How many of you have played Eternal Darkness?
How many of you remember Eternal Darkness?
And how many of you want a sequel to it?
Personally, I loved it. I still remember it.

I assume you mean Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem? And was this brought on by The Spoony Experiments recent review of it?

OT: Never played it, looks good though.

bodyklok:
I assume you mean Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem? And was this brought on by The Spoony Experiments recent review of it?

OT: Never played it, looks good though.

Whos recent review? And yes Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem

I have played it!

And it scared the crap out of me!

Of course I want a sequel!

Man,it was good.

It was pretty good.
If a sequel came out, I might look into it.

I like the game, but oddly I didn't find it all that scary. It seems to me that if you're in control of your Sanity level, then the whole Insanity thing loses its effect.

Mordaci:

bodyklok:
I assume you mean Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem? And was this brought on by The Spoony Experiments recent review of it?

OT: Never played it, looks good though.

Whos recent review? And yes Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem

Spoonyies site, second one from the top.

He's a good reviewer, those aren't his best so check around the achieves if you want to look at some better ones.

I thought it was a pretty good game although it did fall down a few of the pit falls that puzzle/survival horror games usually fall for.

While most of the puzzles were interesting and clever there were a few that felt a bit arbitrary and there were a few fetch quests to boot. On some occasions the puzzles felt a little bit too simple (namely where a symbol appear on the wall and you've got to cast a spell that's the same alignment/colour) and on other occasions they were a bit too vague or unclear (I'm still stuck on the Monestary level for this very reason).

The insanity meter was interesting and shocking at first but after a while my bursts of insanity became readable and predictable to the point where I found myself laughing when weird shit happened rather than feeling uneasy (this in turn can kill the tension which is ultimately important to a horror game and is a shame considering the great effort that went into the H.P.Lovecraft-esc atmosphere and mood of the game).

I guess a sequel could be good but I get the feeling that it make the same mistake that most sequals make and sacrifice some of it's good aspects to counter the weaknesses of the first game.

I never got the chance to play it :(

Always wanted to, though.