Developed by Sledgehammer Games. Published by Activision. Released November 4, 2014. Available on PC, PS4, Xbox One (reviewed). Copy provided by publisher.
If one can extend empathy toward game studios, it’s not hard to see Call of Duty‘s big problem. For half a decade, the series has delivered a game every November with clock-like efficiency, each one aiming to be the biggest selling game of its year. After such a relentless schedule, it’s clear that the series’ foundation has been crumbling with age, but due to its consistent success, it’s difficult to reinvigorate the games without the risk of altering what fans have come to love about them.
Treyarch has been most earnest in its efforts to shake up the system, marrying a clever plot-led campaign to futuristic technology, and providing some of the most interesting multiplayer perks the series has seen. Even so, the Black Ops games still can’t stray too far from Duty‘s zealously obeyed formula, a formula that Call of Duty: Ghosts fully retreated to with unambitious loyalty. Where once the series felt bold, where once it codified a lot of modern multiplayer game ideas, now it seems afraid. Afraid to be the same old CoD, and afraid to be anything else.
Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare is a perfect encapsulation of that fear. It attempts to be an evolution of the series, but it’s not so much a step forward as it is a halfhearted dragging of the feet. Its touted focus on science fiction is window dressing – a few laser beams and jetpacks bolted awkwardly onto the usual framework of assault rifles and shotguns, the equivalent of a “re-imagining” of Romeo & Juliet in which the only change is that the actors are all wearing silver jumpsuits. Aesthetic changes rather than fundamental ones, and not even significant aesthetic changes.
The campaign is not as awfully dreary as Ghosts‘ was, but it’s so monotonous that it’s difficult to get through. While promotional material would have you believe it’s all about flying through the air and crawling up walls like Spider-Man, the reality is that AW‘s single-player is the same NPC-led, corridor-laden shooter you’ve come to expect. Yes, you can climb walls, but only in heavily scripted sequences, once or twice in the campaign, when the game tells you to. You get an EXO Suit, designed to give you tech-enhanced superpowers, but what that boils down to is mostly bullet-time slowdown effects and double jumps, and the game chooses what “powers” you get in each mission, rather than give you any agency.
It doesn’t help that everything this so called “advanced” combat does has been done better in other games, many of them several years old. Double-jumps, bullet-time, cloaking devices, it’s all embarrassingly old-fashioned by today’s standards, and comes off like a half-baked emulation of Halo and Crysis – all in linear environments where one can barely take advantage of the cheap, off-brand toys.
I’m not sure if Advanced Warfare is especially egregious about putting players on a leash, or if I’ve just played so many CoDs that I’ve officially grown sick of it, but the fetters are especially noticeable this time around. I could barely move for NPCs shoving their way past me, opening doors for me, telling me when I could and couldn’t shoot. I failed one mission for straying too far from a soldier I had to follow, all because I got sick of his slow-ass trudging and wanted to explore. Exploration is punished, actively, with arbitrary failure states. At one point, I uncloaked to charge the batteries on my stealth device, and failed the mission because the guy I was following went too far ahead and I got shot to pieces for my transgression. See, I had to charge the batteries when he told me to, not when I felt I was safe to do so. It may as well have been a quick-time-event (of which the game boasts many).
Initiative is condemned. Agency is penalized. To lead is not to be tolerated. You do what you’re told or you suffer, soldier! OBEY!
The only highlight of the campaign is Kevin Spacey, playing the character of Kevin Spacey, and that’s only because he’s Kevin Spacey. Rather than actually create a character to serve as antagonist, Sledgehammer simply gives us a recognizable actor with a creepy cloned face, and lets him do his usual thing. He’s not really a villain, just an idea, a case of the game going, “Look, it’s Kevin Spacey, doing the thing he’s famous for doing, and it’s going to really surprise you when he’s the bad guy maybe!” It’s writing at its cheapest, or it would be if the game didn’t also include a quick-time-event where you “Hold X to pay your respects” at a military funeral. A funeral for a guy I don’t care about, who sacrificed himself to save a guy I don’t care about. Press X.
The actual meat of the action is decent enough, but it’s about as advanced as chainmail. You march down corridors and, when you’re allowed, you shoot factory-standard mooks with the usual cavalcade of guns. Every now and then you stumble upon something unique, like a cool laser beam, and there’s even an instance where you get to wear a mech suit, but once again these are things we’ve seen and done in dozens of other games. One particular cool toy is the variable grenade – grenades can be switched while held to provide EMP blasts or even highlight all enemies in the surrounding area. There’s also a homing “smart” grenade that’s quite fun to use. So that’s something, along with perhaps the laziest skill tree ever conceived – a handful of minor improvements you pay for with one or two points, and I don’t know why they included such an atrophied progression system.
