Topic Index
Too Much Violence in Video Games?

Username:Password:
Log In
Shiuz91
BANNED
Posts: 600
Joined: 8 Jul 2008

I know this topic has been done more than a Mario game but I felt like taking my own crazy stab at it. Firstly I'd like to help disprove a theory "Does Playing FPS's and GTA make you a better shooter" short answer no, long answer hell no. I've been playing FPS's since DOOM and I've played every GTA video game there is and I can't hit the broad side of a barn. So the theory that FPS's and GTA make you a better shooter? FALSE! Next the theory is that violent video games make the player more violent. Now I'm not going to try and deny this has never happened but if you play a violent video game then shoot some people then shoot yourself you deserve to die. Now I've played countless violent video games all the DOOM's (beaten on Nightmare ;)) all the GTA's Assassin's Creed, all the Duke Nukem's, Gears of War, all the Mortal Kombat's, to name a few, and look I've never shot anybody in fact I've never even raised my fist in anger because I don't want to cause anybody pain even if they cause me pain. So the "Theory" that video games make you more violent. FALSE! And lastly that there is too much sex and nudity in video games... what I can't seem to understand about this is that if there is full frontal nudity in a movie nobody bats an eyelash, but if a bra is shown in a video game the whole world is turned upside down there is media frenzies it's all too crazy. It's all just a scapegoat for all the real bad stuff going on in this world like global warming, and 10'000 nukes being in the hands of an incompetent Texan, you know who I'm talkin' about. So is there too much sex and nudity in video games. FALSE!

So in conclusion I've played pretty much every game there is and I've never shot anybody or gone crazy so either I'm a freak of nature or Jacky T. is a complete MORON. So is Jacky T. a complete moron... I'll let you guy's fill that one out.

Cheers

User was banned for: Achievements have ruined my gaming.. (3 days)
A29inchbeefstick
Copy Clerk
Posts: 105
Joined: 24 Aug 2008

*cough* *cough*This is a web site that revolves around gaming...So are you thick...?

Shiuz91
BANNED
Posts: 600
Joined: 8 Jul 2008

A29inchbeefstick:
*cough* *cough*This is a web site that revolves around gaming...So are you thick...?

What do you mean i am thick

User was banned for: Achievements have ruined my gaming.. (3 days)
Darthracoon
Copy Clerk
Posts: 105
Joined: 27 Aug 2008

Shiuz91:

A29inchbeefstick:
*cough* *cough*This is a web site that revolves around gaming...So are you thick...?

What do you mean am i think?

Me fail english? That's unpossible!

Anyways im not quite sure what this is getting at but if it's getting at what i think its getting at, games CAN make someone more violent. (like that taiwanise(sp) teenager who tried to see if mugging a cabbie was as easy in real life as in gta4, and then stabbed him) It certainly can make people short-tempered(happend to me), e.g if you get killed and get pissed of at it your more likely to get pissed off at stuff in real life.

Joeshie
Infamous Scribbler
Posts: 527
Joined: 9 Oct 2007

You're preaching to the choir there buddy.

Copter400
Gone Gonzo
Posts: 2099
Joined: 14 Sep 2007

Shiuz91:
I know this topic has been done more than a Mario game...

Precisely. With this in mind, you should never start another thread on it. Use the search button and post your thoughts there.

And with that, I dash away into the mysterious night!

GothmogII
Pulitzer Laureate
Posts: 758
Joined: 6 Apr 2008

You know what? Videogames -can- and do make people violent. In my own experience though it was never the shooters or the beat em' ups. It was the platformers and the puzzlers that really made my blood boil. I can remember being brought to almost tearing my hair out in frustration at the trapeze level in Psychonauts, feeling like banging my head on the wall when fighting Mr.Sax in Rayman. Like breaking the game discs on only the first island in Myst.

Maybe that's just me though. Frustration brings out anger in me better. And actually...I haven't played a modern game other than the aforementioned Pyschonauts that could cause such frustration, games just seem to have gotten easy, too easy. Most don't frustrate enough...

