Australia's Rau: Reappraise These Games' Ratings

 Pages 1 2 NEXT
 

Australia's Rau: Reappraise These Games' Ratings

image

John Rau has called for 12 games to be examined, including The Walking Dead and The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct.

South Australia's Attorney General John Rau has already gone on record saying that the new classification rules are a bit too soft on games, potentially exposing kids to violent or sexual content. Now Rau has his wish. Twelve titles are to be reappraised, including Killer Is Dead, Alien Rage, Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell Blacklist, Deadly Premonition The Director's Cut, Company of Heroes 2, God Mode, Borderlands 2 Add-On Content Pack, Fuse, Deadpool, The Walking Dead, Gears of War: Judgement, and The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct. The reviews will take place later this month and in December, as the Classification Review Board decides the games' fate.

"The review is an unwarranted and costly exercise to satisfy a vocal yet unrepresentative minority," complains Ron Curry, CEO of The Interactive Games and Entertainment Association. Curry points out that not a single complaint has been made about any of the titles' content; this is an exercise instigated by Rau himself. While Rau's complaint that the titles under scrutiny received M ratings from the ESRB and 18 from PEGI while receiving a lower rating from Australia has some validity, Curry points out that both ESRB and PEGI were established by the games industry, to industry standards, while the Australian version was established by the Australian government.

"In fact, Australia is one of the few developed nations to have classification guidelines determined by Government," Curry says. Comparison to Europe or the United States may be out of place, he thinks, but take a look at New Zealand, which has a system much the same as Australia's; all the titles Rau complains of got a very comparable rating, often R16, or even R13 in the case of Company of Heroes 2. Curry estimates the total cost of the review - at $28,000 per decision - to be $336,000, a fairly hefty bill, particularly given that the whole exercise is a whim of Rau's.

Sources: Classification Review Board Media Release, IGEA response

Permalink

Why is it I get the feeling that Australian gamers hate this guy's guts.

erttheking:
Why is it I get the feeling that Australian gamers hate this guy's guts.

im suprised to be honest that the walking dead got through with the rating it did. it has some extreme moments to say the least.

im thankful they havent made games illegal full stop especially since people thought it was a good idea to elect a catholic extremist time traveler from the 1950s.

freaking waste of money on as its mentioned this assholes whim, actually if the new r 18+ rating lasts the rest of this governments term i will be stunned

My question is, why doesn't Rau pay for the reviews since he is the only one complaining about them? I mean it isn't like they weren't already reviewed.... they were. If they don't fall under his own particular standards then he should be the one footing the bill, especially if he truly believes in his own cause.

As a kiwi I would like to take to opportunity to point and laugh at the broken Australian censorship process.

And for those of you who are intrested only Deadpool, Gears of War: Judgement, and The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct recieved R18 in New Zealand. All the others got a R16 rating except for COH2 which was R13.

Wow... among all the other things wrong with this guy, he wants to reappraise Company of Heroes 2? A historic RTS? Really? Is is next crusade to save children from learning the violence of human existence by reappraising Encyclopedia Britannica and all early-mid 20th century history books for mentioning that whole World Wars business and showing some pictures of bombed out cities? You know... because The Children.

Ed130:
As a kiwi I would like to take to opportunity to point and laugh at the broken Australian censorship process.

And for those of you who are intrested only Deadpool, Gears of War: Judgement, and The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct recieved R18 in New Zealand. All the others got a R16 rating except for COH2 which was R13.

to be fair, I would be surprised if Deadpool got lower than R18 in any country.

OT: He's the only one filing a complaint?

Then he should be footing the bill for everything. While I laugh at the judicial system in the US from time to time, at least people are wary of making claims like this since if the court rules against them they can end up paying for everything.

Australia, why are people like this guy in positions of some importance still?

You know, while I'm rolling my eyes at Rau's unilateralism and wasting of taxpayers' money, I don't know what I'd do if South Australia didn't have an Attorney-General who wasan't a complete waste of skin. He's an improvement over Atkinson but that's like saying skin cancer's an improvement over esophogal cancer.

Poor Australian gamers. Having this chucklefuck in charge of deciding what they are and aren't going to play is awful.

Karloff:
Australia's Attorney General John Rau

Fact Check on Aisle Seventeen!

Rau is the AG of the state of South Australia. He's not the Federal AG. That would be Senator George Brandis.

Try that Google thing next time.

