Five Features Left on the BioShock Drawing Board

image

Fans of BioShock and System Shock 2 should check out “Five Cut Features,” a look back at some of the more interesting gameplay elements that came close to being included in Irrational’s two biggest hits.

It’s not something that most of us think about, but videogame greatness is often achieved almost as much by what developers leave out as what they include. Doom is a great example of that: The original concept included a coherent story, multiple characters, cut scenes and more, whereas the final result was a stripped-down, “pure” FPS experience that became one of the most influential games in history. That refinement process is something that virtually every game goes through and as Irrational reveals in “Five Cut Features,” there’s usually a good reason for it.

Ever wonder why the guns in System Shock 2 broke down so quickly? (If your answer is “no,” then you’ve obviously never played the game.) That great mystery was one audio log away from being explained and, according to the report, was discussed so often that some members of the development team actually thought it had been included. BioShock, meanwhile, came close to employing an “atmospheric pressure system” that sounds interesting as a concept but would have been an absolute train wreck in execution.

And then there’s the infamous BioShock hacking. “Machines that seemed mechanical on the surface would actually have mutated humans operating them behind the scenes – something that players would only come to realize partway through the game,” said designer Alexx Kay. “There is a small remnant of this notion in the hacking mini-game; originally, the fiction behind it was that you were increasing the flow of Adam to this addicted, mutated slave, and he was giving you extra benefits in gratitude.”

It’s a lot of fun to read and also a bit of an insight into the countless decisions that go into the process of taking a game from a rough concept to a finished product. Not everyone will agree with every choice, but some things are quite clearly best left on the drawing board – Nav-Bot, I’m looking at you. Read about all “five cut features” at irrationalgames.com. (And for the record, I thought the weapon degradation mechanic in System Shock 2 worked just fine.)

related content
Read Article Players Are Losing Their Minds Over MW3’s Error Apocalypse
A player running in MW3. This image is part of an article about what clean kills are in MW3.
Read Article Borderlands Trailer Shows Off the Movie’s Star-Studded Cast
Still from the Borderlands trailer.
Read Article Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree Gets First Gameplay Trailer, Release Date
Elden Ring release date
Read Article Nintendo Announces New Rare Games for Switch Online
Switch Online Rare games
Read Article Capcom Apologizes for Street Fighter 5’s Terrible Launch
Street Fighter 5 launch
Related Content
Read Article Players Are Losing Their Minds Over MW3’s Error Apocalypse
A player running in MW3. This image is part of an article about what clean kills are in MW3.
Read Article Borderlands Trailer Shows Off the Movie’s Star-Studded Cast
Still from the Borderlands trailer.
Read Article Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree Gets First Gameplay Trailer, Release Date
Elden Ring release date
Read Article Nintendo Announces New Rare Games for Switch Online
Switch Online Rare games
Read Article Capcom Apologizes for Street Fighter 5’s Terrible Launch
Street Fighter 5 launch