Black yeoman
Copy Clerk
Posts: 112
Joined: 22 Jun 2008

Just because there is more sex is films doesn't mean there isn't too much in games...
I am worried about children getting violent games, or for that matter any game with a character like the women in Soulcalibur (perhaps even any eastern game, I would really like to be proved wrong here.). It is, I think, more subtle than many appreciate, its certainly not a matter of "I don't murder people" or "I don't play gears of war then go and chainsaw people". I recall first hearing/seeing the torture of Morgenholt in Splintercell (advised 16+ Britain) and it scared me, but now I can see much worse without effect. Perhaps it has numbed me too violence, but people should avoid violence because it is the right thing to do, not because they are scared of violence.
So, my conclusion: there is to mush sexism and too young children are exposed to it.
On violence: I don't know, but I know I would like GTA just as much if it was dumbed down a little, I did, for example, like just cause.

EDIT: Yeah, ignorant parents, but I know some 18+ year olds I wouldn't want playing some games.

BallPtPenTheif
Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1391
Joined: 11 Jun 2008

I don't think I own a single PS3 game where I can dismember anybody. Actually, the last violent thing I saw was the Director getting jibbed by the landmine in Tropic Thunder.

fix-the-spade
Gone Gonzo
Posts: 1059
Joined: 25 Feb 2008

Shiuz91:

A29inchbeefstick:
*cough* *cough*This is a web site that revolves around gaming...So are you thick...?

What do you mean am i think?

Never has a question been answered so completely, eloquently and accidentally.

Mukiwa
Copy Clerk
Posts: 96
Joined: 4 Sep 2008

Shiuz91:

A29inchbeefstick:
*cough* *cough*This is a web site that revolves around gaming...So are you thick...?

What do you mean am i think?

Oh the irony.

demon lord 2037
Copy Clerk
Posts: 77
Joined: 5 Sep 2008

no violence is what games are based around and there will never be to much violence in video games

tobyornottoby
Muckraker
Posts: 346
Joined: 2 Jan 2008

(video) games CAN influence you. In my experience, this is noticable in reflex-based actions, or thought patterns. An example of the first would be having a relfex to dodge when you see a camera after playing many stealth games. An example of the latter would be imagining moods of people and talking to them to raise certain stats, after playing too much sims (I heard girls who had this ;)

Why is it noticable in reflex actions? I dunno, guess because they are done without real thinking, and also because games are a lot about learning reflex actions.

So, why did you never go out and shot people? Because that's not really a reflex. HOWEVER, if you would ever end up in a situation where you're holding a gun and things run out of hand, I'll bet my money on it that a gamer would pull the trigger out of reflex earlier than a non-gamer. Fortunately, that's not a common situation to suddenly get in.

EDIT: this is by no means appicable to games only. I know that when I read a lot of cowboy novels when I was young, I sometimes had a reflex on sa sudden action that was 'cowboy-inspired'

EDIT 2: to answer the topic question, NO I do not think there is too much violence in games. We can handle it. However, it is absolutely foolish to say that games have no influence

RedElectric
Copy Clerk
Posts: 61
Joined: 2 May 2008

What do you mean by violence? Criminal or heroic?

Mullahgrrl
Copy Clerk
Posts: 88
Joined: 20 Apr 2008

I think videogames need more violence.

weirdaljedifan2
Beat Writer
Posts: 175
Joined: 12 Apr 2008

I think there are too many games that have this violence and not enough games directed toward video games' ORIGINAL age target, kids. Yes, I was talking about the Xbox 360 and PS3. Am I a Nintendo fanboy? I'm not sure. Is it wrong to be a Nintendo fanboy? Short answer: NO! Long answer: NO, and shut up!

Mistah Kurtz
Infamous Scribbler
Posts: 562
Joined: 6 Jul 2008

Shiuz91:
Next the theory is that violent video games make the player more violent. Now I'm not going to try and deny this has never happened but if you play a violent video game then shoot some people then shoot yourself you deserve to die.

