Am i the only one who realy enjoyed Episode 1? When it was new it was my favourite game. I played it non-stop. I don't know what i would think of it now but then it was great.

Who does this list guy think he is? Jedi Knight I and II aren't even on the list. And yet, Jedi Academy is on the list? JA was great, but it was a mediocre spin-off of JKII. And I don't really understand placing the Super Star Wars games at #1. Nostalgia much? They are ridiculously (read: unfairly) difficult and don't capture Star Wars the way KOTOR or the TIE Fighter/X-Wing games did.

One thing the list did get right was only placing one of the Battlefront games on the list and placing it rather low. They were really just poor Battlefield clones.

Indigo_Dingo:
*sees which website made the list*

Without even viewing it, its shit.

Shouldn't those guys be reviewing LittleBigPlanet? And choking down absolutely massive slices of Humble Pie?

I arrived at the same conclusion. I don't know why people keep linking to that site and their top 10. they are notorious for making stupid, completely random top 10's, for the sole purpose of pissing of people who don't worship the 8bit era.

jezz8me:
Am i the only one who realy enjoyed Episode 1? When it was new it was my favourite game. I played it non-stop. I don't know what i would think of it now but then it was great.

no, i liked it too when it first came out

When "Shadows of the Empire" for the N64 didn't make that list, I knew that I was dealing with idiot reviewers.

They probably think that the original Zelda title was the best game ever made.

These kind of lists are useless since it's all about taste, and even if you try to do it objectively there is always someone who is going to disagree since quality isn't always the same as fun for everyone.

Anyway, pretty strange list, notably Jedi Outcast was missing.

I can never get far in Outcast, the level design is frustrating.
But I do agree with Battlefront 2.

'scuse me? Super Star Wars? Rebel Strike was better than most of the games in that list, and JK2 was better than all of them.

For those of us who have our Network Admin with a Napleonic complex and thus blocks certain sites for self ego stroking, can someone copy and paste the original list cited by the OP?