Braid. It's perfect accompanied with beer and loud, generic rock music.

Judging by the quality of online conversations GTAIV seems to be a total bro game.

Bro Grabs! No?

I'd tell them to pick up Left 4 Dead when it comes around. That seems like a good way to bond with the frat brothers. Form a strong, totally not gay bond.

If the bros were on ectasy then I could see them warming up to Super Smash Bros.

Castle Crashers.

You mean besides Madden? :-P

Eggo:

Ares Tyr:
Bro Grabs! No?

I'd tell them to pick up Left 4 Dead when it comes around. That seems like a good way to bond with the frat brothers. Form a strong, totally not gay bond.

Now that's an excellent suggestion! More cheap beer for that bro!

Hell yeah, bro! BRO GRABS!!!

*lights head on fire*

ALPHA KAPPA PHI FOR LIFE!!!

If its not local multiplayer, they could LAN it up or just have four Live connected boxes in the house.

BallPtPenTheif:
If the bros were on ectasy then I could see them warming up to Super Smash Bros.

Or SM Galaxy and let someone else grab the 2nd Wii-Mote and let them fire stars at everything.

Oh, and there's a ber pong game on Wii-Ware I think.

Just set up the table and play on the wii, no more dirty balls in your beer, and no more mess.

Rock Band.

Strafe Mcgee:
Rock Band.

*approving nod*

Super Mario Bros.

Resistance 2.

Ninja Gaiden 2 (who can beat a level while drunk)

rock band...nothing's more manly than getting a highscore on maps.

Yeah, Madden. I can't remember which year it was, but there was an awesome NHL 0#. Maybe 07.

Eggo:
Rock band isn't really a game which fosters a sense of masculine homophobic+homosocial behavior; I've seen plenty of non-bros play it.

Bro. Iron Maiden...

oddly enough, Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time was a massive bro game in college when it was released. i remember all these random douche bags holed up in their dorm rooms playing that thing and blowing off studying for their finals. totally bizarre, since these were not the typical gamer types. it seems that a lot of old school Zelda fans came back to gaming due to that title.

Ares Tyr:

Bro. Iron Maiden...

Indeed. And Avenged Sevenfold. And Machine Head. And System Of A Down. And... so on and so on and so on. It's the ultimate party game. Even better when you're blootered.

Tenmar:
I'm suprised no one mentioned any sports games yet. Nothing says fraternity than Tiger woods, NHL, NFL, MLB, NBA, and FIFA games. Anyone who is a sports fan will enjoy playing their favorite team and enjoy trash talking and replaying the goal over an over again.

Golf is a frat boy sport?

Puzzle fighter x HD

Indigo_Dingo:
I thought Iron Maiden weren't in Rock Band 2?

I don't think anyone mentioned Rock Band 2... Run To The Hills is on the first one though, and there's a cover of The Number Of The Beast available on the music store.

Cheeze_Pavilion:

Bros realize that college is only a short seven or eight years. At some point Bros must move on to run the world and become biznezzmen who make their deals on the golf course. So Bros need to be ready for that day.

Also: Beer Cart Girls

If they're that smart there not "bros"

You got me.

42manZ:
Castle Crashers.

I recommend this
though the RPG part might be a turn off

Bad Dudes. "Are you a bad enough dude to rescue the president."

Indigo_Dingo:

Strafe Mcgee:

Indigo_Dingo:
I thought Iron Maiden weren't in Rock Band 2?

I don't think anyone mentioned Rock Band 2... Run To The Hills is on the first one though, and there's a cover of The Number Of The Beast available on the music store.

As we were discussing upcoming games, I assumed that people meant Rock Band 2

And you know what happens when we assume....

Ares Tyr:

And you know what happens when we assume....

Spoiler: Click to View

Isn't it "You make an "ass" of "u" and "me".