So your argument to the idea that video games can influence people with predispositions to violence is that they deserve to die? You didn't even attempt to respond to the criticism..

Shiuz91
BANNED
Posts: 600
Joined: 8 Jul 2008

RedElectric:
What do you mean by violence? Criminal or heroic?

Criminal violence

User was banned for: Achievements have ruined my gaming.. (3 days)
Shiuz91
BANNED
Posts: 600
Joined: 8 Jul 2008

tobyornottoby:
(video) games CAN influence you. In my experience, this is noticable in reflex-based actions, or thought patterns. An example of the first would be having a relfex to dodge when you see a camera after playing many stealth games. An example of the latter would be imagining moods of people and talking to them to raise certain stats, after playing too much sims (I heard girls who had this ;)

Why is it noticable in reflex actions? I dunno, guess because they are done without real thinking, and also because games are a lot about learning reflex actions.

So, why did you never go out and shot people? Because that's not really a reflex. HOWEVER, if you would ever end up in a situation where you're holding a gun and things run out of hand, I'll bet my money on it that a gamer would pull the trigger out of reflex earlier than a non-gamer. Fortunately, that's not a common situation to suddenly get in.

EDIT: this is by no means appicable to games only. I know that when I read a lot of cowboy novels when I was young, I sometimes had a reflex on sa sudden action that was 'cowboy-inspired'

EDIT 2: to answer the topic question, NO I do not think there is too much violence in games. We can handle it. However, it is absolutely foolish to say that games have no influence

It may be true that some games can influence people but those people have a choice weather or not they want to kill people or be violent

User was banned for: Achievements have ruined my gaming.. (3 days)
Shiuz91
BANNED
Posts: 600
Joined: 8 Jul 2008

So, my conclusion: there is to mush sexism and too young children are exposed to it.
Don't forget these kids can't buy these games without a parent and if a parent buys GOW or GTA for their kid i feel sorry for the kid having parents that crappy.

User was banned for: Achievements have ruined my gaming.. (3 days)
Shiuz91
BANNED
Posts: 600
Joined: 8 Jul 2008

GothmogII:
You know what? Videogames -can- and do make people violent. In my own experience though it was never the shooters or the beat em' ups. It was the platformers and the puzzlers that really made my blood boil. I can remember being brought to almost tearing my hair out in frustration at the trapeze level in Psychonauts, feeling like banging my head on the wall when fighting Mr.Sax in Rayman. Like breaking the game discs on only the first island in Myst.

Maybe that's just me though. Frustration brings out anger in me better. And actually...I haven't played a modern game other than the aforementioned Pyschonauts that could cause such frustration, games just seem to have gotten easy, too easy. Most don't frustrate enough...

Well yeah you can get frustrated with the game but when i said violence i meant hurting other people or killing them

User was banned for: Achievements have ruined my gaming.. (3 days)
Shiuz91
BANNED
Posts: 600
Joined: 8 Jul 2008

Darthracoon:

Shiuz91:

A29inchbeefstick:
*cough* *cough*This is a web site that revolves around gaming...So are you thick...?

What do you mean am i think?

Me fail english? That's unpossible!

Anyways im not quite sure what this is getting at but if it's getting at what i think its getting at, games CAN make someone more violent. (like that taiwanise(sp) teenager who tried to see if mugging a cabbie was as easy in real life as in gta4, and then stabbed him) It certainly can make people short-tempered(happend to me), e.g if you get killed and get pissed of at it your more likely to get pissed off at stuff in real life.

I'm not the first to admit that i get frustrated at video games (like when i play COD 4 and i have a 15 kill streak and i get sniped) but when i get too frustrated i turn the game off and do something else i don't kill or hit someone.

