doesn't have the moral standing right now to say a damn thing about this (unfortunately) 8 years ago we could have gone to them and said "you make this mandatory and we stop trading with/sanction you." Now we just have to watch.
Let them do what they want, it sucks that all over the world everyone is slowly losing there freedoms.
If we do that somewhere along the line, the U.S. will make some treaty with them that forces them to censor what goes on the internet here (under the Constitution treaties are to be given more importance that the Constitution itself.)
Last I checked, didn't Japan have a ton of porn games for their consoles and portables?
Your are a idiot.
So your saying that another nations treaty can over ride our constitution, but we can't make laws as citizens of this nation that go against the constitution.... There is something called the supreme court, and if a law or treaty is unconstitutional, they don't allow that law or treaty to exist.
Taking your logic that would mean if we signed a treaty with a nation that the treaty could say "All American have no Freedom of speech", which is protected under the first amendment. See there is this thing in the constitution, (which you don't know anything about it seems) called the supremacy clause. This states that no law, or treaty shall over ride the authority of the United States Constitution. We our the citizens have to amendment our constitution if we want something to change, so why would we let another nation dictate our laws?
What you are talking about is the invasion of our Sovereignty, I don't think we would let another nation dictate our laws....
You are clearly a idiot and the reason people around the world think Americans are dumb.
Oh and I can look at porn from japan.... whatever that has to do with anything...
The Iron Ninja: Australia? On behalf of your neighbour, the country known as New Zealand, I present to you our thoughts on the matter.
We offer our deepest condolences towards you and your silly government, and hope it get's well soon.
My puku is not happy with this. Fuck government censorship. This is just further evidence of why we should have a constitutional bill of rights enshrining free speech. My biggest concern is that this is silently going to filter a lot of radical sites giving information on things the government doesn't want known.
Hm, I wonder if they do that the US will swoop in and say BAD AUSTRALIA! One of the good aspects of the US is that we usually intend to do good (not saying we always accomplish good things), and one of the things we would probably step in on is if one of our allies government decided to oppress their own people.
The U.S. government doesn't have the moral standing right now to say a damn thing about this (unfortunately) 8 years ago we could have gone to them and said "you make this mandatory and we stop trading with/sanction you." Now we just have to watch.
Let them do what they want, it sucks that all over the world everyone is slowly losing there freedoms.
If we do that somewhere along the line, the U.S. will make some treaty with them that forces them to censor what goes on the internet here (under the Constitution treaties are to be given more importance that the Constitution itself.)
Last I checked, didn't Japan have a ton of porn games for their consoles and portables?
Your are a idiot.
So your saying that another nations treaty can over ride our constitution, but we can't make laws as citizens of this nation that go against the constitution.... There is something called the supreme court, and if a law or treaty is unconstitutional, they don't allow that law or treaty to exist.
Taking your logic that would mean if we signed a treaty with a nation that the treaty could say "All American have no Freedom of speech", which is protected under the first amendment. See there is this thing in the constitution, (which you don't know anything about it seems) called the supremacy clause. This states that no law, or treaty shall over ride the authority of the United States Constitution. We our the citizens have to amendment our constitution if we want something to change, so why would we let another nation dictate our laws?
What you are talking about is the invasion of our Sovereignty, I don't think we would let another nation dictate our laws....
You are clearly a idiot and the reason people around the world think Americans are dumb.
Oh and I can look at porn from japan.... whatever that has to do with anything...
And you obviously have never read a stitch of the constitution.
The way it is written "Treaties with foreign nations shall be treated as the supreme law of the land" it could very easily be interpreted that way.
So it's mandatory but correct me if I'm wrong, can't we just ask for our ISP to not use the filter on our connection.
Crap! I hope so.
Anyway of getting a list of proposed banned websites. I sure do hope the old 'Scapist isn't on it.