Fallout New Vegas - Did you kill Benny?

 Pages 1 2 3 4 5 NEXT
 

So after racking 20hrs into the game and spending most of the day with pure AWESOME side-quests I'm finally at the casino with Benny.

Now what did you guys do? I've done a couple of sceanarios like luring him to the room alone with my high speech and killing his guards, then he's all like WTF and escapes.

I also tried killing him for the lolz REVENGE but I'm not sure if it's the best idea. (Story wise)

So guys let me hear what you did! :D

EDIT: Also do you lose any quests or anything important if you kill him early? Discuss! ^-^

i black widowed him to his room and shotgunned 10mm pistold his head apart. He had maria. what am I not going to get one of the best hand guns in the game?

I killed him. I spoke to him, let him live, and then put an anti-material .50 cal incendiary round through his skull.
It didn't kill him.
The second round blind-fired into his chest did, though.

Yeah, nothing fancy >.>

I convinced him that we were going to cut a deal, convinced him to go straight up to his room (I'm not having him run off on me) then as soon as we got in his suite I shot him in the back of the head.

I let the Legion nab him and then had him crucified.

Very, very satisfying.

First time, I sweet-talked him into giving me his apartment and walking away, which felt very unsatisfying. So on my next walkthrough, I shot him in the face with a 44 Magnum :D that was muuuuch better :D

[black widow] lure him into the room
[black widow] have sex with him
[black widow] kill him in his sleep

>:D

When I finally tracked Benny down in Vegas, I forgave him for shooting me in the head, since I got better anyway and maybe he had a damn good reason for doing what he did, and after the conversation we had in his room at the hotel, it certainly seemed that way. I agreed we'd team up to try and boot Caesar the hell out, then the stupid bastard double crossed me..

Chased him to Caesar's camp, but the Legion is kill on sight for me, so I had to take an hour butchering everyone in the camp to get to Benny, to find him tied up. Had a chuckle, then killed all the guards. Talked to him again, said I'd let him up. Pick-pocketed a gun into his inventory so he'd have a fair chance, let him stand on his feet, then promptly shot the bastard.

Now ain't that a kick in the head.

After 70 hours of playing I went to The Tops and I told Swank that Benny is a traitor and he gave me my Gobi Rifle back, I passed the speech check with Benny, got as much as info as I could then put two bullets through his skull (I was fair, he put two through mine). *possible spoiler* I think if you don't kill him he betrays you. *spoiler done*

I persuaded him into giving me a suite and meeting me in there, all that was left afterwards was a small pile of dust on the floor of my new suite by the elevator.

TriggerHappyAngel:
[black widow] lure him into the room
[black widow] have sex with him
[black widow] kill him in his sleep

>:D

So... you had sex with a 2-shot person that tried to kill you?

O_o

Legion got him,so I couldn't use explosives like I had hoped,so I settled for a brutaly direct and unefficient bare hand beating,followed by a tire iron to the jaw,and a coup de grace as close to the balls as I could with a golf club.
His body was then stripped and mutilated,and displayed on Caesar's throne.

As satisfying as that was,I just so wanted to knock him out with boxing gloves,plant C4 right under him and watch one hell of a bloody mess rocket to the moon!

Count Igor:

Does it impact the game afterwards? I was going to try that, but after I tried the first time and you know what happened I didnt feel like taking on that task.

How is this a question? I blew the asshole's face off!

Who Dares Wins:
After 70 hours of playing I went to The Tops and I told Swank that Benny is a traitor and he gave me my Gobi Rifle back, I passed the speech check with Benny, got as much as info as I could then put two bullets through his skull (I was fair, he put two through mine). *possible spoiler* I think if you don't kill him he betrays you. *spoiler done*

Wait you had 70hrs before you got to him at the casino? O_o!
Either you explore way to much or you have a secret you're not telling me .

I spent like 10hrs today on side-quests alone so I thought 20hrs was enough before advancing on the story some more =.=

I got him all alone in the presendential suite in the tops and put a frag mine(or two) in his trousers(or three, or seven), and he blew up. So much so that in fact I was surprised why his bodyguards didn't kill me after noticing that he was naked(I robbed his stuff) and that all of his limbs were missing.

Was Pretty fun though.
And BTW killing Benny is the ONLY way to continue the story, otherwise he runs away and then you have to find him.

BJ777:
I got him all alone in the presendential suite in the tops and put a frag mine(or two) in his trousers(or three, or seven), and he blew up. So much so that in fact I was surprised why his bodyguards didn't kill me after noticing that he was naked(I robbed his stuff) and that all of his limbs were missing.