User was banned for: Achievements have ruined my gaming.. (3 days)
tobyornottoby
Muckraker
Posts: 346
Joined: 2 Jan 2008

Shiuz91:
It may be true that some games can influence people but those people have a choice weather or not they want to kill people or be violent

That's the danger with reflexes, impulses. You don't really have a choice there. Killing people luckily takes more than just some impulses usually

DARKLARK
Beat Writer
Posts: 142
Joined: 30 Jul 2008

i play fps's and im a good shot so there is always an exception. Also I think games could use so more violence just to piss you off

Decoy Doctorpus
King of the Yetis
Posts: 1956
Joined: 15 Jul 2008

1: Topic has been done to death
2: "Search button mother fucker! Do you use it?"
3: Edit button. Use it.

bubbaroark0451
Beat Writer
Posts: 139
Joined: 13 Aug 2008

There's a 13 page long thread going on about this right now.

sabotstarr
Anonymous Source
Posts: 5
Joined: 4 Sep 2008

can someone lock this cause its going noware and he just wants the hot topic badge

Shiuz91
BANNED
Posts: 600
Joined: 8 Jul 2008

sabotstarr:
can someone lock this cause its going noware and he just wants the hot topic badge

I already have that badge use your eyes

User was banned for: Achievements have ruined my gaming.. (3 days)
Shiuz91
BANNED
Posts: 600
Joined: 8 Jul 2008

quote=DARKLARK post=9.70693.700369]i play fps's and im a good shot so there is always an exception. Also I think games could use so more violence just to piss you off[/quote]

did you even read what i said i dont think there is a problem with violence in video games

User was banned for: Achievements have ruined my gaming.. (3 days)
Raziel_Likes_Souls
Copy Clerk
Posts: 122
Joined: 6 Mar 2008

BallPtPenTheif:
I don't think I own a single PS3 game where I can dismember anybody. Actually, the last violent thing I saw was the Director getting jibbed by the landmine in Tropic Thunder.

Timeshift has meaty explosions.

rayman 101
Beat Writer
Posts: 185
Joined: 7 Jun 2008

The reason why people are offende by a half-nakade chicks in video games, is because they are used like sex items in them, to satisfy middle-aged sweaty men. While most movies with sexual content have more realistic female characters than ones in video games and are not just there for perverts to jerk off.

Cheesus333
Press Junketeer
Posts: 433
Joined: 20 Aug 2008

Black yeoman:
It is, I think, more subtle than many appreciate, its certainly not a matter of "I don't murder people" or "I don't play gears of war then go and chainsaw people". I recall first hearing/seeing the torture of Morgenholt in Splintercell (advised 16+ Britain) and it scared me, but now I can see much worse without effect. Perhaps it has numbed me too violence, but people should avoid violence because it is the right thing to do, not because they are scared of violence.

So, my conclusion: there is to mush sexism and too young children are exposed to it.

So because of video game violence, there is too much sexism? I see your argument there.

Rolls eyes.

1trakm1nd
Paperboy
Posts: 40
Joined: 21 Jun 2008

Raziel_Likes_Souls:
[quote=BallPtPenTheif post=9.70693.699994]I don't think I own a single PS3 game where I can dismember anybody. Actually, the last violent thing I saw was the Director getting jibbed by the landmine in Tropic Thunder.

You my friend have yet to play Ninja Gaiden II.

1trakm1nd
Paperboy
Posts: 40
Joined: 21 Jun 2008

Violence & Video games is just simple. If you remove the violence from Videogames/TV/entertainment in general, that wont stop violence. It's human nature, or rather I should say animalistic. Human beings are still animals.

Frankly a kid who cannot differentiate a game from Joe Schmoe-down-the-street, should not be playing these yes; however this also means that the parents are idiots as well for not teaching their child right from wrong. Anyone that uses games as a means of "explination" to a violent act should be locked up in a psychiatric ward for life, rather have some nut-job go start some games-are-evil protest. Games induce agression, duh, but what doesn't. Your boss might make you angry, but if you can perceieve good from bad you wont go shooting him. Some people still do, they get locked up.

 
Topic Index

Reply to Thread

You must be logged in to post.
Username:  
Password:  
  

Not registered? Sign up for a free account!