Despite a handful of extra playthings, this is the CoD campaign you’ve come to know and tolerate. The attempts to provide dramatic sequences have gotten more desperate, and the coddling of the player is harder to ignore, but if you just want to shoot some dudes, Advanced Warfare can at least do that, wrapped up in a story that wants to try and make a statement about something, but can’t decide what. Is it pro-military? Anti-military? Is CEO Kevin Spacey an evil extremist, or does he have a point? Are governments inefficient? Can corporations do good? These are all questions Advanced Warfare could have addressed.
It doesn’t though. Of course it doesn’t.
Multiplayer at least “gets it” more in terms of utilizing its new tricks, with open maps designed to make the most of a player’s tools. Here, there are plenty of rooftops and open windows for players to double-jump onto and through, and while it’s still not the fast-paced carnival of boosting and spider-climbing that advertisements may trick you into thinking it is, it’s at least far better about giving players versatility and freedom than the campaign is. Plus, it’s quite satisfying to double-jump above an opponent and then slam down. Tough to do, but delightful.
Everybody gets a double-jump, in addition to temporary boosts provided by their EXO, such as a burst of extra running speed, enhanced health regeneration, or a deployable shield. While a fun idea, EXO abilities feel almost universally useless. I can see anybody with a cloaking device activated, for example, because their outline is pathetically obvious. Similarly, the health regen makes absolutely no difference in a game where getting shot and dying are almost always concurrent events. These EXO abilities are a prime example of CoD‘s wider issue – the need to evolve the series, but the unwillingness to create anything meaningful and game-changing. Stuff that exists simply so the game can say, “See? I did something different, almost!”
Without these trinkets, that classic Calladooty blueprint is adhered to without fail. You march into the usual match types, most likely armed with the more standard rifles, SMGs, and shotguns, because they’re far more reliable than any of the “advanced” stuff, and you blast away while leveling up to get more perks, weapon attachments, and guns. Scorestreaks provide vaguely sci-fi takes on familiar rewards, with UAVs, gun turrets, and “Warbirds” all in attendance, joined by attack drones and mech suits that turn you into a terrifying walking tank.
One thing I enjoy is the character customization. As well as gender, one can mix and match armor types, adding helmets, gloves, leg-guards, and EXO designs. New costume pieces are provided by Supply Drops, which are awarded to players as they go through the multiplayer. Drops provide random outfit pieces of assorted rarity, and it’s kept me more invested than the usual ranking and weapon/perk system has. My worry is that this has been designed for microtransactions later on, a fear emphasized by the “Shop” option right there in the online menu, as well as the fact that some outfit parts (those you obtain via challenges) expire after a limited time. It could all be innocuous, but it’s an environment ripe for “monetization.”
As a writer, I’m trying to cut down on the amount of lazy descriptive words everybody else uses, but it’s really difficult to not describe this all as “solid.” It’s nothing to write home about, but it’s not exactly terrible. It’s simply another Call of Duty for another year, tiding over bullet lovers until next November. It’s all put together nicely. It works. When you do well you feel pretty good. My heart’s just not in it, though. The Warriors games do more to freshen themselves up than the meager edging forward Call of Duty‘s been doing, and after playing a new one of these every year since 2007, I just can’t get excited for this stuff anymore.
Really, that’s Advanced Warfare all over. A crawl toward something different when it needs a leap. It’s not even making any strides in the presentation department, with all its Hollywood bombast looking both technically and artistically dated. It’s familiar CoD visuals, except it occasionally rips off The Matrix.
Call of Duty presided as king over an entire generation. It is now Robert Baratheon, old and tired and surrounded by hungry contenders, having fathered a dozen bastards and now living off the glory of a time when it was young, ambitious, and able to change the world. The sad fact is, the limp half-effort to “advance” the gameplay only highlights how archaic it’s become, copying ideas from newer games, but miring those ideas in antiquity.
Still, Kevin Spacey though!
Bottom Line: Call of Duty: Advanced Warfare upholds the status quo and aims no higher than that. Its sci-fi trappings are but shallow appeals to progress, and while the multiplayer is still able to provide some entertainment, the CoD formula feels anything but “advanced” these days.
Recommendation: Hold X to pay respects.[rating=3]