Was Pretty fun though.
And BTW killing Benny is the ONLY way to continue the story, otherwise he runs away and then you have to find him.

So...

I found him in Vegas and gave him a long talk about spoiler warnings.

OK, I didn't read the OP, and here's why: I haven't played New Vegas, but I plan to. Please don't put spoilers in the title of your damn topic.

Frozen Donkey Wheel2:
OK, I didn't read the OP, and here's why: I haven't played New Vegas, but I plan to. Please don't put spoilers in the title of your damn topic.

What spoilers? The whole game is based about killing a guy that tried to kill you, that's the way it starts.

Either way, sorry.

I battled him in the Legion's arena. Decapitated him with a machete. Then I mutilated his corpse for trying to kill me twice.

My Speech sucked so he got away at the hotel. He ran away, got captured by Caesar's Legion. I got the Mark of Caesar, "did" the quest for him (actually activated the armies, but he thought I did what he wanted), my reward was that I got to choose Benny's death.

I pulled out a .44 Magnum Revolver and slowly walked over to him. I placed the barrel to his forehead, moved out to 3rd person, rotated the camera to the side for a better view and pulled the trigger.

Normally I'm the good guy, but I don't take kindly to people who try/have tried to kill me :P

VincentX3:

BJ777:
I got him all alone in the presendential suite in the tops and put a frag mine(or two) in his trousers(or three, or seven), and he blew up. So much so that in fact I was surprised why his bodyguards didn't kill me after noticing that he was naked(I robbed his stuff) and that all of his limbs were missing.

Was Pretty fun though.
And BTW killing Benny is the ONLY way to continue the story, otherwise he runs away and then you have to find him.

So...

Define killed...I freed him then tried to pick pocket him, and Boon killed him. I could of re-loaded but all i could think of was "Damn!! I like that suit!!"

I got him to ditch his guards and come with me to the suite.

Then I let him explain his entire plan before (very slowly) killing him with the silenced pistol I smuggled into the hotel.

Next time, I'll just punch him. It's the gift that keeps on giving.

Jesus Phish:

Count Igor:

Does it impact the game afterwards? I was going to try that, but after I tried the first time and you know what happened I didnt feel like taking on that task.

Not really. It gives a cool message at the end of the game about him, but you don't see him again.
It gave the Jesus Karma sign, so that's why I did it. Plus I wanted Caeser's fist thingy.

The Black widow perk way of killing benny is one of the funniest, so on my next play through, I manually added black widow perk to my male character, which makes all of the conversation with him absolutely hilarious. "Give those charlies a shake for the ben-man" "Dude, im a guy". Also terrifying presence, one the best perks for funny conversation options, also, make a play through with a character with low intelligence, the conversation options are brilliant.

TriggerHappyAngel:
[black widow] lure him into the room
[black widow] have sex with him
[black widow] kill him in his sleep

>:D

Same. I think I might let him live next time... then kill him once the Legion catch him.
Protip: Caesar seems impressed with you if you kill Benny on your own.

Spoiler thread is spoiling my game. :(

First playthrough I duelled him in the Legion's camp (tried to rescue him at first, but it was too much bother). Second playthrough I never even met him. :)

With my first character I let him go, then Boone and I killed every. Single. Legionnaire.

Then my second character, of whom is currently working with the Legion, crucified him. Yay negative karma!

-Oh my god they killed Benny!
- You bastards!

Sorry... Couldn't help it.

VincentX3:

Frozen Donkey Wheel2:
OK, I didn't read the OP, and here's why: I haven't played New Vegas, but I plan to. Please don't put spoilers in the title of your damn topic.

What spoilers? The whole game is based about killing a guy that tried to kill you, that's the way it starts.

Either way, sorry.

Pretty much. It's with what you start at the beginning of the game, so it's not a spoiler at all...I mean Jebesus...

TriggerHappyAngel:
[black widow] lure him into the room
[black widow] have sex with him
[black widow] kill him in his sleep

>:D

Bloody hell, I just HAVE TO TRY THAT!
brb kthxbai!

I tried many things, but the most satisfying was to get him to the room alone with me thanks to good speech, have him walk to the elevator, go to the casino before him, wait a bit, bot gets confused, I'm back, his guards are there, but he's kinda lost and just stands in one place.
And then I throw dynamite in there. Boom.

 Pages 1 2 3 4 5 NEXT

Reply to Thread

This thread is locked