RT:
Poor Australian gamers. Having this chucklefuck in charge of deciding what they are and aren't going to play is awful.

He's not in charge. He's the Attorney General of one state... and not even the worst AG that state has had. His predecessor was the widely hated and hateworthy Michael Atkinson.

Breaking News: "This just in, Australian government thinks games are bad."

So the point of implementing the R18 system was what exactly?

RhombusHatesYou:

RT:
Poor Australian gamers. Having this chucklefuck in charge of deciding what they are and aren't going to play is awful.

He's not in charge. He's the Attorney General of one state... and not even the worst AG that state has had. His predecessor was the widely hated and hateworthy Michael Atkinson.

That's... actually sad.

So someone gets paid $336,000 to review 12 games (most of them pretty damn good). Lucky bastard/bitch!

Laggyteabag:
So the point of implementing the R18 system was what exactly?

Ah, but this is John Rau. He supported R18+ insofar as he wanted to get rid of the MA15+ rating and shovel all the MA15+ games into R18+. He didn't actually want games that would require an actual R18+ rating to be available. Does that make sense? No, it doesn't.

On the other hand, if South Australia had a state AG who wasn't a massive bellend it would be a sign of the end times. Or that my experimental time machine catapulted me back to the 80s (the last time SA had an AG who wasn't a complete waste of skin... even if he did have a nervous breakdown and went for a stroll all naked).

ciancon:
So someone gets paid $336,000 to review 12 games (most of them pretty damn good). Lucky bastard/bitch!

Yes but part of the hiring process for the Australian Classification Board is that you must pass a psych evaluation showing that you hate fun in all it's forms.

This is laughable for so many reasons, not in the least because any kid who has a weekend job and a paypal account can get whatever they want through Steam.

Or better yet, even if the game was 18+, the parents would probably still buy it for them. And then complain about it when they discover graphic content and demand the game be banned outright.

I know it's popular whenever one of these topics crops up to start sneering at Australia for being the land of the puritans, but really that has nothing to do with it. It's more like the land of the lazy parents believing that everyone else is responsible for their child's upbringing, and an obliging swag of politicians who pander to these morons for votes.

Laggyteabag:
So the point of implementing the R18 system was what exactly?

So that they could move the MA15+ rating to R18+

We still get RC (Refused Classification) material that other countries will gladly give the R18+ rating and allow. If I ever want an RC game I will just get it from one of the countries that allows it (They encourage "grey importing" to get around the Australia tax which is a good thing)

Just so everyone is aware, I'd say none of us Australian gamers are surprised that this is happening. If anything, we've been waiting.

Poor australisns, they keep having completely braindead people in their goverment it seems.

...What? I? What?

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA!!!!

Fuck off you stone age politician. For fuck's sake why do we keep having these dramas in this country, the rest of the world seems to manage fine. Why the fuck is a so called developed country having so many problems with establishing a decent ratings system and sticking to it!

I hate this country at times.

Ed130:
As a kiwi I would like to take to opportunity to point and laugh at the broken Australian censorship process.

And for those of you who are intrested only Deadpool, Gears of War: Judgement, and The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct recieved R18 in New Zealand. All the others got a R16 rating except for COH2 which was R13.

As a fellow kiwi, I feel obligated to point out that our govt has been making some really dumb things happen lately, and we can only hope they don't try something like this and change how it works here.

NZ and Australia is pretty soft on strategy games for its content, especially if it's 'moderate science fiction violence' which is really a bunch of baloney.

chozo_hybrid:

Ed130:
As a kiwi I would like to take to opportunity to point and laugh at the broken Australian censorship process.

And for those of you who are intrested only Deadpool, Gears of War: Judgement, and The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct recieved R18 in New Zealand. All the others got a R16 rating except for COH2 which was R13.

As a fellow kiwi, I feel obligated to point out that our govt has been making some really dumb things happen lately, and we can only hope they don't try something like this and change how it works here.

And as another fellow Kiwi too young to vote considerably younger, I entrust you guys with the future of our country.

Nouw:
NZ and Australia is pretty soft on strategy games for its content, especially if it's 'moderate science fiction violence' which is really a bunch of baloney.

chozo_hybrid:

Ed130:
As a kiwi I would like to take to opportunity to point and laugh at the broken Australian censorship process.

And for those of you who are intrested only Deadpool, Gears of War: Judgement, and The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct recieved R18 in New Zealand. All the others got a R16 rating except for COH2 which was R13.

As a fellow kiwi, I feel obligated to point out that our govt has been making some really dumb things happen lately, and we can only hope they don't try something like this and change how it works here.

And as another fellow Kiwi too young to vote considerably younger, I entrust you guys with the future of our country.

I didn't vote for the people in power... So don't blame me XD

Well, since we got a PM who doesn't believe in global warming I've stopped having such a high opinion of my country. So fuck this guy, but really, what do we expect. We've had bastards like this against video games for decades.

chozo_hybrid:
I didn't vote for the people in power... So don't blame me XD

Well you know what they say, every vote counts x3.

MeChaNiZ3D:
Well, since we got a PM who doesn't believe in global warming I've stopped having such a high opinion of my country. So fuck this guy, but really, what do we expect. We've had bastards like this against video games for decades.

He just seems to dislike science in general.
We didn't need a Science minister right? Or the scientists at CSIRO?

...right?

Nouw:

chozo_hybrid:
I didn't vote for the people in power... So don't blame me XD

Well you know what they say, every vote counts x3.

It does, and it's why I vote :D To not do so, unless you feel no one represents your views, is silly and doesn't halp anything.

At least we have yet to have any games affected by stuff like this, worst we've had is a few bans, and those games all kinda sucked anyway.

chozo_hybrid:

Nouw:

chozo_hybrid:
I didn't vote for the people in power... So don't blame me XD

Well you know what they say, every vote counts x3.

It does, and it's why I vote :D To not do so, unless you feel no one represents your views, is silly and doesn't halp anything.

At least we have yet to have any games affected by stuff like this, worst we've had is a few bans, and those games all kinda sucked anyway.

Yup, can't say Reservoir Dogs and Manhunt are heavy losses to New Zealand's game library hehe.

TiberiusEsuriens:
Breaking News: "This just in, Australian government thinks games are bad."

"In other news, grass grows, birds fly, sun shines and Michael Atkinson molests dogs."

Seriously, what is with these Australian Attorney's and their hatred of the games industry? Did a copy of GTA San Andreas run over Rau's pet dog or something?

Why does it cost 28,000 to reappraise the games? 30 each on steam is 360, wages for two employees playing one game each per day for 6 days each @ 1,200 each (very well paid) and the paper to print out their decisions @ 10. That's 2k. Stop wasting money, Australia!

But really, what to Aussie ministers keep objecting against? Do movies get the same kind of treatment? Video games really get shafted over there, and I can't see how it's helping to be this obsessive. Harden the f**k up, Australia!

Nouw:
NZ and Australia is pretty soft on strategy games for its content, especially if it's 'moderate science fiction violence' which is really a bunch of baloney.

chozo_hybrid:

Ed130:
As a kiwi I would like to take to opportunity to point and laugh at the broken Australian censorship process.

And for those of you who are intrested only Deadpool, Gears of War: Judgement, and The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct recieved R18 in New Zealand. All the others got a R16 rating except for COH2 which was R13.

As a fellow kiwi, I feel obligated to point out that our govt has been making some really dumb things happen lately, and we can only hope they don't try something like this and change how it works here.

And as another fellow Kiwi too young to vote considerably younger, I entrust you guys with the future of our country.

Hey I didn't vote for National (but I did for David Bennett, seriously the guy wanders around the Waikato Uni campus looking for all the world like a normal student during O week).

Dear John Rau,

The next time you're going to grind $300K into dust and snort it up your fat snog-hole on a whim, please reconsider being a wasteful fuckwit and do something useful for the nation that pays you the salary which you have clearly never deserved.

- An Australian Taxpayer

gianttalkingpickle:

MeChaNiZ3D:
Well, since we got a PM who doesn't believe in global warming I've stopped having such a high opinion of my country. So fuck this guy, but really, what do we expect. We've had bastards like this against video games for decades.

He just seems to dislike science in general.
We didn't need a Science minister right? Or the scientists at CSIRO?

...right?

Nah, it's not like Australia was doing anything with science anyway. We'll just rely on mining for the backbone of our economy. Solves the problem of education too, don't have to know much to operate machinery, so we'll get rid of that.

 Pages 1 2 NEXT

Reply to Thread

Log in or Register to Comment
Have an account? Login below:
With Facebook:Login With Facebook
or
Username:  
Password:  
  
Not registered? To sign up for an account with The Escapist:
Register With Facebook
Register With Facebook
or
Register for a free account here